Cheap Sigma 105mm macro

chukka
Posted 12/11/2006 - 21:17 Link
Hi, having just bought a K100D, this is my first post on here. Loving the camera so far

Anyway, I was in a shop the other day talking to the guy about macro lenses. They have the Sigma 105mm EX for £150. Note the lack of the DG designator.

Now he was insistent that there is NO difference between the EX and the EX DG other than the two letters printed on the casing. No special coating, no optimisation for digital - it is the EXACT same identical lense. Is that the case? They also sell the DG for £290 so he's got no agenda in terms of selling me stuff. If anything you would think he would be pushing the more expensive one.

The real question though i guess is, even if there is a difference, is it worth the extra £140? I'm thinking probably not, and have ordered the plain EX (it is in a different branch and needs to be transfrred across). Have I got myself a bargain?
matsoberg
Posted 12/11/2006 - 21:58 Link
Hi Chukka and welcome.

Being a Pentax fan, posting on a Pentax forum, I would recommend you to have a look at the SMC Pentax FA-D 100/2.8 macro, as I do not have any experience with the Sigma.

There is also some of the older F and FA 100/2.8 macro lenses on ebay every now and then. Outstanding image quality from both of them.

// Mats
spirit_of_will
Posted 12/11/2006 - 22:50 Link
Hi Chukka

I have the Sigma 105 EX in the non-DG version, originally bought for use on my MZ-5n and then MZ-S... I don't have any experience with the DG version but have had no problems what-so-ever using the sigma on my ist-D. I've used both this and a Pentax 100mm A series manual focus macro lens and had great results from both...

I'm pretty certain that there's one or two chaps on here that can tell the difference but for me those differences are so slight as to make no odds. I'd say that picking up the non-DG sigma for a £140 saving is a great deal.

Will
Spirit_of_will

Fan and user of quality Pentax Shiny Kit

WEBSITE www.willbartonphotography.com & www.inspiredlightimages.com

Will Barton Photography: Landscapes, Cityscapes
My Flickr
Follow Will Barton Photography on Facebook
Daniel Bridge
Posted 13/11/2006 - 10:50 Link
Hi Chukka,

Being a Pentax fan, posting on a Pentax forum, I would recommend you seriously consider the Sigma 105mm EX, as I do not have any experience with the Pentax!

I also have the non-DG version of this lens, used solely on my istD, and I'm more than happy with it, got some great results. Whether the DG version is any better, I don't know, but I don't think you'll be disappointed with this one.

Many here would say that the equivalent Pentax is sharper, but as I've got no experience of that lens, I can't say either way.

Probably the best price you'll get for a new lens too.

An example of the quality of the Sigma...

Comment Image

istD, Sigma 105mm f/2.8 @f/11, extension tube, ISO200, Flash with diffuser, full frame

I like the solid build quality of the EX lenses too, certainly feel more solid than the DA lenses I have (of which I added one more to my camera bag yesterday - the 50-200mm. Pentax outnumbers Sigma in my bag now ).

All the best,
Dan
Pwynnej
Posted 13/11/2006 - 12:14 Link
'Appantly' on DG lenses Sigma have applied one or two special coatings on the rear elements to stop ghosting.....something digital cameras are susceptible to...

Pictures on my D and DL come out well on my non-DG 70-300 APO Macro and EX 70-200...., thinking of getting the EX 100-300 f4 (non-DG)...

For 100+ pounds more? I wouldn;t

Peter
Prieni
Posted 16/11/2006 - 14:55 Link
Comment Image

Pentax *istD, Sigma 105 mm F2.8 DG Makro, 1/125 s, A13, ISO 200, flash.

This is shot with the "DG", but judging from the fly picture I would happily go for the EX without DG.

(Edited the link, thanks Liam for hosting it!)
Prieni
Daniel Bridge
Posted 16/11/2006 - 18:11 Link
Can't see the pic here. But can if I copy the URL into the address bar of my browser.

Lovely spider - nice hairy legs and the subtle glow of a bit of backlighting - and the flash isn't overpowering at all. Good shot!

Dan
Prieni
Posted 16/11/2006 - 18:21 Link
Thanks Dan,

I had exactly the same problem. Once I opened it in a new window and went back to the thread it was there. Seems like fotocommunity.de is protecting the pic somehow. Will try to link it differently...

Prieni

New try (not sure that link stays permanent; wonderful ways of Google...)
Edit: New try obsolete now as Liam was so kind to host the pic
Daniel Bridge
Posted 16/11/2006 - 18:34 Link
Nope, still not there. Again, could see it by pasting the link into the address bar. Oh, and now it's showing on the baord (with the google address, not the fotocommunity one).

How odd.

Dan
George Lazarette
Posted 16/11/2006 - 18:37 Link
He has a disconcertingly human-looking face. And, like the other, well-lit and very sharp.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Prieni
Posted 16/11/2006 - 18:39 Link
Thanks for hanging in there. I guess both servers are not ideal for that sort of linking. The second one is Picasaweb from Google and I'm not sure that this link is stable.
When I posted the first version (from fotocommunity) the pic would disapear when refreshing the thread page. Had to open it in different tab or window and go back to the thread... voila, there it was again.

Computers, eh...

Prieni
Prieni
Posted 16/11/2006 - 18:41 Link
Quote:
He has a disconcertingly human-looking face. And, like the other, well-lit and very sharp.

G
Guess that's how Spiderman came to life
With the lighting situation I was really lucky...

Prieni
Daniel Bridge
Posted 16/11/2006 - 18:44 Link
Quote:
He has a disconcertingly human-looking face...
Crikey George, wouldn't like to bump into you in a darkened alley!
LiamD
Posted 16/11/2006 - 20:04 Link
Hi Prieni,

I'll happily download your picture and host it from my site's server for you. You can then just change the link in your post, to the one I give you. Obviously, I won't do it unless you give me permission to though.

Cheers

Liam
Liam


"Make your hands respond to what your mind demands." Jesse James

Best wide-angle lens? Two steps backward. Look for the 'ah-ha'. Ernst Haas
George Lazarette
Posted 16/11/2006 - 21:07 Link
Daniel,

I was talking about the spider. My face is so disconcerting, it's barely human at all.

So watch those alleys.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo