Amazon Lightning Deals...Predatory Pricing?

DoctorJeff
Posted 07/12/2015 - 22:09 Link
From Amazon's viewpoint, this has very little to do with profit margin.
Any "special offer" is sold at the same price Amazon UK pay for it - the trick is that they buy it from Amazon Luxemburg. So, all the profit is made in Luxemburg where company taxes are lower than here.
Everything else that Amazon UK sell is traded the same way.
If you think that this is verging on sharp practice, just remember that Ford were doing this in reverse with engines and gearboxes from the Bridgend plant back in the 1970s and no-one complained.
It's all about making your profit where you pay the least tax.
Geoff
Water can wear away a stone - but it can't cook lunch
X-5
istDS
K2000
P50.
Lenses Digital: 50-200, 18-55 KAF: 28-80.
Lenses KA & K: SMC-KA f2.0, SMC-K f1.4, SMC-K f1.7 Tokina KA 28-70 , SMC Pentax 70-210 F4, Sigma KA 75-300 , Hanimex 500mm Mirror, and the Tamron Adaptall-2 stuff.
and then there's all the M42 kit, and the accessories ...
johnriley
Posted 07/12/2015 - 22:44 Link
I wonder a little bit why there's a complaint about low prices? Do we want to pay more? Does having a special offer constitute sharp practice? Has nobody ever bought a special offer?

In the same why I wonder why we complain about any company paying less tax. They are obeying the law, so it's up to governments to change the law if it looks to be unfair. I've never volunteered to pay more tax than I have to. Has anyone?

These are just musings with no particular answer.....
Best regards, John
1stEverPentax
Posted 08/12/2015 - 00:10 Link
Geoff, Yes, Luxembourg does appear to be central to this issue. Perhaps it could be broken up as a country and its regions shared out between its immediate neighbours? Just a suggestion...

John...in ten years time when all our independent retailers have gone under and we can only buy from a handful of global retail giants we'll all be paying a lot more for everything because we won't have a choice. This country will have lost the tax revenue from the businesses that have been forced to close down meaning higher taxes to 'compensate' the Treasury and will gain nothing from the Luxembourg based 'shell' companies operating from there.

You're right about this being an issue for Government...I seem to remember our Chancellor making some noises before the General Election...but that's probably the extent of it. It took a very long time before the VAT loophole was closed that allowed retailers to set up in Jersey and Guernsey undercutting mainland dealers. Open, honest competition is fine John...but that is not what we have today.
fatspider
Posted 08/12/2015 - 00:51 Link
As an online retailer myself I know manufacturers occasionally offer special deals to their distributors/retailers I would imagine this is the same no matter what the product.

What the retailer chooses to do with the discount is their business, some may take advantage of the reduced price in order to make a bit more profit, others may simply pass the same discount on to their customers, and then there are those who will try and stuff up their competitors by offering stock at not much more than what it cost them.

How fast the stock is moving can also see retailers selling at rock bottom prices. I've sold stock at below cost price in the past just to get rid of it, sometimes it's all about cash flow, buy 100 items at £1 and sell 99 of them for £1.10 each your still in profit if you put the last one in the dustbin
My Names Alan, and I'm a lensaholic.
My PPG link
My Flckr link
BruceStrachan
Posted 08/12/2015 - 06:26 Link
Some of the Pro dealers do make large profits.
I recently asked for a quote on my K3 fr4om SRS and they offered me only 210 GBP.
At the same time they are selling a second hand one with almost 50% higher shutter count for 379 GBP...
Now that´s more than a healthy profit margin....

You need to be careful, SRS do offer some good services . but I´ve had as good if not better from Microglobe.
Cheers,

Bruce
Chris@SRSWATFORD
Posted 08/12/2015 - 07:01 Link
BruceStrachan wrote:
Some of the Pro dealers do make large profits.
I recently asked for a quote on my K3 fr4om SRS and they offered me only 210 GBP.
At the same time they are selling a second hand one with almost 50% higher shutter count for 379 GBP...
Now that´s more than a healthy profit margin....

You need to be careful, SRS do offer some good services . but I´ve had as good if not better from Microglobe.
This is getting mildly irritating as this is the second time you have got your facts incorrect about this.

As mentioned before we offered you £300 for a K-3. We sell used k-3's for between £419 and £439.

This is not unreasonable....
For all things Pentax please visit www.srsmicrosystems.co.uk - anything not listed please email or call!

Follow us on Facebook
LennyBloke
Posted 08/12/2015 - 08:05 Link
BruceStrachan wrote:
Some of the Pro dealers do make large profits.
I recently asked for a quote on my K3 fr4om SRS and they offered me only 210 GBP.
At the same time they are selling a second hand one with almost 50% higher shutter count for 379 GBP...
Now that´s more than a healthy profit margin....

You need to be careful, SRS do offer some good services . but I´ve had as good if not better from Microglobe.
SRS consistently offer some of the fairest part-exchange prices you'll find at any camera shop. Their profit has to build in factors such as a guarantee, potential repairs (I bet they received a few items with undisclosed faults), market changes (K3 prices will have been impacted by the K3II), they have significant running costs, plus a superb reputation (I've bought a fair few things from them and had problems with 2 items - both were accepted back with no fuss). Those current profits that you perceive can quickly be eroded by new price drops.

I assume you got a better part-exchange price offer from Microglobe than SRS? But I didn't think they offered the 2 year guarantee that SRS do on new items, and I have no personal experience of how they deal with problems, and there are some who've had very negative experiences.
LennyBloke
johnriley
Posted 08/12/2015 - 08:11 Link
Chris gives us a fantastic service and deserves our support and appreciation!
Best regards, John
Marat
Posted 08/12/2015 - 09:26 Link
Well like most I guess you go with the best price offered at any given time whether it's a PX value or a straight sale of a item.

The Internet has widened the market place greatly over the last few years, and it only takes a few minutes in front of a computer to find a deal that suits.

What you can't see on a computer screen is how helpful, thoughtful and knowledgeable a member of staff is and how they deal with after sales, this is where SRS wins hands down.

As a example, I've used the same insurance broker for the last 30 years my whole family use the same also, there family has been friends with our family for even longer, now I can get insurance a lot lot cheaper on line and speak to a call centre many thousands of miles away and save hundreds of pounds in the process, but I know if I have any sort of problem at whatever time, day or night I just have to give them a call and it's sorted 100% zero hassle.

Sometimes service is more important then price.

Bruce in all fairness I would never deal with yourself, as I have seen how you have conducted yourself on the classifieds listings, moaning about members not posting outside the UK and hijacking other members listings with negative comments to promote your own sales, You are the total opposite of what SRS offers.
MrB
Posted 08/12/2015 - 09:31 Link
SRS is local for me and they regularly get my custom, for all the positive reasons given by others here - always exemplary service, and also including fair prices, special offers, and good part-ex deals.

However, Chris and his team live in the real world, where both service and prices are considerations. They will realise that many of their customers are likely to shop around at the time they want an item, and that they might buy a bargain from a different source, even though it might be taking a risk regarding service.

E.g. My 10-17 was from SRS and my 55-300 was not, because at the different times I wanted to purchase them, they were each cheaper (by a big margin) from their different sources, i.e. prices it would have been silly to reject.

I presume that SRS would see this as part of the swings and roundabouts of the business.

Cheers.
Philip
RobL
Posted 08/12/2015 - 09:53 Link
That trade-in SRS is quoting doesn't sound unreasonable considering they need to check, warranty, advertise and make a profit. I recently accepted a trade-in offer for Minox binoculars against new Leica binoculars from another well-known photo supplier, surprised and delighted to see they quoted almost what I bought them for from them six months earlier. After a sixty mile drive they said their quote was in error based on a higher spec. model despite it being correct in my description and their reply; a typical trade-in would be half what I paid for, apparently. Long argument ensued, and eventually settled on a compromise.
Edited by RobL: 08/12/2015 - 09:54
DaveKitson
Posted 08/12/2015 - 10:56 Link
LennyBloke wrote:


SRS consistently offer some of the fairest part-exchange prices you'll find at any camera shop. Their profit has to build in factors such as a guarantee, potential repairs (I bet they received a few items with undisclosed faults), market changes (K3 prices will have been impacted by the K3II), they have significant running costs, plus a superb reputation (I've bought a fair few things from them and had problems with 2 items - both were accepted back with no fuss). Those current profits that you perceive can quickly be eroded by new price drops.
I believe that secondhand goods also attract VAT, so that part of the price of a secondhand item goes to the taxman rather than the dealer..

FWIW; SRS is my go-to dealer for part-X. I have always felt that I have been fairly treated, and their service is first-class.

dave k
1stEverPentax
Posted 08/12/2015 - 11:32 Link
In the past few years i've bought new photographic gear from SRS, Park Cameras and WEX and been very happy with the service and prices from each...and there are other Independents which I might have bought from but they were out of stock or the price was slightly higher than another Independent I was happy to use ...the point is as long as we all value and use these dealers (and they continue to offer great service) then hopefully they will still be around in a few years time.

As I started this thread i'm happy to bring it to a close before it gets any more personal and out of hand! I've made a point I feel strongly about and hopefully others have had their say.

Turning back to the bargain hunting...isn't it normally about now that the Pentax £40 - £80 off offers make a re-appearance on the cheaper bodies and some lenses? !!
johnriley
Posted 08/12/2015 - 14:16 Link
And a reminder that we don't need personal attacks on the forum, so please don't do that.
Best regards, John

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo