K-5IIs - more discussion

davidstorm
Posted 01/03/2013 - 23:27 Link
Hello Philip, thanks for the post. The original intention was to show the comparative noise levels, but I think it turned into more of a debate on the focussing / sharpness (probably my fault). I did try to focus them exactly the same, but I think the two bodies were behaving slightly differently with the same lens attached - not unusual.

I will only know after extended use with the IIs across a range of shooting situations what extent of the difference is, but there is a difference that I can discern, don't forget I have the benefit of seeing full resolution shots both on screen and on prints I've made.

Best wishes
David
Flickr

Nicola's Apartments, Kassiopi, Corfu

Some cameras, some lenses, some bits 'n' bobs
Edited by davidstorm: 01/03/2013 - 23:29
Smeggypants
Posted 02/03/2013 - 00:26 Link
davidstorm wrote:
The IIs image is brighter and sharper all over and has much less noise, particularly so in the areas of red colouring. It also has more shadow detail.

Regards
David
davidstorm wrote:


I think some people refuse to see what is actually there; I will shortly upload a couple at ISO 6400 to see how these compare; I can't pre-judge the outcome as I haven't looked at them yet.

Regards
David
I'm not refusing to see anything.

You claim the K-5IIs is brighter, sharper and has much less noise.

The images you have posted do not show this at all. Looking at both your 6400 images on the same monitor show no difference brightness whatsoever. I even loaded your 6400 images into Lightroom and actually measured the brightness and they were identical.

I can also see no difference in noise, the jpg compression on the images masks anything out anyway.

I did ask if you could upload full size versions of the images, as there's no way these small jogs are supporting your claims.


I would await full sized versions before making any final judgments on noise levels, but the DXOMark peopel have tested these cameras and have found no difference in noise.

http://www.dxomark.com/index.php/Cameras/Compare-Camera-Sensors/Compare-cameras-side-by-side/%28appareil1%29/830|0/%28brand%29/Pentax/%28appareil2%29/676|0/%28brand2%29/Pentax


The comparison images from DPReview and Imaging resources also don't show these differences you claim.



K5_versus_K5IIs at DPreview






.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
Edited by Smeggypants: 02/03/2013 - 00:27
johnriley
Posted 02/03/2013 - 00:34 Link
Beg to differ. I can see the difference. I looked again just now on the iPad 4 and it's obvious, so is it something to do with our respective screens? I can't think of anything else that could affect viewing so much.but am open to ideas.
Best regards, John
Smeggypants
Posted 02/03/2013 - 00:54 Link
johnriley wrote:
Beg to differ. I can see the difference. I looked again just now on the iPad 4 and it's obvious, so is it something to do with our respective screens? I can't think of anything else that could affect viewing so much.but am open to ideas.
I deliberately measured the brightness of each shot in Lightroom to avoid any questions of screens and lightroom. There wasn't any difference.

Several of us here can't see any differences that support David's claims. The tests and comparion images I've linked to above also do not support David's claims.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
Smeggypants
Posted 02/03/2013 - 01:00 Link
I just copied the 6400 comparison images to my Nokia 808 and viewed them on the screen there. Again no difference in brightness sharpness or noise.

These iamges are too small to properly compare the tiny differences in detail between two anyway.

I await the upload of full size images.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
Fletcher8
Posted 02/03/2013 - 03:27 Link
I think the only way people will really appreciate the K5lls is to use one, view the image on a screen and print one. If after all of this people can't see any benefit, well I guess they won't need to part with any money and they can go on using what ever camera they have.

I know a lot of people would prefer MTF charts and specific test conditions but for anyone out there still interested in the K5lls I personally think Jim Radcliffe's Boxed Light may add a little more debate and thought?


http://www.boxedlight.com/K5IIS/index.htm

Anyway i hope you like the images.
Fletcher8.
Smeggypants
Posted 02/03/2013 - 06:14 Link
Fletcher8 wrote:
I think the only way people will really appreciate the K5lls is to use one, view the image on a screen and print one. If after all of this people can't see any benefit, well I guess they won't need to part with any money and they can go on using what ever camera they have.

I know a lot of people would prefer MTF charts and specific test conditions but for anyone out there still interested in the K5lls I personally think Jim Radcliffe's Boxed Light may add a little more debate and thought?


http://www.boxedlight.com/K5IIS/index.htm

Anyway i hope you like the images.
I agree it wouldn't be right to judge the K-5IIs without viewing images taken with it on screen and comparing those images with images taken with other cameras.


Fortunately with the advent of the internet and digital image files it's not necessary to actually physically press a shutter button on a camera in order to view it's images as the person taking1 the picture can distribute them to the entire world in seconds. As David has kindly done in this thread.

See, no one is contending any hands on attributes of the K-5IIs. The improvements in the low light AF of both the K-5II and the K-5IIs aren't being questioned.

People are contending the claimed performance of the K-5IIs by doing exactly what you suggest.. i.e viewing it's images on screen.

My comments about the K-5IIs are based upon viewing many of it's images on screen and comparing them to many many images of the Original K5 and the K-5II.

So yes I agree. View the images on screen before judging.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
Smeggypants
Posted 02/03/2013 - 06:24 Link
Fletcher8 wrote:
I personally think Jim Radcliffe's Boxed Light may add a little more debate and thought?


http://www.boxedlight.com/K5IIS/index.htm

Anyway i hope you like the images.
I do like them. In fact I love them. Great set of images. I love the processing applied to them. Really brings them out and very inspiring.

None of those images and the IQ of them couldn't be achieved with an original K-5. Even the photographer himself says about that..."Who cares"



The K-5, K-5II an K-5IIs are all great cameras. The K-5II an K-5IIs have improved low light AF and an improved rear screen and for that they are a worthy upgrade for those who can stand the payout for those improvements. if you can get a K-5IIs for the same price as the K-5II then why not, there's nothing to lose.

My only gripe is hyperbole and claims about the K-5IIs that cannot be supported by actual images.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
johnriley
Posted 02/03/2013 - 06:50 Link
I think persistently what you are not seeing is the improvement of clarity in detail. That's clearly visible to me and to others as well. I see it in the images.

When referring to screens I was not thinking of brightness, which has nothing to do with resolution. High resolution screens show the K-5IIs has improved rendition of fine detail, just as we would expect it to. It can't not do because there's no blurring being applied by the camera.

Large prints also show improved rendition of fine detail. Sharpness isn't the issue, it's all about the finer resolution of details in an image. We can all make our images look sharp, hopefully.
Best regards, John
Smeggypants
Posted 02/03/2013 - 08:54 Link
johnriley wrote:
I think persistently what you are not seeing is the improvement of clarity in detail. That's clearly visible to me and to others as well. I see it in the images.

When referring to screens I was not thinking of brightness, which has nothing to do with resolution.
Sure, but David was claiming the K-5IIs is brighter than the K-5 in the images he posted. I proved that to be untrue by actually doing some measurements on the files, thus bypassing any attributes of the monitor screen. even though showing both images on two different screens also didn't show any differences.


Quote:
High resolution screens show the K-5IIs has improved rendition of fine detail, just as we would expect it to. It can't not do because there's no blurring being applied by the camera.

My screens are 1600x1200. That's more than capable of outperforming the 800x520 images David posted.

David for some reason is not posting any fullsize images, despite requests, and is choosing to expect us to make a judgement based upon 800x520 images. Which IMO is unreasonable.

For those who have been willing to make available full size comparison images such as DPReview and Image Resource


Please remember that while it's not possible to discern any difference in the 800X530 images presented in this thread, I haven't said there's no difference between the K-5IIs and the K-5II and K-5 images from the actual tests done by DPReview and imaging resources.

My claim is that the tiny differences in detail of the K-5IIs and other K-5 models are irrelenvent in practise and claims of increased brightness and better noise performance can simply not be shown by any evidence.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
Edited by Smeggypants: 02/03/2013 - 08:54
MrB
Posted 02/03/2013 - 09:53 Link
John - "I think persistently what you are not seeing is the improvement of clarity in detail. That's clearly visible to me and to others as well. I see it in the images."

This might be true for original full-size images although, even then, it seems to me that any differences are being greatly exaggerated. But to make this claim with regard to images posted here drifts well into the world of fantasy.

Smeggy - "..the tiny differences in detail of the K-5IIs and other K-5 models are irrelevent in practice.."

This is very likely to be correct, and an explanation can be found by studying the information and images on the following dpreview page -

http://www.dpreview.com/reviews/pentaxk5/13

(On other pages of this dpreview review of the original K-5, they refer to the "weak AA filter" of the K-5's sensor.)

Philip
davidstorm
Posted 02/03/2013 - 10:34 Link
OK, I think I can add something further to this discussion and prove beyond reasonable doubt the extra clarity and sharpness the IIs has over the original Mk1 K-5. I've taken a different approach this time. I shot one image with each camera, mounted on a tripod, with my Sigma 105mm F2.8 DG EX Macro lens, set on autofocus. This was planned to be a focussing test, but serves the other purpose really well. I've then adjusted the levels on each image (nothing else, just the levels) and loaded them into Photoshop in horizontal tiled view so you can see them side by side. I've blown both up to the sam magnification in areas within each image where they are in sharpest focus.

These are the screen shots from my laptop (1280 x 720 laptop screen). On my full HD monitor the difference is much more apparent, but if anyone says they cannot tell the difference here they either (a) need their eyes testing, (b) need a new monitor or (c) they are not being completely impartial and open about what they are seeing.

Comment Image


Comment Image


I don't think for a minute that this will settle the argument and convince everyone, but I can tell you 100% that these differences are clear and unambiguous on my monitors and this is borne out by printed output of the same images.

Regards
David
Flickr

Nicola's Apartments, Kassiopi, Corfu

Some cameras, some lenses, some bits 'n' bobs
davidstorm
Posted 02/03/2013 - 10:57 Link
Are you now convinced? Look at these if not:

Comment Image


Same lens, focussed in exactly the same place, images have been magnified at their sharpest point and have had only a levels adjustment.

Regards
David
Flickr

Nicola's Apartments, Kassiopi, Corfu

Some cameras, some lenses, some bits 'n' bobs
Dodge69
Posted 02/03/2013 - 11:40 Link
Finally some heavy crops, this is what I've have been wanting to see - thanks David.

I feel I'm detecting a difference, where as with the others I thought the mki actually looked better lol.

I still can't say it would make me want to upgrade though, particularly while the price is still so close to the release price. Out of curiosity, David I believe you have be a champion of the 'value' the Pentax system brings - could I ask why you 'auntie'd up' and upgraded so quickly?
Pentax pour des images riches en détails!
davidstorm
Posted 02/03/2013 - 12:15 Link
Dodge69 wrote:
David I believe you have be a champion of the 'value' the Pentax system brings - could I ask why you 'auntie'd up' and upgraded so quickly?
Hi Sean, thanks for the observation LOL! I'm just a sucker and couldn't resist any longer! Also I'm out and about quite a lot and always take two cameras, it used to be the K-5 and K-x, but the K-x is not quite as robust / damp resistant as I would like, so I decided on two K-5's. The price I paid for the IIs was no more than I could buy a II standard for, so as I mentioned earlier, there was nothing to lose.

Regards
David
Flickr

Nicola's Apartments, Kassiopi, Corfu

Some cameras, some lenses, some bits 'n' bobs

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo