Advice would be appreciated

Smeggypants
Posted 12/05/2011 - 21:21 Link
johnriley wrote:
The idea of follow no rules though is not IMHO the right approach. It's only when you understand what the "rules" are that you can break them intentionally to your advantage. Otherwise you are relying on your own vision skills without any guidance.

Smeggypant's images in general, and I hope he will forgive me for using him as an example, do not break the rules, but in fact make highly intelligent use of the rules. They are bold and visually rich, but show me the ones that don't adhere to good principles of composition.

The rules were created after srtists spent many years examining the most favoured paintings of the masters. Why did they work? What made some appeal far more than others? They were found to often fit into certain patterns and these became the rules of composition. It wasn't random.

However, there are other rules that can freely be broken, such as perhaps someone saying, "This isn't a suitable subject for monochrome." To which I would suggest that if done properly and with good reason, that statement is almost always wrong. Yet sometimes we take these things on board without questioning them.

Always question, but don't discard the basic rules of photography unless there's a good reason.
Quite happy to be used as an example John ( and thanks for the compliment )


I've never bothered deliberately learning any rules though. I just snap what I think looks good and muck about later in PP to make it look even better if I can.

I've obviously heard of some 'rules', you can't avoid it at some point, but the only two I can think of is the composition rule of 1/3rds and side subject facing into the frame.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that if you apply an approach of just snapping to what you think looks good then there's no need to learn any rules as you'll end up in the same place anyway.

Once you know a rule it can be hard to break and there's also the subconscious steering you towards the rules. I know this from my Music days. I learned too many rules in music and then discovered that most of the people who wrote great pop music didn't bother with rules and most couldn't even read music.

If you want a good example of how rules can ruin music then look no further than the songs written for the X-Factor winners. Completely and utterly formulaic. I know the formula off by heart, it's many decades old, and I could teach you to write a comparable song in an afternoon.

So when I took up photography properly in 2009 I deliberately said "Bollox to Rules!"
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
Dangermouse
Posted 12/05/2011 - 21:58 Link
I think it's a case of some people not needing rules and others being in dire need of them!

I don't look in viewfinders and consciously think whether the composition meets the rules, I shoot what I think looks good and tend to find that what I consider my best goes down well with others.

Meanwhile you get Kev with his iphone blazing away at everything and getting the reaction of "nice colours..." from people with some artistic taste who're too polite to say it's terrible!
Matt

Shooting the Welsh Wilderness with K-m, KX, MX, ME Super and assorted lenses.
Don
Posted 12/05/2011 - 22:04 Link
let us dispense with the term rules and use instead "Formula" there are formula's that lead to higher ratios of successful images.
I don't care much for rules... it seems to me the kinds of people that demand rules be put in place are usually the first ones to break them, anyways.....
Fired many shots. Didn't kill anything.
Smeggypants
Posted 12/05/2011 - 22:27 Link
Don wrote:
let us dispense with the term rules and use instead "Formula" there are formula's that lead to higher ratios of successful images.
I don't care much for rules... it seems to me the kinds of people that demand rules be put in place are usually the first ones to break them, anyways.....
Formula is probably a better word. But then does anyone really like formulaic photography any more than they like non-formulaic Photography?
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
Smeggypants
Posted 12/05/2011 - 22:30 Link
Dangermouse wrote:
I think it's a case of some people not needing rules and others being in dire need of them!

I don't look in viewfinders and consciously think whether the composition meets the rules, I shoot what I think looks good and tend to find that what I consider my best goes down well with others.

Meanwhile you get Kev with his iphone blazing away at everything and getting the reaction of "nice colours..." from people with some artistic taste who're too polite to say it's terrible!
I see some really mediocre photography on Facebook ( not record the moment phone snaps but where the photographer has a reasonable camera and has made an attempt at actual photography ) and they've received some very favourable comments. Really bad sunsets seem to attract the polite wow comments.
[i]Bodies: 1x K-5IIs, 2x K-5, Sony TX-5, Nokia 808
Lenses: Pentax DA 10-17mm ED(IF) Fish Eye, Pentax DA 14mm f/2.8, Sigma 17-70mm f/2.8, Pentax-A 28mm f/2.8, Sigma 30mm F1.4 EX DC, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.2, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-FA 50mm f/1.4, Pentax-A 50mm f/1.7, Pentax DA* 50-135mm f/2.8, Sigma 135-400mm APO DG, and more ..
Flash: AF-540FGZ, Vivitar 283
moose
Posted 13/05/2011 - 09:52 Link
Rules or formulae are useful to guide us to better images. For some there is little need to refer to the 'rules', as they have an intuitive feel for what is right. There are also those who struggle with an instinctive approach and require a mental check list to aid composition etc.
Most of us fall somewhere between the two. Too much attention to 'rules' can stifle creativity, yet thoughtless spontaneity can result in images that could be much better.
I guess the problem is that it is easier to learn to improve our craft rather than our art. Those who I most admire have both raw ability but are also excellent technicians.

neville
Edited by moose: 13/05/2011 - 09:53
japers45
Posted 13/05/2011 - 11:13 Link
All good advice. I have already purchase PSE9 and have used the ACR application. May just stick with this for now- I guess photo mags are a bit like newspapers- you can't believe all that you read.B&W interests me so i will definatley takin a look at the mag recommended.

Thanks for all your help.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo