50mm vs 100mm for macro

adwb
Posted 14/10/2009 - 01:00 Link
Hi I need advice from those wiser than me , which is plenty of you!!
I have a kit 18-50 A/F lens supplied with my camera which is fine for close up images of flowers and other large object that don't get frightened by a lens looming in at them.
But I would like to try to capture insects, spiders and ladybirds and the like which are small and need a 1:1 macro or better, or so I understand.
It seems since I cannot afford a new 1:1 macro lens that I have choice.
Get an A series 50mm 2.8 [which I understand from another post is better than the 1.4 for this due to the construction] and try it with an extension or reversing ring both of which I have, these 50mm seem to be plentiful and cheap from various sources, or
to wait and try to find A series 100mm macro which will allow some distance to be maintained from the insect ,
comments , thoughts , and advice please as I really can't afford to buy lenses that won't do the job.
Alistair
Assorted Pentax bodies and lenses as well as Sony and Olympus kit
Mannesty
Posted 14/10/2009 - 06:59 Link
There are some fans of short macro lenses here but I much prefer the longer ones. 100mm and 180mm being my most used macro lenses.

The longer lenses allow you to maintain a bit of distance between you and your subject which means, in a lot of cases, your subject may still be there when you are ready to press the shutter release.

The SMCP-A 50mm 1:2.8 lens you mention is almost certainly a macro lens and therefore will not be cheap, but manual focus is OK. Close macro work usually requires you to use MF anyway.

You would do well to consider the Sigma & Tamron macro lenses, they are cheaper than Pentax lenses and produce outstanding results.

My recommendation would be to wait for a macro lens having a minimum focal length of 90mm for the Sigma/Tamron lenses, or 100mm for a SMCP-F/FA Pentax lens.
Peter E Smith - flickr Photostream
Thordell
Posted 14/10/2009 - 07:27 Link
Yes, I prefer the longer ones too and use a Sigma 105mm, gives you so much more scope and makes the DOF easier to deal with.
Jackie H
K7, K20D, istDS, Optio SV, ME
Most used glass
50mm f1.4, 60-250mm, 28-80mm,
Sigma 105mm 2.8 Macro & Bertha 50-500
johnriley
Posted 14/10/2009 - 08:20 Link
I have always preferred 100mm macro lenses and this must be fairly general as there are always more of them to be found than the 50mm ones.
Best regards, John
adwb
Posted 14/10/2009 - 11:33 Link
Thank you for your replies it seems that 100mm macro or with a macro add apter of a type is the consensus
thanks
Alistair
Assorted Pentax bodies and lenses as well as Sony and Olympus kit
George Lazarette
Posted 14/10/2009 - 11:45 Link
For live things and little things, use 100mm or more.

For larger things and documents, 50mm is fine.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
awaldram
Posted 14/10/2009 - 20:49 Link
Never quite understood the greater working distance argument.

105 mm min working distance = 12inches
50mm min working distance = 7.4 inches

105 lens = 3.8 inches long
50 lens = 2.5 inches long

so from the font element 50mm is 4.9inches and the 105 is 8.2 .

not sure 3inches will stop the bug running away
George Lazarette
Posted 14/10/2009 - 21:03 Link
When you talk in inches it doesn't sound much. But the difference is about 37%, and if the object is only half an inch long, three inches is a long way.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
Thordell
Posted 14/10/2009 - 22:15 Link
George Lazarette wrote:
For live things and little things, use 100mm or more.

For larger things and documents, 50mm is fine.

G
for larger things like hands and faces also documents a prime 50mm works as well as a macro. Think in general we do not take shots as close as is possible but would rather move away as far as possible as long as we can fill the frame. Of course if you want more than 1.1 you need something different and not a macro lens at all.
Jackie H
K7, K20D, istDS, Optio SV, ME
Most used glass
50mm f1.4, 60-250mm, 28-80mm,
Sigma 105mm 2.8 Macro & Bertha 50-500

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo