Filters for B/W

Kim C
Posted 01/08/2004 - 12:52 Link
I used to do a lot of B/W photography. Unfortunately, pressures of work/ family etc now mean that I can't spend much time in the darkroom. I want to try some of the new generation of B/W films that use the C41 process which means I can use commercial processing more. Has anyone tried them and specifically what is the effect of the usual B/W filters? The Trad film was more sensitive to the blue end of the spectrum, so the use of yellow or even orange was needed as correction filters. The new films have 3 colour layers and therefore should have a more even response. Does this mean that you don't need to correct anymore? Also do the "contrast" filters such as blue, green and red still have the same effect and to the same degree?

Regards
Kim
johnriley
Posted 01/08/2004 - 15:23 Link
In practical terms I would still use a red filter for most of my monochrome work even with C41 process films.

I think the main drawback is that the image is made up of dyes instead of silver and it lacks the absolute "sparkle" that you can get with the silver-rich films such as Plus-X, Tri-X, FP4 and, to a lesser extent, HP5.

I've gone right back to Kodak Tr-X, which is fast (400 ISO) and has a wonderfully tight and crisp grain structure which gives a terrfic texture to landscape work. For portraits I would use a finer grain fim such as Plus-X or T-Max 100.
Best regards, John
Kim C
Posted 01/08/2004 - 15:44 Link
Hi John,
I must admit that having tried most of the Kodak films including T-Max, my favourite was always FP4 or Pan F. I tended not to use red too much - lovely dramatic skies but a bit overpowering. I tended to prefer orange as I could always increse to effect in the darkroom if I wanted. But, as I said, I haven't got that much time these days, and wanted to try the new films and commercial processing. It was more for "normal" use I was refering to. Yellow 2 used to bring FP4 to a more normal spectral curve. Do I still need this with the new films if I don't want to highlight skies etc?

Regards
Kim
johnriley
Posted 01/08/2004 - 18:25 Link
Hi Kim

I didn't really answer the question, did I?

As far as I can recall from the last time I used the chromogenic films, the filter effects are similar to conventional films.
Best regards, John

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo