blow out skys - how to solve the problem??
Posted 21/11/2007 - 12:26
Link
With reference to the shots you've posted:-
ND Grads (one or more) can help solve the problem if, and only if, the brighter part of the image composition is to one or more edge(s) (top, bottom, right, left). The bright portion of your images is not at one or more edges.
These particular images have a very high dynamic range, and as such would benefit from processing using an HDR dedicated piece of software like Artizen.
Phase One's Capture One V4 (beta) has some HDR capabilities too, as does Sylkipix I believe.
Artizen, for instance requires at least 2 images, one exposed for the highlights, and one exposed for the shadows. It then 'blends' them and requires some use of tone mapping to achieve an acceptible result.
The image on the home page of the above link demonstrates exactly, why you might need to use it (bright outside tunnel, dark inside).
You can also achieve something similar by combining 2 images within Photoshop etc.
The truth is, CCD and CMOS sensors have some way to go before thay can faithfully capture the extreme's of dynamic range that we often encounter.
Hope that helps.
ND Grads (one or more) can help solve the problem if, and only if, the brighter part of the image composition is to one or more edge(s) (top, bottom, right, left). The bright portion of your images is not at one or more edges.
These particular images have a very high dynamic range, and as such would benefit from processing using an HDR dedicated piece of software like Artizen.
Phase One's Capture One V4 (beta) has some HDR capabilities too, as does Sylkipix I believe.
Artizen, for instance requires at least 2 images, one exposed for the highlights, and one exposed for the shadows. It then 'blends' them and requires some use of tone mapping to achieve an acceptible result.
The image on the home page of the above link demonstrates exactly, why you might need to use it (bright outside tunnel, dark inside).
You can also achieve something similar by combining 2 images within Photoshop etc.
The truth is, CCD and CMOS sensors have some way to go before thay can faithfully capture the extreme's of dynamic range that we often encounter.
Hope that helps.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Posted 21/11/2007 - 12:36
Link
The thing is, the shadow detail is still there, even in your "underexposed" one.
This version of it took all of 20 seconds to do, and looks a lot more natural than your merged version:

If you burn out the highlights, they're unrecoverable, so if you want the highlight detail, you have to expose for it.
I'd stop using the exposure compensation, for a start. This "the K10D underexposes in general" view is one I've seen before, and it's far too sweeping a generalisation to be useful, as you're clearly discovering.
You'll notice that not overexposing the highlight detail also avoids the pronounced purple fringing you get in areas of very high contrast.
Edit: it occurs to me that if it's that easy to do in Photoshop, a setting in the K10D's custom menu that let you boost the shadows and/or cut the highlights a bit might be very handy indeed for those that don't want to do too much post-processing. It's often not that the dynamic range isn't there, it's that it isn't rendered sometimes as we expect.
This version of it took all of 20 seconds to do, and looks a lot more natural than your merged version:

If you burn out the highlights, they're unrecoverable, so if you want the highlight detail, you have to expose for it.
I'd stop using the exposure compensation, for a start. This "the K10D underexposes in general" view is one I've seen before, and it's far too sweeping a generalisation to be useful, as you're clearly discovering.
You'll notice that not overexposing the highlight detail also avoids the pronounced purple fringing you get in areas of very high contrast.
Edit: it occurs to me that if it's that easy to do in Photoshop, a setting in the K10D's custom menu that let you boost the shadows and/or cut the highlights a bit might be very handy indeed for those that don't want to do too much post-processing. It's often not that the dynamic range isn't there, it's that it isn't rendered sometimes as we expect.
Posted 21/11/2007 - 13:01
Link
There's a terrific Highlight/Shadow control in PS CS2 that could help.
One answer is to recompose the shot, although that isn't really possible in the example. Here you have a subject in shadow and a bright sky behind. One way might be to light the subject with some flash, which would reduce the exposure for the background. That works for a portrait, but for this large subject you might need very powerful flash to achieve the same.
In any event, Chris A has done a good job for you.
As regards exposure compensation, don't dial it in as standard, that isn't necessary, learn where to use it by accepting what the camera meters at first and then learning where it needs correcting.
One answer is to recompose the shot, although that isn't really possible in the example. Here you have a subject in shadow and a bright sky behind. One way might be to light the subject with some flash, which would reduce the exposure for the background. That works for a portrait, but for this large subject you might need very powerful flash to achieve the same.
In any event, Chris A has done a good job for you.
As regards exposure compensation, don't dial it in as standard, that isn't necessary, learn where to use it by accepting what the camera meters at first and then learning where it needs correcting.
Best regards, John
Posted 21/11/2007 - 13:14
Link
Quote:
There's a terrific Highlight/Shadow control in PS CS2 that could help.
That's all I used. It's easy to overdo it, but often a little is all that's needed.There's a terrific Highlight/Shadow control in PS CS2 that could help.
And that control is in Photoshop Elements too.
Posted 21/11/2007 - 18:27
Link
I am amazed by how many people dial in exposure compensation when they could quite easily use the camera in manual or aperture/shutter priority and use the exp lock before recomposing the image. As has been mentioned exposure compensation dialed in as standard is not a cure all solution. Learn what will fool the meter and adjust exposure accordingly for the result that you want. The shadow/highlight tool is a great start and has brought detail into the shadows for me on many occasions.
Harry
Harry
Posted 21/11/2007 - 21:13
Link
Quote:
I am amazed by how many people dial in exposure compensation when they could quite easily use the camera in manual or aperture/shutter priority and use the exp lock before recomposing the image. As has been mentioned exposure compensation dialed in as standard is not a cure all solution. Learn what will fool the meter and adjust exposure accordingly for the result that you want. The shadow/highlight tool is a great start and has brought detail into the shadows for me on many occasions.
Harry
As usual, it's horses for courses.I am amazed by how many people dial in exposure compensation when they could quite easily use the camera in manual or aperture/shutter priority and use the exp lock before recomposing the image. As has been mentioned exposure compensation dialed in as standard is not a cure all solution. Learn what will fool the meter and adjust exposure accordingly for the result that you want. The shadow/highlight tool is a great start and has brought detail into the shadows for me on many occasions.
Harry
If you have the time to use spot metering and the exposure lock, it can work very nicely and is often the best way.
If on the other hand you are taking action shots in a situation where you know you are likely to under/over expose, a little dialed in exposure compensation drastically improves your hit rate in automatic mode.
I don't advocate dialing it in as a matter of course, but it certainly has it's uses.
you don't have to be mad to post here
but it does help
but it does help
Posted 22/11/2007 - 12:48
Link
Quote:
With reference to the shots you've posted:-
ND Grads (one or more) can help solve the problem if, and only if, the brighter part of the image composition is to one or more edge(s) (top, bottom, right, left). The bright portion of your images is not at one or more edges.
.....
Hope that helps.
All advice helps With reference to the shots you've posted:-
ND Grads (one or more) can help solve the problem if, and only if, the brighter part of the image composition is to one or more edge(s) (top, bottom, right, left). The bright portion of your images is not at one or more edges.
.....
Hope that helps.
If you were strapped for cash, would you buy an ND filter or a CPL filter? I have tried to read about these but I feel straight advice and actually borrowing one is the best way so I can see how my pictures improve (or get worse!).
https://www.flickr.com/photos/_cypher/
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Posted 22/11/2007 - 12:53
Link
Quote:
The thing is, the shadow detail is still there, even in your "underexposed" one.
.....
If you burn out the highlights, they're unrecoverable, so if you want the highlight detail, you have to expose for it.
I'd stop using the exposure compensation, for a start. This "the K10D underexposes in general" view is one I've seen before, and it's far too sweeping a generalisation to be useful, as you're clearly discovering.
You'll notice that not overexposing the highlight detail also avoids the pronounced purple fringing you get in areas of very high contrast.
Edit: it occurs to me that if it's that easy to do in Photoshop, a setting in the K10D's custom menu that let you boost the shadows and/or cut the highlights a bit might be very handy indeed for those that don't want to do too much post-processing. It's often not that the dynamic range isn't there, it's that it isn't rendered sometimes as we expect.
Thanks for showing me what can be one with the photo. The thing is, the shadow detail is still there, even in your "underexposed" one.
.....
If you burn out the highlights, they're unrecoverable, so if you want the highlight detail, you have to expose for it.
I'd stop using the exposure compensation, for a start. This "the K10D underexposes in general" view is one I've seen before, and it's far too sweeping a generalisation to be useful, as you're clearly discovering.
You'll notice that not overexposing the highlight detail also avoids the pronounced purple fringing you get in areas of very high contrast.
Edit: it occurs to me that if it's that easy to do in Photoshop, a setting in the K10D's custom menu that let you boost the shadows and/or cut the highlights a bit might be very handy indeed for those that don't want to do too much post-processing. It's often not that the dynamic range isn't there, it's that it isn't rendered sometimes as we expect.
I would like to give up playing with the ev compensation altogether but i feel the view in the view finder always looks so dark and i end up compensating and then it looks much brighter on my computer screen and blown out. Do you have your lcd brightness set to a brighter level?
https://www.flickr.com/photos/_cypher/
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Posted 22/11/2007 - 12:53
Link
Most effects can be done in Photoshop, so these days I only ever would think about the following filters:
Polariser
Graduated ND
UV or Skylight (to prevent too much blue light scattering around at high altutude, not to protect the lens)
In reality I only ever bother with the polariser and that very rarely.
Polariser
Graduated ND
UV or Skylight (to prevent too much blue light scattering around at high altutude, not to protect the lens)
In reality I only ever bother with the polariser and that very rarely.
Best regards, John
Posted 22/11/2007 - 12:56
Link
Quote:
I am amazed by how many people dial in exposure compensation when they could quite easily use the camera in manual or aperture/shutter priority and use the exp lock before recomposing the image. As has been mentioned exposure compensation dialed in as standard is not a cure all solution. Learn what will fool the meter and adjust exposure accordingly for the result that you want. The shadow/highlight tool is a great start and has brought detail into the shadows for me on many occasions.
Harry
I use Av all the time and when i press the exposure lock nothing seems to happen or maybe i don't know what to look for. Am I doing something wrong? Can you elaborate on how to achieve this. Do you have to use spot metering?
I am amazed by how many people dial in exposure compensation when they could quite easily use the camera in manual or aperture/shutter priority and use the exp lock before recomposing the image. As has been mentioned exposure compensation dialed in as standard is not a cure all solution. Learn what will fool the meter and adjust exposure accordingly for the result that you want. The shadow/highlight tool is a great start and has brought detail into the shadows for me on many occasions.
Harry
https://www.flickr.com/photos/_cypher/
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Posted 22/11/2007 - 13:01
Link
You can use exposure lock on all settings. I couple it to the AF point and lock focus and exposure with a half press of the shutter release.
All it does is lock the exposure, so when you move the camera to recompose the readings will stay the same.
All it does is lock the exposure, so when you move the camera to recompose the readings will stay the same.
Best regards, John
Posted 22/11/2007 - 13:03
Link
I guess what bugs me the most is I have never had this problem before I moved to the K10D. I have been using the Canon S1 IS for about three years and never or very rarely experienced this problem. It is a super zoom glorified point and shoot with many manual options including ev compensation. I could always use the pictures i got from the camera albeit a few contrast adjustments.
I was hoping if I tweaked the jpg setting on the k10d I could more or less use it like a super point and shoot in that I would not have to post process the images or have to do very little post processing. I appreciate the real benefits of a dslr is the picture quality which is much much better and also the fact you can shoot in raw and tweak the images so I do want these features that but not all the time if I can help it.
I will try and take some pictures with both cameras at the same time and post the results. Maybe someone will be able to tell me what i am doing wrong.
I was hoping if I tweaked the jpg setting on the k10d I could more or less use it like a super point and shoot in that I would not have to post process the images or have to do very little post processing. I appreciate the real benefits of a dslr is the picture quality which is much much better and also the fact you can shoot in raw and tweak the images so I do want these features that but not all the time if I can help it.
I will try and take some pictures with both cameras at the same time and post the results. Maybe someone will be able to tell me what i am doing wrong.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/_cypher/
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75
Posted 22/11/2007 - 13:07
Link
Probably look at the Custom Settings menu and set up the camera to do what you want.
It would be interesting to see some pictures, so please do post some.
It would be interesting to see some pictures, so please do post some.
Best regards, John
Posted 22/11/2007 - 13:59
Link
It's best to assume that all your images will benefit form a little tweaking, and then develop a routine that allows you to do this very quickly.
In my early days I used to use the batch-processing feature in Irfanview (free and fast software) to apply common adjustments to a range of similar pictures.
With experience, it took very little time, and the results were immeasurably better than anything one could achieve in-camera.
G
In my early days I used to use the batch-processing feature in Irfanview (free and fast software) to apply common adjustments to a range of similar pictures.
With experience, it took very little time, and the results were immeasurably better than anything one could achieve in-camera.
G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


278 posts
19 years
London,
UK
I have been taking a lot of pictures on cloudy and sunny days and I seem to be getting over exposed/blow out skys consistently. I am finding it quite hard to get the sky and the foreground properly exposed. I am knew to dslr so it could just be part of my learning curve. I have posted two pictures below as an example. Might not be the best examples but I think they explain the problem I am having.
I have read on this forum that the k10d tends to underexpose in general and one should compensate by using +0.3ev or +0.7ev. I tend to use +0.5 e vor +1.0ev in general. Is this alright?
I have also read it is better to underexpose rather than overexpose and someone mentioned they usually drop down to -0.5ev for landscapes. Does that make sense?
I am also wondering if a filter might help me in these situations like an ND or CPL one. What would people suggest?
All pictures are taken with Aperture Priority, Matrix metering, iso 100, f3.5 using the Tamron 18-250 and K10D
Over exposed (1/250)
Under exposed (1/750)
Merged in photomatix [merged 5 in total but the two above were next to each other in bracketing]
Pentax K10D, 50, 18-55, 28-70, 100, Sigma 10-20, Tamron 18-250, 28-75