K10D, D200, D80 & 30D

benjikan
Posted 04/07/2007 - 23:55 Link
Quote:
Quote:
The other thing I garnered was the importance of understanding the latitude of the sensor in regards to extreme highlights to shadow detail.
What did you determine the latitude to be? It'd be interesting to hear your experience on this.

Quote:
I have concluded that without a doubt in my mind, that RAW is the best solution for pulling the best performance out of the Pentax K10D.
Absolutely
And if you haven't tried it yet, Ben, Silkypix Developer Studio gives the most amazing sharpness and colour rendition and control I've seen out of all the RAW converters (pixel peeping or otherwise).

Matt
Hello Matt;

That is a good question. When exposed correctly and using RAW, I can say a spectrum of 9 to 10 stops.

Ben
benjikan
Posted 04/07/2007 - 23:59 Link
Quote:
I to find silkypix excellent but for jpegs especially the AWB and Exposure. If you let silkypix evaluate images they come out very good. The sharpness settings are very good to

Ben you have said its best to shoot RAW with the K10D so does this mean jpegs are far worse with the K10d compared to the other brands. What is your opinion on this ? I have read this to be the case on other forums and reviews but wondered what you thought.

I always shoot jpegs for speed of the buffer always allows more continues shots. Also file size
I know this may sound very weird, but, I have never even tested the K10D in jpeg. I may have tried it once or twice but haven't any precise recollection...Honestly.
Pahrens
Posted 05/07/2007 - 04:20 Link
I agree that the Pentax K10D has great photo quality, but better than all the competitors may be stretching it a tad; The Nikon D80 and D200 take photos of equal quality and maybe better in some instances. They certainly do not use much in camera sharpening.

The metering and auto exposure are brilliant on the D200 and certainly far superior than in the Pentax, I don't need to touch the exposure compensation. However the auto white balance in my Pentax is generally always very close to correct, the D200 rarely is as accurate.

As for Canon and Sony I don't know, but I am sure they are still great cameras.

I am not trying to bash a particular brand I think they are all great, they all have their own weaknesses and strengths. I shoot both Pentax and Nikon and love them both, I can print as large as my wallet allows with either camera and still enjoy the result.
ChrisA
Posted 05/07/2007 - 07:49 Link
Quote:
MattMatic wrote:
Quote:
The other thing I garnered was the importance of understanding the latitude of the sensor in regards to extreme highlights to shadow detail.
What did you determine the latitude to be? It'd be interesting to hear your experience on this.
That is a good question. When exposed correctly and using RAW, I can say a spectrum of 9 to 10 stops.
So do you expose for half way up this range, or is it non-linear?
benjikan
Posted 05/07/2007 - 08:04 Link
Quote:
benjikan wrote:
Quote:
Quote:
The other thing I garnered was the importance of understanding the latitude of the sensor in regards to extreme highlights to shadow detail.
What did you determine the latitude to be? It'd be interesting to hear your experience on this.
That is a good question. When exposed correctly and using RAW, I can say a spectrum of 9 to 10 stops.
So do you expose for half way up this range, or is it non-linear?
As I suggested in another forum:

So much depends on how you are metering the image and your interpretation of that information. I usually try to find the happy medium between the two extremes and find the average, i.e. If the highlight is reading f22.0 and the shadows f5.6 I generally shoot at f11.0. That way I have split the difference and have more latitude when imported in to Adobe RAW and then PS.
ChrisA
Posted 05/07/2007 - 08:15 Link
Quote:
So much depends on how you are metering the image and your interpretation of that information. I usually try to find the happy medium between the two extremes and find the average, i.e. If the highlight is reading f22.0 and the shadows f5.6 I generally shoot at f11.0. That way I have split the difference and have more latitude when imported in to Adobe RAW and then PS.
Thanks for the tip.
benjikan
Posted 05/07/2007 - 08:25 Link
Quote:
benjikan wrote:
So much depends on how you are metering the image and your interpretation of that information. I usually try to find the happy medium between the two extremes and find the average, i.e. If the highlight is reading f22.0 and the shadows f5.6 I generally shoot at f11.0. That way I have split the difference and have more latitude when imported in to Adobe RAW and then PS.
Thanks for the tip.
I hope that helps. Here is one more thing. If you see that the highlight to shadow pendulum is extreme, manually expose for -1/2 to 1.0 stops as well.

Ben
MattMatic
Posted 05/07/2007 - 09:41 Link
Normally I ETTR (Expose To The Right) and try and ensure I don't blow out the highlights but get them as far to the right as possible.

Normally, half the CCD data is in the top 1-stop. But I think Pentax have made their CCD slightly non-linear (more film like) with the 22-bit ADC etc.

It's a shame there isn't a "real RAW" - ie all 22-bits that could be processed. You'd get unbelievable latitude with that (even if only 16 to 18 bits were actually useful)

Matt
http://www.mattmatic.co.uk
(For gallery, tips and links)

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo