K5IIs versus K5

McGregNi
Posted 14/02/2016 - 12:01 Link
Assessments via monitor screens, especially of 'web-sized' jpegs will always be fraught by inconsistency. The resizing algorithm applied for that final jpeg version may well be the overriding determining factor, and certainly RAW ' capture sharpening', which will be as varied as the number of programmes and profile set-ups used by everyone, can have it's influence.

I've never denied that taken to the ultimate extreme through a processing workflow then the non AA filtered image will prove to have a significant edge in clarity .... But very few of us have the need for such a highly optimised output, which is probably only needed for larger exhibition prints.

Going back to Steve's point earlier ... Surely the results of moving from a lesser lens to a premium * type lens will have far more visual impact on ones photography than a move to an AA filterless sensor .... ?
My Guides to the Pentax Digital Camera Flash Lighting System : Download here from the PentaxForums Homepage Article .... link
Pentax K7 with BG-4 Grip / Samyang 14mm f2.8 ED AS IF UMC / DA18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL WR / SMC A28mm f2.8 / D FA 28-105mm / SMC F35-70 f3.5-4.5 / SMC A50mm f1.7 / Tamron AF70-300mm f4-5.6 Di LD macro / SMC M75-150mm f4.0 / Tamron Adaptall (CT-135) 135mm f2.8 / Asahi Takumar-A 2X tele-converter / Pentax AF-540FGZ (I & II) Flashes / Cactus RF60/X Flashes & V6/V6II Transceiver
Edited by McGregNi: 14/02/2016 - 12:06
Algernon
Posted 14/02/2016 - 12:29 Link
Yes the lens is very important, but if you pixel peep very few lenses are good at the edges and will be better on one side than the other...... You can't actually see this when you reduce down to monitor size.

I once tested this theory with a crude merge of the best parts two shots and a full shot with a lens that was poor on the left. Hardly any difference at monitor size and even the dodgy join was almost invisible.

--
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber

Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff

Algi
SteveEveritt
Posted 14/02/2016 - 12:42 Link
The fact is, the AA filter was applied to create blur which would prevent the fabled moire (that's the moire that so rarely appears it's not worth bothering to prevent) that post process sharpening was then needed to correct.
I have a K-5iis and had a loan K-5 from SRS (my K-3 needed repairing) and running the two bodies side by side there was an obvious and pronounced improvement in sharpness with the iis that could only be achieved with PP using the 5.
Flickr
"Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans" (John Lennon)
Edited by SteveEveritt: 14/02/2016 - 12:45
McGregNi
Posted 14/02/2016 - 12:47 Link
Agreed, and the debate about whether an AA filter is now required is a different one again. It seems that the latest and highest resolution sensors reduce the occurrence of moire in many situations.

The old question and debate was about a very direct choice we were given with two camera versions ... And the 100 pound difference in price that involved.
My Guides to the Pentax Digital Camera Flash Lighting System : Download here from the PentaxForums Homepage Article .... link
Pentax K7 with BG-4 Grip / Samyang 14mm f2.8 ED AS IF UMC / DA18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL WR / SMC A28mm f2.8 / D FA 28-105mm / SMC F35-70 f3.5-4.5 / SMC A50mm f1.7 / Tamron AF70-300mm f4-5.6 Di LD macro / SMC M75-150mm f4.0 / Tamron Adaptall (CT-135) 135mm f2.8 / Asahi Takumar-A 2X tele-converter / Pentax AF-540FGZ (I & II) Flashes / Cactus RF60/X Flashes & V6/V6II Transceiver
Algernon
Posted 14/02/2016 - 13:40 Link
This lens test taken with a KiiS and 12-24mm that's poor on the RHS shows that a good body isn't much use if the lens is bad..... see barge shot (bottom/right) large and normal versions.

https://www.pentaxuser.com/review/pentax-smc-p-da-12-24mm-f-4-0-ed-al-lens-revie...

--
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber

Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff

Algi
judderman62
Posted 14/02/2016 - 22:12 Link
davidstorm wrote:
I was one of those involved in the long discussions about improvements the K-5iis offered over the K-5, yes it is sharper , yes

Regards
David
In your opinion.

I also participated lots in the debate and I have not seen one single comparison where I thought the images taken with the S were even the tiniest bit sharper. Seen a fair few comparison shots and looked at them with glasses (and yes I have my eyes tested every 12 months) , without glasses, usual distance from screen, close up to screen, standing on one leg, squinting a bit funny and have not seen one single comparison where there was even a whisker of difference to my sight.

Emperor's new clothes as far as I'm concerned.
- -
Mike

Pentax K5 / Pentax K5 11/ Pentax K200D / Canon Rebel T1 i / Canon 650D / Pentax MX-1 / Fuji XF1 /Fuji X 10 / Canon EOS-M / Canon G10/ Pentax Mz-7 x 2
judderman62
Posted 14/02/2016 - 22:14 Link
SteveEveritt wrote:
And during that discussion it was pointed out that there is a significant improvement in sharpness akin to upgrading from poor glass to DA* glass and that still stands true.
In some people's opinions, there were others like Smeggy, myself et al who felt the exact opposite.

Additionally if any such perceived difference were indeed significant then surely there's be no debate?
- -
Mike

Pentax K5 / Pentax K5 11/ Pentax K200D / Canon Rebel T1 i / Canon 650D / Pentax MX-1 / Fuji XF1 /Fuji X 10 / Canon EOS-M / Canon G10/ Pentax Mz-7 x 2
davidstorm
Posted 14/02/2016 - 22:27 Link
Anyone who tries to claim a K-5iis is not inherently sharper than a K-5 needs their head examining.

It has no AA filter. AA filters create blur, there can be no disputing this.

End of story.

Cheers
David
Flickr

Nicola's Apartments, Kassiopi, Corfu

Some cameras, some lenses, some bits 'n' bobs
stu62
Posted 14/02/2016 - 23:15 Link
Algernon wrote:
This lens test taken with a KiiS and 12-24mm that's poor on the RHS shows that a good body isn't much use if the lens is bad..... see barge shot (bottom/right) large and normal versions.

https://www.pentaxuser.com/review/pentax-smc-p-da-12-24mm-f-4-0-ed-al-lens-revie...

--


Would love to know when pentax are releasing this camera (about time i got my own back)
johnriley
Posted 14/02/2016 - 23:17 Link
Since the K-5 IIs many camera makers have also taken this on board and today the lack of the AA filter is quite normal. It does have benefits, but the essence of sharpness and resolution needs to be understood.

For example, a Panatomic-X negative film (ISO 32) will show the same detail as a Tri-X one (ISO 400) but the slower film shows it with the individual details rendered more crisply. It's not a perfect analogy, but the K-5 needs more sharpening than the K-5 IIs and files from the latter are indeed visibly sharper. There is still a limitation on this with the 16MP sensor.

The same is true of the pixel shift technology. It renders the detail visibly more crisply, but does require that we work very carefully to get the best advantage from it.

It is accepted by most publications that removing the AA filter increases the crispness of images, and manufacturers have moved in that direction.
Best regards, John
CMW
Posted 14/02/2016 - 23:19 Link
I have to smile at the reigniting of this ancient controversy. It's perhaps the photographic equivalent of asking how many angels can dance on the head of a pin. There will be no consensus, no 'right' or 'wrong', unless the question is drawn so narrowly as to be scarcely worth the asking. The perceived sharpness of a final result, whether on screen or in the form of a print, comes from so many different inputs - of which the sensor and presence or absence of an anti-aliasing filter are but a starting point - that the simple assertion that the K5iis is sharper than the K5, however true, doesn't say much at all.

Some of my K5 images, after processing, using particular lenses, compare commendably well for sharpness with prints achieved on a full-frame camera with over double the pixels and no filter over the sensor. The bigger camera has a native advantage of course, but as I was saying ....
Regards, Christopher

ChristopherWheelerPhotography
McGregNi
Posted 15/02/2016 - 08:28 Link
You're right to phrase it as a ' starting point', and noting David Storms post above where he said 'end of story' ... Well I'd say no, the sensor/AA filter configurations are just the START of the story....

That is why I have constantly approached this from a workflow and processing viewpoint, and there are so many variations to personal techniques and software default profiles that it becomes a very personal question.

Remember we started with this presented as a choice .... One that involved a 100 pound price difference .... And that is why I titled my workflow tests 'New Choice Considerations '.

I believe it is still the case that for most people, given their output needs and personal workflow techniques, that a sensor without AA filter will offer no particular tangible benefit .... Of course, times have moved on and the choice has either gone now or the prices are similar.
My Guides to the Pentax Digital Camera Flash Lighting System : Download here from the PentaxForums Homepage Article .... link
Pentax K7 with BG-4 Grip / Samyang 14mm f2.8 ED AS IF UMC / DA18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL WR / SMC A28mm f2.8 / D FA 28-105mm / SMC F35-70 f3.5-4.5 / SMC A50mm f1.7 / Tamron AF70-300mm f4-5.6 Di LD macro / SMC M75-150mm f4.0 / Tamron Adaptall (CT-135) 135mm f2.8 / Asahi Takumar-A 2X tele-converter / Pentax AF-540FGZ (I & II) Flashes / Cactus RF60/X Flashes & V6/V6II Transceiver
darkskies
Posted 15/02/2016 - 08:42 Link
Well, I don't care what anyone else thinks. I'm right and anyone who disagrees is wrong!
This space deliberately left blank.
womble
Posted 15/02/2016 - 12:32 Link
Personally, I would look at the whole issue differently.

Are you pleased with the results you get from your camera? Yes... good news, carry on snapping. No? Firstly, check your technique (always easiest to blame one's tools). If still no, try a different camera. Everyone's technique, desires, level of acceptability, inside leg measurement is different. Go with whatever works for you. Luckily we have lots of choice (film, digital, Pentax, Nikon, modern * lenses, old glass...) so we should all be able to find something that works for us.

Pretty much everything else is irrelevant.

K.
Kris Lockyear
It is an illusion that photos are made with the camera… they are made with the eye, heart and head. Henri Cartier-Bresson
Lots of film bodies, a couple of digital ones, too many lenses (mainly older glass) and a Horseman LE 5x4.
McGregNi
Posted 15/02/2016 - 12:39 Link
I would say you're looking at it exactly the same as me Kris, which is to put it into a wider context. Taken in isolation, the presence or not of the AA filter on a modern DSLR is going to be of far less significance than many other factors.
My Guides to the Pentax Digital Camera Flash Lighting System : Download here from the PentaxForums Homepage Article .... link
Pentax K7 with BG-4 Grip / Samyang 14mm f2.8 ED AS IF UMC / DA18-55mm f3.5-5.6 AL WR / SMC A28mm f2.8 / D FA 28-105mm / SMC F35-70 f3.5-4.5 / SMC A50mm f1.7 / Tamron AF70-300mm f4-5.6 Di LD macro / SMC M75-150mm f4.0 / Tamron Adaptall (CT-135) 135mm f2.8 / Asahi Takumar-A 2X tele-converter / Pentax AF-540FGZ (I & II) Flashes / Cactus RF60/X Flashes & V6/V6II Transceiver

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo