Lens Defect Survey
Posted 08/02/2010 - 16:19
Link
I have bought 7 Sigma lenses - all have been excellent....still have 3 of them - the others have been sold to liberate room in the camera bag.
Z-1p, K-1, P50
F50 1.7. SMC-FAs 24, 35, 50 1.4, 85, 135. HD-FA15-30, DFA24-70, D-FA*70-200. The SMC-FA Limited Trinity.
Metz 45 CL-4, AF500FTZ. AF540FGZ.
Some Mamiya and some Nikon, and a Canon T70.
F50 1.7. SMC-FAs 24, 35, 50 1.4, 85, 135. HD-FA15-30, DFA24-70, D-FA*70-200. The SMC-FA Limited Trinity.
Metz 45 CL-4, AF500FTZ. AF540FGZ.
Some Mamiya and some Nikon, and a Canon T70.
Posted 08/02/2010 - 19:02
Link
I am being driven up the wall by this lens failure business. I am convinced it has been blown out of all proportion. Not so much here, but on other forums (you know the ones - birding lens = FA50 on six TCs :wink they are convinced that if you buy an SDM lens it will explode and kill you. The really worrying stat. was that 20% (of those who answered) said they had not had one and would not even consider trying one.
I suspect this is the result of a few failures and a vocal minority over there. After all who shouts "Mine hasn't broken".
I suspect this is the result of a few failures and a vocal minority over there. After all who shouts "Mine hasn't broken".
Posted 08/02/2010 - 19:24
Link
I've had no failures with one of mine lenses.
About the SDM, there are quite some users here with an SDM lens and I've only heard 3 or 4 times that someone had a problem with one so all in all that isn't that bad.
I believe someone said most problems occur during rough handling during shipping, the align seems to be quite critical.
This only hear say though so don't hang me on it
About the SDM, there are quite some users here with an SDM lens and I've only heard 3 or 4 times that someone had a problem with one so all in all that isn't that bad.
I believe someone said most problems occur during rough handling during shipping, the align seems to be quite critical.
This only hear say though so don't hang me on it
Posted 08/02/2010 - 23:56
Link
johnriley wrote:
I would suspect that these results are very skewed. The idea that out of 5 lenses at best the chance of one of them being faulty was as high as 40% is dreadful.
I can see that with the complexity of modern lenses the chance of a fault must be higher than with a manual focus lens, but even so....
Very true, but it seems as though it is one of the best of all the brands, according to this survey snippet.I would suspect that these results are very skewed. The idea that out of 5 lenses at best the chance of one of them being faulty was as high as 40% is dreadful.
I can see that with the complexity of modern lenses the chance of a fault must be higher than with a manual focus lens, but even so....
Quote:
And then we see the Sigma result...
Which proves my point.
And then we see the Sigma result...
Cameras:K-7/K20D/*ist D/K10D
Lenses:DA14 f2.8, A16 f2.8, FA20 f2.8, FA31 f1.8, DA35 f2.8 macro, FA43 f1.9, FA50 f1.4, A50 f1.4, A50 f1.2, FA50 f2.8 macro, DA*55 f1.4, FA77 f1.8, DFA100 f2.8 macro, A100 f2.8, DA*300 f4, FA*300 f4.5, DA10-17 FE, DA12-24 f4, DA*16-50 f2.8, DA17-70 f4, FA*28-70 f2.8, DA*50-135 f2.8, DA*60-250 f4, FA*80-200 f2.8.
Flashes:AF540FGZ, AF360FGZ
Lenses:DA14 f2.8, A16 f2.8, FA20 f2.8, FA31 f1.8, DA35 f2.8 macro, FA43 f1.9, FA50 f1.4, A50 f1.4, A50 f1.2, FA50 f2.8 macro, DA*55 f1.4, FA77 f1.8, DFA100 f2.8 macro, A100 f2.8, DA*300 f4, FA*300 f4.5, DA10-17 FE, DA12-24 f4, DA*16-50 f2.8, DA17-70 f4, FA*28-70 f2.8, DA*50-135 f2.8, DA*60-250 f4, FA*80-200 f2.8.
Flashes:AF540FGZ, AF360FGZ
Posted 08/02/2010 - 23:57
Link
hefty1 wrote:
It's skewed because most people who find that survey probably got there by Googling "Sigma+lens+faulty" (substitute manufacturer of choice). Therefore a disproportionate number of response will come from folk who have had problems and were searching for solutions.
But then you know what they say about lies, damn lies and statistics...
I couldn't agree more, but he does cover this in his "results page":It's skewed because most people who find that survey probably got there by Googling "Sigma+lens+faulty" (substitute manufacturer of choice). Therefore a disproportionate number of response will come from folk who have had problems and were searching for solutions.
But then you know what they say about lies, damn lies and statistics...
The data presented here is based on the Lens Defect Survey. No survey is 100% reliable and as someone once may have said 'There are lies, damned lies, and statistics' (Mark Twain quoting Benjamin Disraeli). So be aware that:
•First the survey doesn't sample random users. It samples users who were directed here from one of two or three other websites.
•Second it doesn't sample all users, only those motivated to fill in the survey.
•Third, some people like to mess with surveys and give bogus data. While efforts have been made to detect and eliminate obviously bogus data, it can't all be eliminated.
•Fourth, it's possible that people with complaints are more likely to be motivated to leave their data than those who are happy with their lenses.
•Fifth, there is no differentiation here between cheap Photographic lenses and expensive lenses. You might expect cheap SLR lenses to have lower quality control and perhaps a higher numbers of defects, but on the other hand you might expect buyers of expensive SLR lenses to be more critical and so find more defects!
Cameras:K-7/K20D/*ist D/K10D
Lenses:DA14 f2.8, A16 f2.8, FA20 f2.8, FA31 f1.8, DA35 f2.8 macro, FA43 f1.9, FA50 f1.4, A50 f1.4, A50 f1.2, FA50 f2.8 macro, DA*55 f1.4, FA77 f1.8, DFA100 f2.8 macro, A100 f2.8, DA*300 f4, FA*300 f4.5, DA10-17 FE, DA12-24 f4, DA*16-50 f2.8, DA17-70 f4, FA*28-70 f2.8, DA*50-135 f2.8, DA*60-250 f4, FA*80-200 f2.8.
Flashes:AF540FGZ, AF360FGZ
Lenses:DA14 f2.8, A16 f2.8, FA20 f2.8, FA31 f1.8, DA35 f2.8 macro, FA43 f1.9, FA50 f1.4, A50 f1.4, A50 f1.2, FA50 f2.8 macro, DA*55 f1.4, FA77 f1.8, DFA100 f2.8 macro, A100 f2.8, DA*300 f4, FA*300 f4.5, DA10-17 FE, DA12-24 f4, DA*16-50 f2.8, DA17-70 f4, FA*28-70 f2.8, DA*50-135 f2.8, DA*60-250 f4, FA*80-200 f2.8.
Flashes:AF540FGZ, AF360FGZ
Posted 08/02/2010 - 23:58
Link
Oggy wrote:
I am being driven up the wall by this lens failure business. I am convinced it has been blown out of all proportion. Not so much here, but on other forums (you know the ones - birding lens = FA50 on six TCs :wink they are convinced that if you buy an SDM lens it will explode and kill you. The really worrying stat. was that 20% (of those who answered) said they had not had one and would not even consider trying one.
I suspect this is the result of a few failures and a vocal minority over there. After all who shouts "Mine hasn't broken".
Right on the money!
I am being driven up the wall by this lens failure business. I am convinced it has been blown out of all proportion. Not so much here, but on other forums (you know the ones - birding lens = FA50 on six TCs :wink they are convinced that if you buy an SDM lens it will explode and kill you. The really worrying stat. was that 20% (of those who answered) said they had not had one and would not even consider trying one.
I suspect this is the result of a few failures and a vocal minority over there. After all who shouts "Mine hasn't broken".
Cameras:K-7/K20D/*ist D/K10D
Lenses:DA14 f2.8, A16 f2.8, FA20 f2.8, FA31 f1.8, DA35 f2.8 macro, FA43 f1.9, FA50 f1.4, A50 f1.4, A50 f1.2, FA50 f2.8 macro, DA*55 f1.4, FA77 f1.8, DFA100 f2.8 macro, A100 f2.8, DA*300 f4, FA*300 f4.5, DA10-17 FE, DA12-24 f4, DA*16-50 f2.8, DA17-70 f4, FA*28-70 f2.8, DA*50-135 f2.8, DA*60-250 f4, FA*80-200 f2.8.
Flashes:AF540FGZ, AF360FGZ
Lenses:DA14 f2.8, A16 f2.8, FA20 f2.8, FA31 f1.8, DA35 f2.8 macro, FA43 f1.9, FA50 f1.4, A50 f1.4, A50 f1.2, FA50 f2.8 macro, DA*55 f1.4, FA77 f1.8, DFA100 f2.8 macro, A100 f2.8, DA*300 f4, FA*300 f4.5, DA10-17 FE, DA12-24 f4, DA*16-50 f2.8, DA17-70 f4, FA*28-70 f2.8, DA*50-135 f2.8, DA*60-250 f4, FA*80-200 f2.8.
Flashes:AF540FGZ, AF360FGZ
Posted 09/02/2010 - 01:43
Link
Added my 5 lenses with zero defects and Pentax are still in the lead. The Pentax, Nikon and Canon failure rates are very similar, as I expected, but not what you would expect if you spend much time over on Depressing Review
Posted 09/02/2010 - 21:54
Link
I don't own any SDM lenses and I'm not likely to in the future (for cost, rather than reliability, reasons) so it doesn't personally affect me, but Pentax could kill this issue (whatever its merits or otherwise) stone dead by doing a specific extended warranty on SDM failure like Microsoft did with the Xbox 'ring of death'.
Posted 09/02/2010 - 23:13
Link
But it isn't an issue, so no need to kill it.
G
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 10/02/2010 - 00:47
Link
George Lazarette wrote:
But it isn't an issue, so no need to kill it.
G
It’s hard to say if it’s a ‘real’ issue or not – nobody outside Pentax has access to the relevant data, but the perception that it is an issue is definitely out there.But it isn't an issue, so no need to kill it.
G
The more components added to any system will increase the probability of failure, although I doubt it’s any more of an issue than lenses from other marks. But there is a very vocal group who appear to take every opportunity to make it a ‘Pentax only’ problem ignoring the facts that lenses from other makes also fail.
I do think that it would be to Pentax‘s advantage to make some moves to counter the negative publicity that is being generated. If Pentax is confident of the technology and design then offering an extended warranty should not cost them much anyway. After all the DA* series are sold as top flight pro lenses and for such a high premium that Pentax demands for the lenses it’s not unreasonable for users to expect them to make some gesture of faith in the quality of its flagship products.
Posted 10/02/2010 - 08:20
Link
Two year guarantee from Pro Dealers seems pretty positive to me. Plus of course EU and especially UK consumer protection for maybe up to 6 years.
Best regards, John
Posted 10/02/2010 - 12:48
Link
johnriley wrote:
Two year guarantee from Pro Dealers seems pretty positive to me. Plus of course EU and especially UK consumer protection for maybe up to 6 years.
John - You've hit the nail squarely on the head!
Two year guarantee from Pro Dealers seems pretty positive to me. Plus of course EU and especially UK consumer protection for maybe up to 6 years.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



4018 posts
19 years
Buckinghamshire,
UK
But then you know what they say about lies, damn lies and statistics...