Is a Really Fast Lens Worth It?
Posted 03/11/2006 - 13:10
Link
try using your tripod when you're in your kyak....
tripod won't help if you can't use it.....
then there's shallow dof in portraits.....
also what point is "sharper" lens when you lose the shot due to subject motion, because you can't get a faster shutter speed?
sometimes there's no shot unless you can get a superfast telephoto....is it worth the price? depends on how often you miss those photo ops and how much having them really means to you. I imagine pro sports/wildlife/portraits photogs will put a higher value than an occasional vacation snapshooter.
tripod won't help if you can't use it.....
then there's shallow dof in portraits.....
also what point is "sharper" lens when you lose the shot due to subject motion, because you can't get a faster shutter speed?
sometimes there's no shot unless you can get a superfast telephoto....is it worth the price? depends on how often you miss those photo ops and how much having them really means to you. I imagine pro sports/wildlife/portraits photogs will put a higher value than an occasional vacation snapshooter.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Posted 03/11/2006 - 13:21
Link
Hi Mac,
Good question, not silly question! One that you can only really answer based on personal experience and techniques, I think.
For me, there are several benefits, and several drawbacks, to large aperture telephotos:
Benefits
1. Brighter viewfinder image (great for focusing - manually or AF - in subdued lighting, e.g. woodland in overcast conditions).
2. Potential for faster shutter speeds, freezing action, if at the expense of optimal lense sharpness.
3. Teleconvertors can be used whilst retaining AF.
Drawbacks
1. Cost (although both my long 2.8s, an 80-200 and a 300, both MF, were secondhand and at reasonable price £179 and £330 respectively).
2. Weight (my 80-200 is currently not in my bag, I took it out when in Scotland a few weeks back and it hasn't found it's way back).
3. Filter size, although my Cokin P fits my 80-200, just, and the 300 has rear filters, but I don't think I'd get a polariser in there.
I use my 300mm with the 1.7x AF convertor, giving me an effective aperture of f/4.8, which is still well within the range where AF will work. If it was an f/4 lens, that would give f/6.8, and AF would probably be a bit more hit and miss. The usability of teleconvertors is a great advantage, because it makes the lenses much more versatile.
I understand it that most lenses are best when stopped down a couple of stops, not necessarily down to F/8-f/11. Hence an f/2.8 lens will (hopefully) give it's best performance around f/5.6-f/8.
Having said that, I read an online review of the Pentax 300/2.8 the other day, and image quality was great at 2.8, and fantastic at 4. I guess you pays your money...
Flexibility is the key for me, I think, but whether the pros outweigh the cons is obviously a personal choice. I have to say, I'll be ordering the DA 50-200 soon - everyone here raves about it, and it weighs less than a quarter of my 80-200. I will miss the brighter viewfinder though.
Dan
Good question, not silly question! One that you can only really answer based on personal experience and techniques, I think.
For me, there are several benefits, and several drawbacks, to large aperture telephotos:
Benefits
1. Brighter viewfinder image (great for focusing - manually or AF - in subdued lighting, e.g. woodland in overcast conditions).
2. Potential for faster shutter speeds, freezing action, if at the expense of optimal lense sharpness.
3. Teleconvertors can be used whilst retaining AF.
Drawbacks
1. Cost (although both my long 2.8s, an 80-200 and a 300, both MF, were secondhand and at reasonable price £179 and £330 respectively).
2. Weight (my 80-200 is currently not in my bag, I took it out when in Scotland a few weeks back and it hasn't found it's way back).
3. Filter size, although my Cokin P fits my 80-200, just, and the 300 has rear filters, but I don't think I'd get a polariser in there.
I use my 300mm with the 1.7x AF convertor, giving me an effective aperture of f/4.8, which is still well within the range where AF will work. If it was an f/4 lens, that would give f/6.8, and AF would probably be a bit more hit and miss. The usability of teleconvertors is a great advantage, because it makes the lenses much more versatile.
I understand it that most lenses are best when stopped down a couple of stops, not necessarily down to F/8-f/11. Hence an f/2.8 lens will (hopefully) give it's best performance around f/5.6-f/8.
Having said that, I read an online review of the Pentax 300/2.8 the other day, and image quality was great at 2.8, and fantastic at 4. I guess you pays your money...
Flexibility is the key for me, I think, but whether the pros outweigh the cons is obviously a personal choice. I have to say, I'll be ordering the DA 50-200 soon - everyone here raves about it, and it weighs less than a quarter of my 80-200. I will miss the brighter viewfinder though.
Dan
Posted 03/11/2006 - 13:59
Link
Don and Dan,
That's what I was looking for!
With my failing eyesight, I can sure see the advantages of huge aperture focusing in bad light no matter what kind of shooting one does.
And Don, I'll bet you're correct about missed shots. Mine are usually missed 'cause I have the wrong focal length mounted when those once-in-a-lifetime opportunities arise, but I can see the frustration of needing a stop or two more to get even a slightly out-of-focus picture.
I'm a big fan of tripods by the way, and even use a Manfroto Monopod in the kayak (can you spell seasick?)
Dan, lenses that perform at f2.8 - f4 gotta be a miracle and are probably worth it.
Silly question well answered!
Best to all...
That's what I was looking for!
With my failing eyesight, I can sure see the advantages of huge aperture focusing in bad light no matter what kind of shooting one does.
And Don, I'll bet you're correct about missed shots. Mine are usually missed 'cause I have the wrong focal length mounted when those once-in-a-lifetime opportunities arise, but I can see the frustration of needing a stop or two more to get even a slightly out-of-focus picture.
I'm a big fan of tripods by the way, and even use a Manfroto Monopod in the kayak (can you spell seasick?)
Dan, lenses that perform at f2.8 - f4 gotta be a miracle and are probably worth it.
Silly question well answered!
Best to all...
Posted 03/11/2006 - 14:44
Link
Hi,
There is lots of mis-information about fast lenses and lots of myths.
Fast lenses were basically developed for pro use, especially for low light shooting and also action work. Lens makers assume they are going to be used wide open or near to it, so most fast lenses are actually computed to have the highest performance at the wider f stops, so for instance you would expect an 85/1.4 lens to perfom best at about f2 to f2.8. In contrast a slower lens is computed to work best at the middle range of f stops. So if you tend to use lets say f5.6, f8 and f11, then normally the slower lenses will perform better.
People also often forget that slower lenses are FAR easier for lens makers to make and usually have better performance than their faster and far more expensive cousins. People fall into the trap of assuming just because fast lenses cost far more, then they must have better performance...this is simply untrue in lots of cases.
The other myth is that fast lenses must be faster and easier to focus. I have often found this to be untrue. They do let more light in, but often the difference is so slight that it is near to impossible to see any difference. What actually happens is that the much reduced depth of field with a fast lens actually often makes them harder to focus.
If you conduct an experiment like I did, compare the focussing 'ease' of an 85/1.4 with an 85/2.8 and the slower lens is often easier to focus, because the image snaps in and out of focus far more noticeably with the slower lens.
Many people are now buying these fast lenses due to falling prices and yet many are trading in slower lenses which often have better performance!
cheers Steve.
There is lots of mis-information about fast lenses and lots of myths.
Fast lenses were basically developed for pro use, especially for low light shooting and also action work. Lens makers assume they are going to be used wide open or near to it, so most fast lenses are actually computed to have the highest performance at the wider f stops, so for instance you would expect an 85/1.4 lens to perfom best at about f2 to f2.8. In contrast a slower lens is computed to work best at the middle range of f stops. So if you tend to use lets say f5.6, f8 and f11, then normally the slower lenses will perform better.
People also often forget that slower lenses are FAR easier for lens makers to make and usually have better performance than their faster and far more expensive cousins. People fall into the trap of assuming just because fast lenses cost far more, then they must have better performance...this is simply untrue in lots of cases.
The other myth is that fast lenses must be faster and easier to focus. I have often found this to be untrue. They do let more light in, but often the difference is so slight that it is near to impossible to see any difference. What actually happens is that the much reduced depth of field with a fast lens actually often makes them harder to focus.
If you conduct an experiment like I did, compare the focussing 'ease' of an 85/1.4 with an 85/2.8 and the slower lens is often easier to focus, because the image snaps in and out of focus far more noticeably with the slower lens.
Many people are now buying these fast lenses due to falling prices and yet many are trading in slower lenses which often have better performance!
cheers Steve.
Posted 03/11/2006 - 18:16
Link
Hi Steve,
Just had a go at your experiment, can't say I got the same results as you. Found it easier to focus critically with a wider aperture. Also tried stopping down my 50mm 1.7 to f/4, focusing, then opening the aperture up to f/1.7 again. Found that what looked in focus at f/4 wasn't at f/1.7, and the focus point was usually just behind the subject.
Also just had a look online at lens test charts here: http://www.photozone.de/8Reviews/. Not looked at this site before, but was the first I came to when I searched, so I'm prepared for a deluge of "that's the worst lens-test website ever!" comments, but it looks fairly comprehensive to me. Had a look through various f/2.8 lenses - their performance all seemed to peak at f/5.6 (apart from the Canon 80-200 IS, which was best at f/8 ). The Nikon 85mm 1.4 was quite a surprise.
I chose to get an 80-200 f/2.8 because at the time I was using manual exposure and focus, and didn't want to have to reset my exposure with every change in focal length (hence the constant aperture), and didn't want f/5.6 at the long end, as I think that would have been too dark to focus accurately in the environment I was using it, and most lenses in this range tend to end up at f/5.6 at the long end. Bear in mind I was usually using a polariser too, so I was already losing two stops to that.
There is lots of mis-information about all aspects of photography, but the best thing to do is to try things out and see what works best for you.
And don't believe everything you read on the web!
Dan
Just had a go at your experiment, can't say I got the same results as you. Found it easier to focus critically with a wider aperture. Also tried stopping down my 50mm 1.7 to f/4, focusing, then opening the aperture up to f/1.7 again. Found that what looked in focus at f/4 wasn't at f/1.7, and the focus point was usually just behind the subject.
Also just had a look online at lens test charts here: http://www.photozone.de/8Reviews/. Not looked at this site before, but was the first I came to when I searched, so I'm prepared for a deluge of "that's the worst lens-test website ever!" comments, but it looks fairly comprehensive to me. Had a look through various f/2.8 lenses - their performance all seemed to peak at f/5.6 (apart from the Canon 80-200 IS, which was best at f/8 ). The Nikon 85mm 1.4 was quite a surprise.
I chose to get an 80-200 f/2.8 because at the time I was using manual exposure and focus, and didn't want to have to reset my exposure with every change in focal length (hence the constant aperture), and didn't want f/5.6 at the long end, as I think that would have been too dark to focus accurately in the environment I was using it, and most lenses in this range tend to end up at f/5.6 at the long end. Bear in mind I was usually using a polariser too, so I was already losing two stops to that.
There is lots of mis-information about all aspects of photography, but the best thing to do is to try things out and see what works best for you.
And don't believe everything you read on the web!
Dan
Posted 04/11/2006 - 10:28
Link
".......... the slower lens is often easier to focus, because the image snaps in and out of focus far more noticeably with the slower lens..."
I think you have this round the wrong way,...a faster,ie, larger aperture gives less depth of field and thus allows easier image 'snap' than a smaller aperture.....
Something not mentioned thus far is the fact that with reflex cameras one must use the lens also for supplying an adequate viewfinder picture. For some low light work it is essential to see as clearly as possible and an extra stop can make all the difference,..quite apart from easier focus.
I think you have this round the wrong way,...a faster,ie, larger aperture gives less depth of field and thus allows easier image 'snap' than a smaller aperture.....
Something not mentioned thus far is the fact that with reflex cameras one must use the lens also for supplying an adequate viewfinder picture. For some low light work it is essential to see as clearly as possible and an extra stop can make all the difference,..quite apart from easier focus.
Posted 04/11/2006 - 11:18
Link
It is generally accepted that a brighter viewfinder image is easier to focus, but it's not always the case. Some users report difficulty when using the Beattie type screens which, although undeniably brighter, seem to make the point of focus less easy to judge. This may mean that the granularity of the screen is also a factor.
Best regards, John
Posted 04/11/2006 - 14:37
Link
Hiya,
To reply to this:
"I think you have this round the wrong way,...a faster,ie, larger aperture gives less depth of field and thus allows easier image 'snap' than a smaller aperture....."
I do realise what I said and I stick by it. It is a misnomer that fast lenses with shallower depth of field are always easier to focus. I have found that more often than not, the increased depth of field of slower lenses actually makes them easier to focus in many instances.
I know what you are saying and you would think it makes logical sense, but I have found the opposite to be true quite often. I am not the odd one out here either, there are many others who have had difficulty focussing fast lenses like 50mm f1.2's because the depth of field is TOO shallow. Sometimes a shallow DOF actually makes the focus point more critical and you end up going back and forth to find it.
I just tried it again yesterday, I used a film SLR with a standard screen (not Beattie or similar) I went into the garden and used two different lenses, one a 80mm f1.4 and the other a 60mm f2.8. The f2.8 lens was much easier to focus. Yes, the image was darker, but crucially the f2.8 lens snapped in & out of focus much better than the f1.4 lens.
Cheers Steve.
To reply to this:
"I think you have this round the wrong way,...a faster,ie, larger aperture gives less depth of field and thus allows easier image 'snap' than a smaller aperture....."
I do realise what I said and I stick by it. It is a misnomer that fast lenses with shallower depth of field are always easier to focus. I have found that more often than not, the increased depth of field of slower lenses actually makes them easier to focus in many instances.
I know what you are saying and you would think it makes logical sense, but I have found the opposite to be true quite often. I am not the odd one out here either, there are many others who have had difficulty focussing fast lenses like 50mm f1.2's because the depth of field is TOO shallow. Sometimes a shallow DOF actually makes the focus point more critical and you end up going back and forth to find it.
I just tried it again yesterday, I used a film SLR with a standard screen (not Beattie or similar) I went into the garden and used two different lenses, one a 80mm f1.4 and the other a 60mm f2.8. The f2.8 lens was much easier to focus. Yes, the image was darker, but crucially the f2.8 lens snapped in & out of focus much better than the f1.4 lens.
Cheers Steve.
Posted 04/11/2006 - 14:54
Link
I think the key point here is the amount of light available. In normal daylight it's easy enough to focus any lens, but in twilight a wide max aperture makes things much easier.
G
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 04/11/2006 - 15:00
Link
Talking of focusing lenses, it's also vital that the eyepiece correction is suitable for your eyesight. As photographers get older it's more and more difficult to focus using the standard eyepiece with a -1 dioptre value such as found on most earlier Pentax cameras.
Some photographers might find it easier to use their reading glasses, or maybe to fit an eyepiece correction lens M. Later cameras have dioptre adjustment built in, which is much better.
Some photographers might find it easier to use their reading glasses, or maybe to fit an eyepiece correction lens M. Later cameras have dioptre adjustment built in, which is much better.
Best regards, John
Posted 05/11/2006 - 01:52
Link
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Posted 05/11/2006 - 23:20
Link
Quote:
Sometimes a shallow DOF actually makes the focus point more critical and you end up going back and forth to find it.
Okay, fair point, probably found by myself with my test - but are you not getting acceptable focus with the increased depth of field of a slower lens, rather than critically sharp focus with the shallower DOF of a faster lens?Sometimes a shallow DOF actually makes the focus point more critical and you end up going back and forth to find it.
You're relying on the increased depth of field to allow a little leeway in focusing accuracy, so in essence, yes, I suppose it could be viewed that it would be faster to obtain acceptable focus on a lens with a smaller maximum aperture.
If you want to focus critically though, I would still argue a wider aperture, and the corresponding brighter viewfinder (not necessarily hugely brighter, but noticeably to my eyes), are the way to go.
You could always stop down to f/22 and not bother focusing at all.
Dan
Posted 05/11/2006 - 23:27
Link
I'm with Daniel on this one.
He's quite right. The greater DOF of a small ap. lens allows for a wider range of "acceptable" focus. It doesn't help to obtain true focus.
G
He's quite right. The greater DOF of a small ap. lens allows for a wider range of "acceptable" focus. It doesn't help to obtain true focus.
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Posted 06/11/2006 - 00:02
Link
George, we must stop agreeing like this.
Dan
Dan
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


2277 posts
24 years
Here to muddy the waters again with today's Silly Question - but I really wanna know!
I can understand the benefits of fast lenses in Wide Angle up to maybe 85mm. Myself I would use them wide open in portrait work to soften the edges and thus would welcome the reduced D.O.F..
With telephoto and longer zooms, the D.O.F. is very small to begin with and almost dissapears when the lens is opened to the max.
Most if not all, tests show a lens to be at its best for contrast and sharpness set at around f8 to f11. At these openings the depth is also fine.
So, why the quest for super fast and super expensive 200mm + primes and zooms if they perform optimally stopped down. Are they of a superior quality making them out-perform their modest siblings at f8?
The only humble comparisons I've been able to make are in 50mm, 1:1.4, 1:1.8, and Macro 1:4 and in 135mm, 1:2.5 to 1:3.5. (All Super Tak M42's) If I set all the lenses to f8, I really can't see any difference in the results.
I'm sure I'm missing something here (big surprise), but so far it isn't a lot of money. These very fast long lenses make me gasp when I look at the price tags.
Cheers, your willing student,