Lens Test Charts

Algernon
Posted 26/08/2010 - 21:44 Link
It's the way all the mags test lenses Ken also all the sites on the internet. Please stop complicating matters. The BBC like to waste Licence payers money. Period

I've worked in industries where we have had to put in large concrete bases and 50m long concrete vertical piles and raker piles to stop very tiny movements. A tripod for what we are talking about just needs to stop a certain amount of movement/vibration. There is a thread on the other forum about that and it mentions (amonst other things) how to bring any tripod up to "Class A" spec. by attaching a fairly heavy block of iron.

The thread I'm referring to covers testing of the SR on the K-7 and has found flaws which have been relayed back to Pentax Japan. They have used a Class A tripod in the testing. So lets leave it at that. We are doing very very simple tests at a maximum of 87.5 lpmm, hardly rocket science
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber

Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff

Algi
Anvh
Posted 26/08/2010 - 22:03 Link
Algernon wrote:
Thanks Stefan, I'll read through that tomorrow, but that's not as high as the resolution I'm talking about. Zeiss have managed 400lpmm on film (which is really tiny 0.0025mm). This site gives the maximum digital resolution as 87.5lpmm which means the testing setup doesn't need to be anything more than a decent tripod. Normal film testing used to yield 120-140lpmm again with just a decent tripod.
Didn't knew that about Zeiss, very intersting.

About the maximum for digital if you read further you see it's the resolving power of the 40D and not the smallest that's possible for digital.
Also when you read even further he is saying you can't actually calculate it that way because more is going on so it's even less.

This a very detailed article about maximum sharpness of the lens and when a sensor out resolve it. link

Grain vs pixels link

And why we shouldn't/can't compare film and digital link

More then enough to keep you busy for the day
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Edited by Anvh: 26/08/2010 - 22:04
Dangermouse
Posted 26/08/2010 - 23:40 Link
To be quite honest I find a brick wall in good light wide open and at f8 is a good test. You can tell how sharp the lens is and how it renders colours.
Matt

Shooting the Welsh Wilderness with K-m, KX, MX, ME Super and assorted lenses.
flossie
Posted 27/08/2010 - 09:04 Link
I did a print-out of that AP test chart on a reasonably high-quality laser printer. To the naked eye I can see moire patterns and aliasing errors in the diagonal lines. So I'd say its of little use for testing a domestic lens.

I might have a go at printing it on my A1 printer instead I suppose...
Still shooting in the dark (literally and metaphorically)...
Algernon
Posted 27/08/2010 - 10:24 Link
Thanks Stefan, the whole business of lens testing is far too complex for people like us who just want to see if a 300mm A* is sharper than a 300 FA*, that's why I only photograph a £10 note and take at least 4 shots at each aperture and pick out the best, (because of focusing difficulties). I might start using Live View for focusing. See this site for why?

A brick wall is ideal if you have one that you can set up square to and at the right distance and it's not raining, and the light doesn't vary throughout the test I sometimes use a Burgular alarm box about 30m away.

Flossie I wouldn't bother with the AP chart. It's partly copied off the Patterson chart which had 4 colour blocks R G B and Black all on a white background. On digital you can't read off the resolution f/2.8 and f/8 look the same? On film you have to use a microscope to read it it's so small. The colours do show that digital is poor on red but improves as you stop down. Excellent on green and blue, which is probably why night shots taken at the Bluhour look very sharp.
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber

Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff

Algi
greynolds999
Posted 27/08/2010 - 17:33 Link
The reason you are seeing alising errors with the AP chart is because it has been stored as a bitmap, therefore the moiré patterns can never be removed.

The Cornell one is saved as a vector diagram, so the bigger you print it the better it will be. The PDF is here.
sportyman531
Posted 29/01/2013 - 23:25 Link
Setting your camera up square on to the subject is not as easy as it sounds, it can be out in any plane and how do you measure it for accuracy?

Steve
Flickr
DA AL 35mm f2.4, K3,18-135 WR, DA 55-300, Pentax KX, K5 x 2, 18-50 50-200 kit lenses, Tamron 17-50 f2.8, Fuji X10, 2x Mamiya 1000s 2x 80mm f2.8, 150mm f3.5, 210mm f4, Yashica 124G TLR, 2x Yashica FX3 Super 2000, Tamron 28mm f2.8, 90mm SP f2.5, 135mm f2.5, Olympus 35RC, 2x Yashica FX2, Kodak Pocket Instamatic, Kodak Box Brownie
pentaxian450
Posted 30/01/2013 - 00:24 Link
gartmore wrote:
The only lens charts I have ever seen in meaningful use (a BBC camera maintenance workshop) was where the chart stand and the camera stand were cast steel and both bolted to a concrete floor.
Unfortunately, given the resolution of TV cameras, that set up is completely useless. Just another way to waste taxpayers money.
Yves (another one of those crazy Canucks)
Algernon
Posted 30/01/2013 - 09:04 Link
sportyman531 wrote:
Setting your camera up square on to the subject is not as easy as it sounds, it can be out in any plane and how do you measure it for accuracy?

Steve
If it's indoors the walls are usually square so just set the
camera the same distance off the sidewall and floor that the CL of the
chart is.

Postage stamps (Irish ones off ebay are quite detailed) make
good test targets.

The most important part is getting the focus right. Live
View is the best way, but it's more accurate to use a
focus rack and take shots say every 10mm on either side
of the LV focus. Alternatively put the target on a box
and move that. You can't rotate the focus ring on the
lens by the equivalent of 10mm.

Very few people testing lenses on the net actually get the
focus right and that makes the whole test useless

This (shot of a can which I use to check LV focus because
the dots on the side look like they move as you focus)
shows correct focus on the left and moved back by
only 7mm on the right, so even 7mm makes a big difference.
The shot is front focused.

Comment Image


90mm Macro lens at f/2.8 50% crop. You can see it
better at 100% but I've had to reduce the size to
800w to post here.

Distance 1050mm LED Daylight lighting.

The can isn't much use as a resolution test. I
use it just to test my focus.

Accurate focus of a single shot with just a camera and
lens is IMPOSSIBLE. You have to focus bracket.
DOF helps to make it look better and the luck/statistics
of getting say 1 in 4 right also helps.


-
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber

Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff

Algi
Edited by Algernon: 30/01/2013 - 09:21
petrochemist
Posted 30/01/2013 - 10:24 Link
Algernon wrote:
Thanks Stefan, the whole business of lens testing is far too complex for people like us who just want to see if a 300mm A* is sharper than a 300 FA*, that's why I only photograph a £10 note and take at least 4 shots at each aperture and pick out the best, (because of focusing difficulties). I might start using Live View for focusing. See this site for why?
Algi as MrCynical pointed out Photographing british banknotes is illegal without permission (not too difficult to get - but it expires after a year) Your much better off using Euros - the European bank has a list of conditions on it's website, if you stick within them you have permission.
IIRC as long as you're not photographing the whole note, and don't put high resolution shots on line you should be OK.
Mike
.
Pentax:K5ii, K7, K100D, DA18-55, DA10-17, DA55-300, DA50-200, F100-300, F50, DA35 AL, 4* M50, 2* M135, Helicoid extension, Tak 300 f4 (& 6 film bodies)
3rd Party: Bigmos (Sigma 150-500mm OS HSM),2* 28mm, 100mm macro, 28-200 zoom, 35-80 zoom, 80-200 zoom, 80-210 zoom, 300mm M42, 600 mirror, 1000-4000 scope, 50mm M42, enlarger lenses, Sony & micro 4/3 cameras with various PK mounts, Zenit E...
Far to many tele-converters, adapters, project parts & extension tubes etc.

.[size=11:].Flickr• WPF• Panoramio
gartmore
Posted 30/01/2013 - 10:44 Link
pentaxian450 wrote:
gartmore wrote:
The only lens charts I have ever seen in meaningful use (a BBC camera maintenance workshop) was where the chart stand and the camera stand were cast steel and both bolted to a concrete floor.
Unfortunately, given the resolution of TV cameras, that set up is completely useless. Just another way to waste taxpayers money.
you are very quick to jump to conclusions, i never mentioned TV cameras.
For the record it is 35 and 16mm motion picture cameras using Zeiss Distagon f1 lenses and the BBC isnt funded by taxpayers. You are also commenting on a three year old post.
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Algernon
Posted 30/01/2013 - 11:16 Link
petrochemist wrote:
Algi as MrCynical pointed out Photographing british banknotes is illegal without permission (not too difficult to get - but it expires after a year) Your much better off using Euros - the European bank has a list of conditions on it's website, if you stick within them you have permission.
IIRC as long as you're not photographing the whole note, and don't put high resolution shots on line you should be OK.
I only used to photograph a very small portion of the note, but now
use postage stamps instead. Most editors such as PS and Corel won't
let you import a photo of a UK banknote.
I think Dollar Bills are OK and they can be bought off ebay.
Or old banknotes from former communist now European
countries.

Strange thing is ebay is full of photos of UK banknotes
just search for it

For testing lenses at about 1M we aren't recording
much fine detail anyway.

Irish postage stamps have a lot of detail and are cheap on ebay.
example

-
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber

Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff

Algi
Edited by Algernon: 30/01/2013 - 11:28
JAK
Posted 17/03/2013 - 00:56 Link
Algernon wrote:
Strange thing is ebay is full of photos of UK banknotes
just search for it
All I could see is a few obsolete ones.

Why resurrect a three year old thread?

John K
John K

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo