Cokin P system filters
Posted 05/08/2013 - 16:26
Link
Hi Russ
Pleased to hear you are taking a sensible approach to filters on a budget. I did exactly the same - then moved up to hitech and am now in the process of swapping over to Lee a bit at a time
The main issue I had with Cokin was that when you stack them - especially on long exposures - you can get a bad colour cast (often green)that is difficult/ impossible to totally eradicate pp. Not always but when it happens you will know! However - for the price, they are good.
If you are looking to add some low cost filters to your set to play with - I would also recommend Kood. Cheaper than Cokin and I could not tell any difference on the solid ND set I had (paid about £5 each for them).
Enjoy!
Carl
Pleased to hear you are taking a sensible approach to filters on a budget. I did exactly the same - then moved up to hitech and am now in the process of swapping over to Lee a bit at a time
The main issue I had with Cokin was that when you stack them - especially on long exposures - you can get a bad colour cast (often green)that is difficult/ impossible to totally eradicate pp. Not always but when it happens you will know! However - for the price, they are good.
If you are looking to add some low cost filters to your set to play with - I would also recommend Kood. Cheaper than Cokin and I could not tell any difference on the solid ND set I had (paid about £5 each for them).
Enjoy!
Carl
No matter how many lenses I have owned - I have always needed just one more
Posted 06/08/2013 - 11:45
Link
Thanks Russ. It is always good to hear of someone's experiences. I have just this morning order an adaptor ring, filter holder and filter from here http://www.srb-griturn.com/index.asp so I'm hoping to have a go soon too.
Any shots ready for posting here yet?
Dave
Any shots ready for posting here yet?
Dave
Posted 06/08/2013 - 23:39
Link
Posted 17/10/2013 - 21:15
Link
I have been using Cromatek Filters for two years now and these are truly neutral- the Cromatek 75 series Digital SLR Kit (ND 2stop Grad, 81b and circular polarizer) comes with with their Matte Box holder (which cleverly stops sidelight bouncing in between filters).
http://www.spaphoto.co.uk/acatalog/Filter_Kits.html - are the sole UK distributer
I also have their ND standards at 2 and 3 stops + a 3stop ND Grad
The optical clarity/ complete lack of colour casts is superb and good value. It's an 84mm wide system so will fit Hitech Filter holders (who also do great 10stop ND standards) or the Cokin P holder
http://www.spaphoto.co.uk/acatalog/Filter_Kits.html - are the sole UK distributer
I also have their ND standards at 2 and 3 stops + a 3stop ND Grad
The optical clarity/ complete lack of colour casts is superb and good value. It's an 84mm wide system so will fit Hitech Filter holders (who also do great 10stop ND standards) or the Cokin P holder
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.




640 posts
17 years
So in light of that i decided upon the Cokin P system. And initially i was going to go real cheap and buy the Amazon set for £14.99 all in. But i decided against that and instead went real mega cheap with an Ebay £8.99 set. That included everything, holder, adapters and 6 filters (3 x ND & 3 x ND Grad). Before the Ebay order had time to arrive i decided to purchase the Cokin ND Grad kit for £26.....i bottled it! Was less than convinced the Ebay kit would cut it. And i hadn't really lost anything because the Cokin 52mm adapter was £6.99, which i didn't need.
Had a chance to use both kits now. Two wonderful (but rushed) mornings on the South Downs Walk.
The first morning i used the Ebay kit. I think you won't be surprised to learn the cheap filters had issues, although not as bad as i was expecting. The filter holder itself is to all intents and purposes every bit as good as the Cokin original. As are the adapter rings. And the filter holder wallet also proved to be a great item. I would happily recommend anyone thinking of going the 85mm square filter route to consider the cheap Ebay holder and adapters. They do the job perfectly. And you can buy all this as a kit without the filters, leaving you free to choose the filters you prefer.
The filters themselves are less easy to recommend. It will be no surprise to learn they give a magenta cast to sky. And this get worse if you start stacking filters. On the upside there was no apparent loss of image quality, which i was also expecting. But the strong magenta cast with two filters was highly annoying.
The original Cokin filters proved to be extremely good, even stacked up. I read a couple of reviews that said they also suffered with a magenta cast, perhaps to a lesser degree. But in use i had no issues at all with the Cokin filters. Just lovely blue skies with the odd puffy white cloud. Based on this i highly recommend the Cokin P filters for anyone on a tight budget.
My next purchase will be a Hitech filter or two. One of their hard ND Grads and a more extreme ND filter.
Worth noting that the magenta cast can be removed in Photoshop, so if you are on a really tight budget but still want to try some filters for landscape don't be put off trying the Ebay or Amazon kits. You can add better quality filters when finances allow.