DA* 300mm or DA* 60-250mm?

alig
Posted 23/06/2009 - 11:55 Link
First of all I hate these questions and when I see them I think 'oh make your own mind up!'

But...

I was saving up for the DA* 300mm but with all the great comments re the DA* 60-250mm I am wondering IF this is the lens I should save for...

I have the DA* 50-135mm, so is the DA* 60-250mm TOO much of an overlap?

I would appreciate any 'help' on this issue from anyone that has both or all of these lenses!

To be honest I just would like the extra reach, further than the DA* 50-135mm I have at the moment.

Cheers in advance.

ali
Cheers

Ali

ist* DS & Ricoh GR
aminstar
Posted 23/06/2009 - 11:59 Link
I can't really help you decide but all I can tell you is that I have the DA*60-250 and the DA*300 and both complement each other. I can't see one making the other redundant, specially because I use the DA*300 with the Pentax 1.7x adapter sometimes for that extra reach and am not sure if others have managed to use the adapter with the 60-250mm but I have never tried. So that rests the case for me.

I don't have the DA*50-135 so I can't really give you any practical advice based on experience, but what I just mentioned above is all I can do to help you make up your mind.

Good luck with your choice
Edited by aminstar: 23/06/2009 - 12:00
alig
Posted 23/06/2009 - 12:16 Link
Thanks Amin, wish I could get both, don't think it would go down well...

Don't think either will be a 'bad' choice, just with having the 50-135mm don't want to make it or 60-250mm redundant... if that makes sense.

ali
Cheers

Ali

ist* DS & Ricoh GR
Unlocker
Posted 23/06/2009 - 12:33 Link
Now that I have the 60-250, the 50-135 is redundant for me, and if Fiona wasn't a keen photographer as well, I would be selling it as soon as the price rises are effective at every supplier rather than putting it in her camera bag!

It helps that I got the 60-250 at the original £799 price, but it is now around £1150, although some still have old stock at £899. The 300mm would not be that important to me having the 60-250, and if I did have one, it would be like Amin's by having the 1.7x adaptor on it permanently.

To be honest, the 60-250 just seems so good and versatile to me, that I now have very little desire to complete the DA* collection. The next purchase will have to wait until there is a DA* Lens longer than 300mm, guessing that won't be cheap either!
aminstar
Posted 23/06/2009 - 12:34 Link
Ali
Its better you get it right. DA*300 is a stunning lens but in my personal opinion its really mostly used if you are into wildlife photography or shooting at events such as air shows etc. Some of us who own it around this forum you will notice that we are quite into it.
The lack of zoom restricts it, and let me tell you, it does restrict a lot if you want to make use of it for other moments. I know this by experience.

There was one thread somewhere here that Stefan had mentioned something about taking a 300mm prime to shoot wildlife where the animals were tame and that you really get stuck with it. I took it to Whipsnade before I had the DA*60-250mm and I couldn't get shots properly framed. This would happen if you are going to a zoo or places where you know you are bound to run into situations you want to shoot at closer ranges. I had the quality but not the right length. Had to literally chop the legs and parts of images of my little ones and I felt really gutted.
On my next trip I carried my then owned 55-300mm and that was perfect. That's when I made a decision that I needed a zoom and never regretted buying the DA*60-250. From now on when I go to places with my little ones or they are playing in the garden I use my DA*60-250. I debated about getting the DA*50-135 but am not so sure if it would cover the range while shooting the images when the little ones are playing far away, these are the moments I like to shoot them.

So in the end if you sit down and put things in perspective you might find it easy to decide. Just list the things and go through it. Remember the restrictions you get with the prime. If by any chance you think you will consider to want to use it at the range above 135mm but controlling the length then the DA*60-250 is the lens to go. If you think you want the far end only then prime it is. It really depends.

I will send you a PM with some info shortly that might help you further more.

thanks

Amin
Edited by aminstar: 23/06/2009 - 12:37
aminstar
Posted 23/06/2009 - 12:41 Link
Unlocker wrote:
Now that I have the 60-250, the 50-135 is redundant for me, and if Fiona wasn't a keen photographer as well, I would be selling it as soon as the price rises are effective at every supplier rather than putting it in her camera bag!

It helps that I got the 60-250 at the original £799 price, but it is now around £1150, although some still have old stock at £899. The 300mm would not be that important to me having the 60-250, and if I did have one, it would be like Amin's by having the 1.7x adaptor on it permanently.

To be honest, the 60-250 just seems so good and versatile to me, that I now have very little desire to complete the DA* collection. The next purchase will have to wait until there is a DA* Lens longer than 300mm, guessing that won't be cheap either!
Danny

that was really the comment I was looking for mate from someone who owns both the DA*50-135 and the DA*60-250. You helped me big deal on this even without knowing .

Ali,
Have you considered getting the DA*60-250 and then if you think it makes your 50-135 redundant then get rid of it? You might even make some money out of it due to such high prices. I have a suspicion that just like Danny said the 60-250 might make it redundant.

You haven't mentioned still what applications you want to use the lenses for, that might open up a completely different perspective.
Oggy
Posted 23/06/2009 - 12:43 Link
I have not had a chance to use the 60-250 and 300 much, but my initial findings are in terms of detail that the 50-135 produces a better image than the 60-250 and the 300 creams both. This is what I would expect. More to follow.
aminstar
Posted 23/06/2009 - 12:48 Link
Remember that the difference between the 60-250 and 50-135 is only 10mm and that really is not much. Just like Danny said, for some applications that might make the 50-135 redundant and you could end in a win win situation, buy the DA*60-250 while its still cheap at certain places, and then you can either get rid of the 50-135 if you think its redundant and make even some extra out of it, or just sell off the newly acquired 60-250 and you will still make money out of it.

This is just my personal view of it. Might not make it the right choice though. Just trying to help you with some different perspective as I have been down the more or less the same routes quite recently
Edited by aminstar: 23/06/2009 - 12:49
aminstar
Posted 23/06/2009 - 12:57 Link
Oggy wrote:
I have not had a chance to use the 60-250 and 300 much, but my initial findings are in terms of detail that the 50-135 produces a better image than the 60-250 and the 300 creams both. This is what I would expect. More to follow.
Oggy
I am no expert in this but in my personal situation if I didn't have my 60-250 with me on certain occasions I wouldn't have managed to zoom as close as I had wished and still get a stunning portrait. And this is on day to day situations in a party or a gathering, or even in my back garden for example. I think the 135mm would be a bit short.

This is where the 60-250 really excells, I use it as a walk about lens and have a huge array of choice. As I do not own a 50-135 I am not sure how much better the quality of it would be compared to what I get from the 60-250. But if its just a minor one then its a great trade off.

Danny has both and I know he has used all of them widely, and reading his comment saying that his 50-135 is redundant, that for me settles it, personally I mean, for my own situations. Knowing his addiction for the DA* lenses that comment had to be well calculated and thought before it was put in writing
Unlocker
Posted 23/06/2009 - 13:20 Link
Don't read too much into what I've said, the 50-135 is still a fantastic lens, and there may be the odd occasion that I will need F2.8 at 135mm. It's just that I don't see the point in putting it in the bag for general use when the 60-250 is there.

Have done no specific quality testing to come to this conclusion at all, just personal preferences, why carry both? Plus the Wife gets a DA* in her bag, so it's always going to be there if needed.

If the 300 'creams' both the others, may have to re-evaluate that one!
aminstar
Posted 23/06/2009 - 13:34 Link
Unlocker wrote:
Don't read too much into what I've said, the 50-135 is still a fantastic lens, and there may be the odd occasion that I will need F2.8 at 135mm. It's just that I don't see the point in putting it in the bag for general use when the 60-250 is there.

Have done no specific quality testing to come to this conclusion at all, just personal preferences, why carry both? Plus the Wife gets a DA* in her bag, so it's always going to be there if needed.

If the 300 'creams' both the others, may have to re-evaluate that one!
Danny,
I get your point , and just like you said, prefer the DA*60-250. If I had the 50-135 attached I would miss the longer end of the 60-250.
But this is all assumption I don't own the 50-135.

As for the DA*300 creaming it hmmm, not exactly sure, I personally think that depends on what you are using it for. If I am photographing something that I frame at let's say 150mm range, what would happen if I used the 300mm prime? My last experience was I had to chop off my little one's legs . So all the cream of the DA*300 came to no avail

I will tell you what would be perfect though, a zoom that would go to 300mm (like a 60-300 or even I could live with 70-300) and with the quality of the DA*300mm. But we all know that we don't live in a world where perfection comes at a bargain price do we?
Anvh
Posted 23/06/2009 - 15:08 Link
aminstar wrote:
Remember that the difference between the 60-250 and 50-135 is only 10mm and that really is not much
It's the same distance as the 250mm against 300mm so if you say that you can also say that the DA*300 is redundant
But then again the 300 works well with the TC but the DA*50-135 is f/2.8 so they both have something to gain.
And the rendering of the DA*50-135 I find more magical then the DA*60-250 from what I've seen.
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Edited by Anvh: 23/06/2009 - 15:09
aminstar
Posted 23/06/2009 - 15:30 Link
Anvh wrote:
aminstar wrote:
Remember that the difference between the 60-250 and 50-135 is only 10mm and that really is not much
It's the same distance as the 250mm against 300mm so if you say that you can also say that the DA*300 is redundant
huh? Is my maths letting me down? I thought from 250 to 300 is 50mm and from 50 to 60 is just 10mm.

So when is the wider side 10mm equates to the longer 50mm? Is this how its calculated with regard to lenses?
Am I missing something here?

Have I had too many puffs of that coloured smoke is it?
Edited by aminstar: 23/06/2009 - 15:31
hefty1
Posted 23/06/2009 - 15:43 Link
aminstar wrote:
Anvh wrote:
aminstar wrote:
Remember that the difference between the 60-250 and 50-135 is only 10mm and that really is not much
It's the same distance as the 250mm against 300mm so if you say that you can also say that the DA*300 is redundant
huh? Is my maths letting me down? I thought from 250 to 300 is 50mm and from 50 to 60 is just 10mm.

So when is the wider side 10mm equates to the longer 50mm? Is this how its calculated with regard to lenses?
Am I missing something here?

Have I had too many puffs of that coloured smoke is it?
With focal lengths the important thing is percentages, not the actual length in mm.

The difference between 50mm and 60mm is 20%, the difference between 250mm and 300mm is 20%; hence the difference in the field of view is exactly the same between a 50/60 and a 250/300.
Joining the Q
Anvh
Posted 23/06/2009 - 15:44 Link
well yes Amin but lengths doesn't go up evenly but parabolic.
10mm difference between 50-60m is the same as 50mm between 250-300mm

Here is the math you should do.
60 divided by 50 = difference of 1.2x
300 / 250 = 1.2x also

Do you get it?

Hefty was faster
Stefan
Comment Image

K10D, K5
DA* 16-50, DA* 50-135, D-FA 100 Macro, DA 40 Ltd, DA 18-55
AF-540FGZ
Edited by Anvh: 23/06/2009 - 15:44

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo