Lenses for photographing storms

Digby22
Posted 16/03/2008 - 11:56 Link
I am quite new to photography so apologies for incorrect terms.

In May I am going on a storm chasing holiday in the States (Texas, Kansas, Oklahoma, Colarado) and want to photograph the storms which will consist dark cloud formations, lightning and, hopefully, tornadoes.

What lenses would people recommend for this kind of photography?

After taking a look at some landscape, lightning and sky photos it seems that most are shot a low ISO with a short or medium lense. It looks to me that the shorter focal lengths (10-20mm) are marginally the more professional (compared to, say, 50mm on a 18-55mm lense). Anyone have any thoughts on this?

Also, do I need a polarizer and how will it help?

Thanks for any help!

John

PS I have just bought a K20D with the 16-45mm lense. I also own old manual 50mm and 120mm primes with my MX film camera (which I have been learning photography on).
Mannesty
Posted 16/03/2008 - 12:05 Link
Welcome to the forum.

Can I just correct one error before we start? Lens is spelled "lens", not lense, a common mistake for which I can forgive you . . . once.

Your ideal lens will be one suitable for landscape work, anywhere in the 10 to 50mm zoom range. Additionally, in storm conditions such as you hope to experience, there isn't much light due to the dense clouds so it also ideally needs to be fast. Shooting at anything up to 400 ISO should be good. Getting the exposure right might be a challenge too.

Lens recommendations: SMCP-DA 12-24mm, SMCP-DA 16-45mm (which you already have) SMCP-DA* 16-50mm 1:2.8 (my choice). I have no personal experience of it but folks here favour the Sigma 10-20mm for a wide angle zoom.

Polariser will probably not be needed as you'll not be seeing many reflections to remove or colours to enrich.

Shoot RAW, it'll give you more latitude to correct errors when you get back than if you were to save in JPG format. Take plenty of cards.

Good luck, enjoy the experience, and post some pics here when you get back.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
johnriley
Posted 16/03/2008 - 12:07 Link
Welcome to the forum.

It depends on what sort of distance you will be photographing the storms from. I can imagine both distant images of raging storms that might need a long lens and also closer ones where you would want the sky in and would need a wide angle.

The 16-45mm is a fine lens and will serve well close up, so perhaps you could consider the inexpensive SMC Pentax-DA 50-200mm, a great lens at such a modest price.

If there is a lot of grit and debris in the air then I would suggest a protective filter, probably a UV or Skylight. I don't normally use filters with digital cameras, but in this instance it might be a good idea to protect the lens front element.

A polariser would remove reflections from water and foliage and darken blue skies so I'm not sure it would be needed here. The 2.5 stops reduction in light would not be helpful anyway.

I would start with highest quality JPEG setting at perhaps ISO 200 and you should be able to cover most things.

Incidentally, a wide angle lens is not "more professional" but the skilled photographer might be more to the point. A professional calibre lens, such as your 16-45mm is of the highest optical and mechanical quality to stand up to constant use, but without the photographer's input it won't take better photos.

Hope that helps!
Best regards, John
ikillrocknroll
Posted 16/03/2008 - 12:34 Link
I would personally use the Sigma 10-20 and then a prime around the 100mm mark, just to capture the details in the distance; but if your near the storm, you probably wouldnt want to change lens

Wide angle would be my choice anyway.
http://www.behance.net/robbranigan
K20D, DA18-55II, FA50 1.4, DA10-17
To buy: Metz 58 AF-1, DA*50-135, DA12-24, DA100M
Digby22
Posted 16/03/2008 - 12:39 Link
Thanks very much for your replies! I'm quite amazed at the speed.

johnriley: Good to know that the lens have already seems to be suitable.

I will be shooting from about 100m to about 2 miles from the storm. I guess I will need a longer lens for the bigger distances - I'll look at your recommended 50-200mm, but I am also tempted by the DA* model because of the weather sealing.

Mannesty: it looks like I need to get some exposure practice in beforehand - still learning the basics on the K20d. Any advice on what setting to prioritise? I am going to look at the short lenses you recommend.

Cheers!

John

PS About the "lense" spelling - I always assumed it was a UK / US English spelling difference but now I look I can't find it spelt "lense" anywhere, so you must be right.
johnriley
Posted 16/03/2008 - 12:49 Link
Lens is definitely spelt "lens" and always has been, but I have noticed on the web that the "e" is often added on the end.

I think this may be because the plural of lens is lenses and a simple spelling error has caught on to some degree.

Either way though, we know what you mean.
Best regards, John
iceblinker
Posted 16/03/2008 - 14:23 Link
A decent low-cost telephoto zoom that is faster at 200mm (F4.5) than the Pentax DA 50-200mm (F5.6) is the Tamron AF 70-300mm LD Di. Find the review at www.photozone.de/Reviews/Pentax%20Lens%20Tests

"Lense" is listed as a variant of "lens" in Merriam-Webster's Medical Dictionary - http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/lense
~Pete
JohnMcD
Posted 16/03/2008 - 15:52 Link
I'd consider the two new DA" lenses 16-50 F2.8 and 50-135 F2.8 , they're expensive but optically very good and between them cover the range you'd probably need. Most importantly however they can get a bit wet without any fuss and as the K20D is weather sealed you'd have the ideal combination ! There's also a new DA* 60-250 F4 coming out soon so you might want that instead of the 50-135 if you need more reach.
promhandicam
Posted 16/03/2008 - 19:30 Link
Being 100m from a storm I'd want the heaviest lens possible to stop the whole lot being blown away Good luck with your trip and post some of your photos here when you get back.

Steve
Mannesty
Posted 16/03/2008 - 21:41 Link
Quote:
Any advice on what setting to prioritise?
I can't offer you any advice based on practical experience of your proposed scenario but the normal rules/decisions should apply. If you want to freeze the action (bits of buildings or trees hurtling through the air) then a fast shutter speed and shutter priority might be appropriate. Otherwise use Aperture priority.

My best advice is, if you have the time, experiment. Try using Sensitivity priority, you set the aperture and shutter, the camera selects an appropriate ISO. I would set a range limit to the ISO though, but can't advise what range to set because I don't know what the K20D is capable of . . . because I haven't got one . . . yet .

If it were a K10D I'd set it to be between 100 and 800.

Good luck.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Mongoose
Posted 17/03/2008 - 12:50 Link
Quote:
Digby22 wrote:
Any advice on what setting to prioritise?
Try using Sensitivity priority, you set the aperture and shutter, the camera selects an appropriate ISO. .
Peter, that's good advice but it's not Sv, the mode you are thinking of is TAv (Shutter-Aperture Priority). Sensitivity Priority is you pick the ISO, camera does the rest.

Sorry to be picky, but our new friend has enough things to learn without confusion over which mode he's in
you don't have to be mad to post here



but it does help
gartmore
Posted 17/03/2008 - 21:28 Link
I'm assuming you are going on some sort of guided tour so why not ask your hosts who will have some considerable experience in this field?
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Mannesty
Posted 17/03/2008 - 23:28 Link
Quote:
Mannesty wrote:
Quote:
Any advice on what setting to prioritise?
Try using Sensitivity priority, you set the aperture and shutter, the camera selects an appropriate ISO. .
Peter, that's good advice but it's not Sv, the mode you are thinking of is TAv (Shutter-Aperture Priority). Sensitivity Priority is you pick the ISO, camera does the rest.

Sorry to be picky, but our new friend has enough things to learn without confusion over which mode he's in
You're right to be picky, I made a mistake. Thanks for the correction. TAv (Shutter & Aperture priority) mode is what I was thinking of. I got the right mode, wrong name.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
promhandicam
Posted 17/03/2008 - 23:43 Link
Quote:
In May I am going on a storm chasing holiday in the States (Texas, Kansas, Oklahoma, Colarado) and want to photograph the storms which will consist dark cloud formations, lightning and, hopefully, tornadoes.
I've just posted a couple of my efforts here from this evening with the lessons learnt. I'm certainly no expert and having never been to the US can only comment on my experience of tropical storms in Africa.

Cheers,

Steve
Digby22
Posted 21/03/2008 - 09:03 Link
Thanks for all your replies. I think I am tending towards the 16-50 DA* as a first step. However, I have the 16-45 so it would be quite a big cost to get similar functionality.

What I am wondering is, how does the 16-45 (or any other non weather proof lens) cope with rain?

Do you use extra protection when photographing in rain?

It might seem like an obvious question, but I have never taken pictures in anything more than spitting.

Cheers

John

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo