digital photo review
Posted 24/01/2012 - 21:41
Link
Wish i knew how . This months digital photo magazine
Nikon d7000
features and build *****
peformance*****
image quality *****
value for money ****
overall *****
pentax k5
features and build ****
performance ****
image quality *****
value for money ****
overall ****
Nikon d7000
features and build *****
peformance*****
image quality *****
value for money ****
overall *****
pentax k5
features and build ****
performance ****
image quality *****
value for money ****
overall ****
Posted 24/01/2012 - 21:46
Link
The last bit utter rubbish "we found thek-5s menu system was less intuative than its rivals,slower to navigate,and the button arrangment not as refined as canons 60d or nikons d7000
Posted 24/01/2012 - 23:46
Link
Well at least the K-5 got to be included.
I suppose if the reviewer is more used Canikons he would be more familiar with their menu systems. I don't think you can beat the one on the K-5 where all the main functions are available together on one of the INFO screens. I've no idea for sure if that is on Canikons as well but a quick peruse of their menu systems in their respective manuals suggests not. Their normal menu systems are much the same as the K-5's so hardly any less intuitive.
Actual article is in the magazine, not on the web.
John
I suppose if the reviewer is more used Canikons he would be more familiar with their menu systems. I don't think you can beat the one on the K-5 where all the main functions are available together on one of the INFO screens. I've no idea for sure if that is on Canikons as well but a quick peruse of their menu systems in their respective manuals suggests not. Their normal menu systems are much the same as the K-5's so hardly any less intuitive.
johnriley wrote:
A link please?
linkA link please?
Actual article is in the magazine, not on the web.
John
John K
Posted 25/01/2012 - 09:59
Link
JAK wrote:
I don't think you can beat the one on the K-5 where all the main functions are available together on one of the INFO screens. I've no idea for sure if that is on Canikons as well but a quick peruse of their menu systems in their respective manuals suggests not.
It is on my 50D and was on the 7D I tested.I don't think you can beat the one on the K-5 where all the main functions are available together on one of the INFO screens. I've no idea for sure if that is on Canikons as well but a quick peruse of their menu systems in their respective manuals suggests not.
The only reason I can see for Pentax being knocked down on their interface is lack of familiarity due to reviewers using Canikon a lot more than Pentax because between the two I prefer the Pentax menus.
Probably due to a lot more use.
whatsthisbuttondo wrote:
pentax k5
features and build ****
performance ****
image quality *****
value for money ****
overall ****
pentax k5
features and build ****
performance ****
image quality *****
value for money ****
overall ****
I actually think that is about right for the K-5 apart from features and build which deserves a 5. However I think the Nikon is overmarked rather than the Pentax undermarked.
Posted 25/01/2012 - 10:13
Link
Mike-P wrote:
The only reason I can see for Pentax being knocked down on their interface is lack of familiarity due to reviewers using Canikon a lot more than Pentax because between the two I prefer the Pentax menus.
Probably due to a lot more use.
Zactly. If a Pentax User had done the test, the results would have been a lot different! Actually a lot of comments I've seen online from people coming to Pentax from another brand suggest they prefer the button placement when they get used to it... having the ISO button on top within finger's reach when holding the camera, for example!
The only reason I can see for Pentax being knocked down on their interface is lack of familiarity due to reviewers using Canikon a lot more than Pentax because between the two I prefer the Pentax menus.
Probably due to a lot more use.
Posted 25/01/2012 - 10:25
Link
A D7000 is £250 more than a K-5??? .... How can they both score
4 stars VFM.... surely the K-5 should be 5 stars
4 stars VFM.... surely the K-5 should be 5 stars
Half Man... Half Pentax ... Half Cucumber
Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff
Algi
Pentax K-1 + K-5 and some other stuff
Algi
Posted 25/01/2012 - 10:49
Link
One of the most difficult ratings to provide is a "value for money" one. How do you argue VFM with a Limited lens, for example? The 77mm could be regarded as expensive or, compared to Leica prices, an absolute steal....where does that leave us?
Personally I would ditch VFM ratings.
Personally I would ditch VFM ratings.
Best regards, John
Posted 25/01/2012 - 11:56
Link
whatsthisbuttondo wrote:
The last bit utter rubbish "we found thek-5s menu system was less intuative than its rivals,slower to navigate,and the button arrangment not as refined as canons 60d or nikons d7000
A personal opinion of the menus should not have skewed the results so much. Surely as professional reviewers of kit they should be impartial, I always assumed performance referred to imaging performance.
The last bit utter rubbish "we found thek-5s menu system was less intuative than its rivals,slower to navigate,and the button arrangment not as refined as canons 60d or nikons d7000
Posted 25/01/2012 - 12:02
Link
It probably comes under "handling", but reviewers need to be very careful with this. Having and stating opinions on handling is fine, we need to know how things work in practice, but it's the giving of scores that's IMHO the really tricky bit. Attempts to quantify scoring tend to leave us with scores that don't reflect the total usefulness and performance of an item.
Best regards, John
Posted 25/01/2012 - 13:09
Link
I agree that the reviewers familiarity with Canon and Nikons may sway things when it comes to menus and handling, I find Canons totally alien and doubt I would ever want one, not handled enough Nikons to say the same.
I don't really know how other marques compare from model to model but I find with Pentax that if you've used one model you can pick up another and use it instinctively and that says a lot about a camera systems design.
I don't really know how other marques compare from model to model but I find with Pentax that if you've used one model you can pick up another and use it instinctively and that says a lot about a camera systems design.
Posted 25/01/2012 - 15:50
Link
I just wonder how many of these reviewers have been feted and fawned over at trade shows by Pentax?
Not as many as those buttered up by Canikon.
Not as many as those buttered up by Canikon.
Chunky
Posted 25/01/2012 - 16:16
Link
chunky wrote:
I just wonder how many of these reviewers have been feted and fawned over at trade shows by Pentax?
Not as many as those buttered up by Canikon.
Whos fault is that?I just wonder how many of these reviewers have been feted and fawned over at trade shows by Pentax?
Not as many as those buttered up by Canikon.
You can't blame them for Canikon getting more exposure when Pentax hardly attend any of the trade shows.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


586 posts
15 years
nantwich