Discussion: Weekly Competition #7: Age

justgetoutandride
Posted 23/08/2007 - 21:01 Link
has George gone on holiday too? the deadline was Tuesday, it's thursday evening and no update.
Please call me aj,

I use a Pentax K10D, on a MacBook with LightRoom (vers 1.3 + beta 2)

http://www.ba-joseph.co.uk/gallery
johnriley
Posted 23/08/2007 - 22:59 Link
We knew George was possibly going to be a little late, but hang on for a short while and I'm sure when he gets his Internet access back the wait will be wiorth it.
Best regards, John
Mannesty
Posted 24/08/2007 - 15:02 Link
In reply to another thread, I think George mentioned he was going to be away until Sunday . . .
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Daniel Bridge
Posted 24/08/2007 - 15:07 Link
No, think it was that he was going on sunday but would have internet access by wednesday, in time for judging. Should really check that before I post, but what the heck!

Hope he wasn't going to the Caribbean...

Dan
K-3, a macro lens and a DA*300mm...
dirk1000
Posted 24/08/2007 - 16:54 Link
Gentlemen,

As we can see, judging the competition is not an easy (and always wanted) job.

I think we have a problem with our Weekly Competition in this area.

Another thing: what about if the winner is a novice photographer (like me). How can I judge respectfully and with acceptable criteria the work of a long experienced artist?

I was thinking in another (alternative) way for judging the competition:

Each of all the participants at the deadline time, proposes his 3 favorites competitors works (except ethically his own) and gives an argument or critique about his decision, then with simple math, the moderator (JohnR) proclaims the winner…

Just an idea…


Best regards.
________________
Dirk TROTTEYN.
K10D+ Sigma 18-50 1:2.8 EX DC Lens.
Don
Posted 24/08/2007 - 17:07 Link
Dirk, I like the images of yours I've seen so far, and don't think you should be so modest.

truthfully, I don't need to know a damn thing about internal combustion engines to know if my car is or isn't running right.

I don't need to know how to drive like Villeneuve to figure out who's winning the race.

We accept that this is a friendly venue with no prizes other than the feedback we get from our friends here. Your opinion (if not the same as mine, must be wrong) is valued, and bound to differ from mine (and therefore must be wrong), but it's ok because I know it's subjective (you're allowed to be wrong).

I like the way things are and might suggest that if the winner is unavailable to judge and post a new topic, the honour (curse) befalls the runner up.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
ChrisA
Posted 24/08/2007 - 17:16 Link
Quote:
Another thing: what about if the winner is a novice photographer (like me). How can I judge respectfully and with acceptable criteria the work of a long experienced artist?
I agree with Don - I don't think there is a problem.

And I also think you're putting yourself down needlessly.

I'd be surprised if there's a single person contributing to this forum that is so arrogant as to have no interest in the views of someone - no matter how inexperienced - that is capable of producing work good enough to win the previous week.

Don't worry. If you win, that entitles you to your opportunity to judge - in the view, I would guess, of virtually all the entrants.

In any case, having different winners gives us the chance of hearing the preferences of different judges. I think that's a good thing. Who knows - someone's inexperienced eye might be just the thing to give a new slant on things for those with much more experience.
Galoot
Posted 24/08/2007 - 18:18 Link
Don and Chris are right, the weekly competition should be a fun exercise between like-minded people , and judging it should be open to any winner, novice or expert. Everyone has an opinion, and should be entitled to express it. If you are judging and a particular picture takes your eye, just declare it the winner, and as you are the judge, your decision is final, just give us a wee bit of feed-back, please.

As for your pictures, Dirk - well you'll be judging very soon.
dirk1000
Posted 25/08/2007 - 03:21 Link
Quote:
Dirk, I like the images of yours I've seen so far, and don't think you should be so modest.

truthfully, I don't need to know a damn thing about internal combustion engines to know if my car is or isn't running right .
Quote:
Don't worry. If you win, that entitles you to your opportunity to judge - in the view, I would guess, of virtually all the entrants.
Quote:
As for your pictures, Dirk - well you'll be judging very soon.
Thanks Don, ChrisA and Galoot for you encouraging words.

After reading your replays I feel more comfortable and confident with the judging role.

But tell me the truth, don´t you feel a little intimidated saying to George: I don´t like your picture, needs better contrast and exposure… ; or to John Riley: I would like to see the horizontals more horizontal?

Seriously, I insist, judging from a “learner photographer position” is a great and heavy responsibility although it is just for fun.

Also understand perfectly the character of the competence; a healthy and fun exercise between like-minded people.

Things like this make me enjoy this forum.



Best regards.
________________
Dirk TROTTEYN.
K10D+ Sigma 18-50 1:2.8 EX DC Lens.
Don
Posted 25/08/2007 - 04:14 Link
I don't really think it was appropriate for Michaelangello to paint dirty pictures on the ceiling of a church where people bring thier children to learn about abstinence......

so if I can have a difference of opinion with him, I'm sure George's or John Riley's self esteem could survive my scathing tongue.....

My opinion doesn't change wheather or not he's a good photographer, it's just an observation about one image, and I'm sure they'd weigh it appropriately, after all, I'm just some kook on the other side of the pond.
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
justgetoutandride
Posted 25/08/2007 - 10:13 Link
As far as I'm concerned, 'the judge' decides if they like or don't like a picture. If they can give a reasoned argument of why, then all the better, but for me it comes down to gut instinct.

I can appreciate the qualities that go into ... whatshisname ... benjikan's images, but they leave me cold. the light is well managed, the focus is pin sharp, the subjects (usually) stunningly pretty, but I'd chose an out of focus butterfly in preference. And if I'm the judge then that is my preference.
Please call me aj,

I use a Pentax K10D, on a MacBook with LightRoom (vers 1.3 + beta 2)

http://www.ba-joseph.co.uk/gallery
johnriley
Posted 25/08/2007 - 10:45 Link
Out around the photographic societies, judging of competitions is always an issue. Faced with an audience who all have an emotional investment in their images, the judge dismisses anything out of hand at his own peril.

My wife Sue nearly gave up altogether after a judge slated what she had done, and only because he didn't like digitally added borders. He never even mentioned the content of her picture. Fortunately she recovered from that and went on to be a fantastic photographer. She might be better than I am, but let's not go there...

As regards here, everyone has judged fairly and courteously and done a terrific job. It is an emotional response to an image that will win the day, but there is also a rational approach behind that. Lousy pictures don't win and good ones do, but of the good ones the ones that speak to us stand above the rest.

Keep up the good work, don't worry too much and just have fun!
Best regards, John
Clarky
Posted 25/08/2007 - 11:03 Link
Talking of Borders and having fun i was playing with a program last week which puts borders on you pics and this was one of the horror stories i came up with Comment Image
[/img][/url]
Camera:|K-7|
Pentax Lenses:|DA12-24/f4 ED AL|DA35Ltd Macro|FA31Ltd|FA77Ltd|FA50/1.4|F70-210|FA20-35 f4/AL|A*200/f4 Macro ED|A50/1.7|A50 Macro f2.8|1.7xAF adapter|
Voigtlander|125/f2.5SL Macro APO Lanthar|
Sigma Lenses:|EX DG 100-300 f4|2X & 1.4X TC|
Flashes:|AF540FGZx2|RingFlash AF160FC|
johnriley
Posted 25/08/2007 - 11:46 Link
My photochromic glasses turned instantly black.....

Best regards, John
Clarky
Posted 25/08/2007 - 12:01 Link
Show it too your wife she will feel a lot better about that judging experience.
Camera:|K-7|
Pentax Lenses:|DA12-24/f4 ED AL|DA35Ltd Macro|FA31Ltd|FA77Ltd|FA50/1.4|F70-210|FA20-35 f4/AL|A*200/f4 Macro ED|A50/1.7|A50 Macro f2.8|1.7xAF adapter|
Voigtlander|125/f2.5SL Macro APO Lanthar|
Sigma Lenses:|EX DG 100-300 f4|2X & 1.4X TC|
Flashes:|AF540FGZx2|RingFlash AF160FC|

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo