Circular polariser and noise
Posted 19/10/2010 - 00:24
Link
I'm using a Hama, Alan. And yes it's a cheapo. Quite disappointing really as I thought it would improve my photos.
Leon
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8
Posted 19/10/2010 - 00:55
Link
leongu wrote:
First of all, forgive the ignorance but I've only recently used a circular polariser. What it is is that I've noticed increased noise in my photos whilst using a circular polariser. I would love to post and show sample images, but I'm not sure I can with no website to link the photos to.
2 of the photos I've taken have the following specs:
1. with cpolariser and more visible noise
24mm, f/22, 1/60s, ISO 200
2. no cpolariser less noise
50mm, f14, 1/200s, ISO 200
Appreciate if someone could advice if the use of a cpolariser has a direct impact to camera noise. I thought it was a bit odd to find noise at low ISOs especially on a K-x. Also note that the photos haven't been processed yet. So you can just imagine that noise would get worse post levels and contrast adjustments.
Thanks for your help.
f/22 with a polariser and 1/60 sec. Just how bight was it or were you covering arc welding?First of all, forgive the ignorance but I've only recently used a circular polariser. What it is is that I've noticed increased noise in my photos whilst using a circular polariser. I would love to post and show sample images, but I'm not sure I can with no website to link the photos to.
2 of the photos I've taken have the following specs:
1. with cpolariser and more visible noise
24mm, f/22, 1/60s, ISO 200
2. no cpolariser less noise
50mm, f14, 1/200s, ISO 200
Appreciate if someone could advice if the use of a cpolariser has a direct impact to camera noise. I thought it was a bit odd to find noise at low ISOs especially on a K-x. Also note that the photos haven't been processed yet. So you can just imagine that noise would get worse post levels and contrast adjustments.
Thanks for your help.
Some thing does not gel here.
Best regards
Too far from a shore.
Posted 19/10/2010 - 21:59
Link
hahaha It wasn't quite arc welding Gary. I managed to link the sample photos and I hope it will make more sense.
1. shot with cpol
[IMG]http://i1209.photobucket.com/albums/cc400/leongu/samplewithcpol-noPP.jpg[/IMG]
2. shot with uv filter
[IMG]http://i1209.photobucket.com/albums/cc400/leongu/samplenocpol-noPP.jpg[/IMG]
1. shot with cpol
[IMG]http://i1209.photobucket.com/albums/cc400/leongu/samplewithcpol-noPP.jpg[/IMG]
2. shot with uv filter
[IMG]http://i1209.photobucket.com/albums/cc400/leongu/samplenocpol-noPP.jpg[/IMG]
Leon
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8
Posted 19/10/2010 - 23:10
Link
Woh that's bit too technical Stefan, but I think I'm getting it now. So objective is to avoid underexposure which would lessen noise as well. I completely forgot that I lose 2 stops when using a polariser. Hence I should have compensated with an increase in f-stop or slow down shutter speed. I was shooting on Av mode and thought the camera was compensating on shutter speed automatically. Or did it?
Leon
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8
Posted 19/10/2010 - 23:35
Link
Yes it did compensate. The only thing here that I can think might influence noise is that the polariser has darkened some areas, as it should. Darker areas will show more noise.
Best regards, John
Posted 20/10/2010 - 00:10
Link
Thanks very much for the help and clarification John and Stefan! Good night!
Leon
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



20 posts
16 years
Manchester
2 of the photos I've taken have the following specs:
1. with cpolariser and more visible noise
24mm, f/22, 1/60s, ISO 200
2. no cpolariser less noise
50mm, f14, 1/200s, ISO 200
Appreciate if someone could advice if the use of a cpolariser has a direct impact to camera noise. I thought it was a bit odd to find noise at low ISOs especially on a K-x. Also note that the photos haven't been processed yet. So you can just imagine that noise would get worse post levels and contrast adjustments.
Thanks for your help.
K-x, K100D, DAL 18-55, DAL 50-200mm, Tamron 70-300Di, SMC M28/2.8