Weekly Competition #5 - "Self Portrait"

  • Topic Locked - You will not be able to post to this topic.
HowardJ
Posted 05/08/2007 - 20:12 Link
A shadow of my former self

Comment Image


and breaking a few rules




Howard
Cymru Am Byth
johnriley
Posted 06/08/2007 - 07:49 Link
We now await the Judgement with bated breath!
Best regards, John
Daniel Bridge
Posted 06/08/2007 - 19:17 Link
This is HARD!

Just to let you all know I haven't forgotten, but haven't been in from work long and am cooking tea.

Will post my 'Judgement' as soon as I can, but it's tricky weighing up the pros and cons, especially the balance between the emotional and technical aspects...

Be back soon.
Dan
K-3, a macro lens and a DA*300mm...
justgetoutandride
Posted 06/08/2007 - 20:14 Link
Just pick mine Dan, save yourself a lot of trouble.

Please call me aj,

I use a Pentax K10D, on a MacBook with LightRoom (vers 1.3 + beta 2)

http://www.ba-joseph.co.uk/gallery
Tyr
Posted 06/08/2007 - 20:28 Link
Quote:
This is HARD!

Just to let you all know I haven't forgotten, but haven't been in from work long and am cooking tea.

Will post my 'Judgement' as soon as I can, but it's tricky weighing up the pros and cons, especially the balance between the emotional and technical aspects...

Be back soon.
Dan
I'm glad I'm not in your position at the moment. Just don't pick mine as I'll be in the same position next week then
ChrisA
Posted 06/08/2007 - 20:40 Link
Can't he eat a bit quicker?
Tyr
Posted 06/08/2007 - 20:44 Link
Quote:
Can't he eat a bit quicker?
Perhaps he is looking over them while eating dinner to really digest all there is
Daniel Bridge
Posted 06/08/2007 - 21:08 Link
Nearly ready.

Dan
K-3, a macro lens and a DA*300mm...
Daniel Bridge
Posted 06/08/2007 - 21:41 Link
Well here goes, sorry to those that put lots of effort in and didn't win, it was, as I said, really hard to judge.

Probably more so as portraits are not my favourite subject. But I wanted to pick something that I wasn't necessarily going to compare to my own efforts, and that I thought would make you think a bit differently, as I rightly guessed lots of you wouldn't want a straight shot of your face.

Read on, and apologies again, but it's obviously nothing personal...


Don: Beautifully controlled lighting (3 lights?), and a great look about it, very much like a still/promo from a gangster film. Feel a bit wary saying anything negative, but appreciate we're on opposite sides of the Atlantic. (Just hope you don't have 'friends' over here...). I find the blue light on the background a little overpowering, and the look on yourface, through the smoke, not quite right (sorry can't explain it more than that, but I reckon he might be concentrating on his macbook...). Other than that, I think it's a superb image - technically the best, but it's my Second Place!

Amoringello: Really well done composite (please tell me it's not a straight shot ) - I like the idea, and the execution, slightly disconcerting that you've got two left ears, but nice none-the-less. Only thing I don't like about it is the photoshop filter (brushstrokes? Poster?) I think that detracts rather than enhances. Great effort though. Highly Commended.

Dirk1000: Another well thought out idea, and I prefer the amended version to the original. I now see it as a morning, noon and night shot (whether that's your intention or not), before it looked as though all shots were supposed to be the same. However, the main image doesn't look sharp enough on your face to me.

ChrisA: I like this, not from a technical point of view, but because it looks as though you're smiling. I find the double reflection in the LCD screen detracts from what could have been a better looking overall image (makes the 'subject' seem out of focus, even though I don't think it is), but again, a good idea well done.

Prieni: This could have been the winner, if it hadn't been for that reflection which I think isn't needed. I know it's the Pentax User logo, but we all know where we are, and I think it would have been a great image without it. The coloured logo is at odds with the sepia tone of the rest of the pic. Third Place.

Zach Abubeker: Sorry Zach, but that's just too small an image to base an opinion on - can't tell whether that's a shadow, or a composite or what...

Clarky (or should I call you Mr. Oddie?): Getting bored of myself saying 'nice idea', but here I go again. Nice idea, but could be sharper, and white balance needs sorting. And the lighting. But I liked it - it made me smile.

Justgetoutandride: Well done for entering! Nicely concieved (as a change from 'nice idea'), perhaps not as technically proficient as Don's... But, it shows something of the man, not just an image - he's drinking water and eating a healthy snack, so he take's care of himself (Don, take note ). Pose could be better though - do you always have a snack pressed to your cheek?

Galoot: Really well done. Not a nice idea - a great idea! If I'd done it, I would have been tempted to do more with the photoshop work to get the newspaper part looking less 'stuck on', but I don't think that would have necessarily made it better. At the risk of a flood of complaints from furious members, it's my Winner of the Week! Amusing, with eye contact!

Lenscape: I hope you weren't riding over the speed limit and taking pics of yourself at the same time...? Like Justgetoutandride, you've given us a image that shows us what you do, or what you enjoy. Well executed with a mix of lighting to balance, and timed well to have the 'slow down' sign showing. Wondering now why that's blurred... Highly commended (but I don't condone speeding!)

Kcmadr: A nicely exposed (bearing in mind the areas in shadow and sunlight), that has a slightly abstract feel to it. However my eyes get drawn to the black and yellow shape on the right hand side, and also to the dust-spot top left, and I don't think I see enough of you for it to really engage me.

Pschlute: I like the pose, I like the lighting, but I don't like the 'filter' applied. Makes it look as though you've got really dirty hands. And neck. And ears. I feel it would have been a lot better without it, but the lack of eye contact would have prevented it being in the top three anyway.

Lilly: Again a nice looking image that I feel is spoilt by the filter - nice touch with the green eyes, but I can't help thinking your avatar looks better composed, and the eye contact (with slightly more controlled hair, I do find it a bit distracting) improves it.

Legasso: I think this would have looked a lot better with different lighting. Using the lights above the mirror with more subtle fill-in would have improved it, I feel. Was a little confused as the subject seems a little at odds with your entry in the previous ('flight') competition, but I'm guessing that was just a mis-typing. I'm a little put off by the angle of the reflection, I'm just picky like this, but if this were a true reflection, the angles would be different, if you see what I mean.

Tyr: Now this is really nicely done too, good range of tones, nice lighting, strong eye contact, what more could I ask for? Not sure really, and looking back I find it hard to justify why I would pick Galoot's entry over this (or any of the others), but I like the humour in Galoot's, and I'm not so keen on the look of this. One thing that stands out as being 'wrong' is that the nearest eye (your left) is out of focus, the right eye's sharp. This gives the immediate impression to me that the shot is out of focus, and for a technically good image like this I think that jars a bit, and may explain why I'm not so keen. It might be the hat though . Highly Commended.

HowardJ: I like the diagonal composition, but feel the exposure could have been better. Cloning top right is a little obvious too.


Well there you go, sorry Tyr (especially), as I think you might have thought you'd do better (and with a different judge you probably would), but I've judged it as I've seen them and now it's Galoot's turn.

Glad I'm not doing this again! Almost enough to stop me entering.

Dan
K-3, a macro lens and a DA*300mm...
johnriley
Posted 06/08/2007 - 21:47 Link
Brilliant! A fantastic evaluation, and it wasn't an easy one to do. Very well done to all, but especially to our winner, Galoot.

So, Galoot, you know what you have to do....we await your challenge!

Best regards, John
lenscape
Posted 06/08/2007 - 22:10 Link
Congratulations to Galoot.

Interesting use of blatant suggestion!

Dan - just to put your mind at ease: the bike was stationary at the time.

Looking forward to the next one.
lenscape
K20D, K10D, K-m, MZ3, Metz 58-AF1, Optio MX4 & Linux.(No Windows)
(Gone: *istD, ME Super, Super-A)
amoringello
Posted 06/08/2007 - 22:11 Link
Just have to say "I'm furious"!

Congratulations Galoot!

Honestly, I do not envy the task you have ahead of ya.
The choices seem to be growing and becoming more difficult on the judge each week.

Can't wait to see what you have in store for the next one.
Daniel Bridge
Posted 06/08/2007 - 22:15 Link
Quote:
Interesting use of blatant suggestion!
Yes, I did wonder about that...

Dan
K-3, a macro lens and a DA*300mm...
Tyr
Posted 06/08/2007 - 22:18 Link
I am not dissapointed, getting the correct AF point over my eye and not moving was very hard. I actually thought that Lilly and Lenscape had the best shots. Composition on both was good as were the surrounding images. It shows enough and are both very well thought out.

Now for the main part... It is an outrage that Galoot won this! It must not stand Hehe...

There are a couple of other things I'm not pleased with in my shot.

Armongello, the two left ears are quite disconcerting.

I was not fond of the reflection in Prieni's picture either. Pentax isn't paying for the advert Good image though. Thought it was in with a chance.

I actually liked the black lines filter. Looks a bit like what happens when you oversharpen. Liked the angle as it was effective.

Congratulations Galoot, what is the next challenge?
dirk1000
Posted 06/08/2007 - 22:18 Link
Congratulations Galoot!

I also think you’re the best.

But, as you can read in “The Inverness Courier” newspaper, I´m furious and complaints flood in!

Please, take the next theme with charity.

Dan, you made justice. Good critiques.

Best regards.

_______________

Dirk TROTTEYN.
K10D+ Sigma 18-50 1:2.8 EX DC Lens.

Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo