50mm Lenses

johnriley
Posted 08/09/2009 - 19:49 Link
I have in front of me the 13 issues of Creative Photography from 1981/1982. The thing still of interest here is the extensive lens tests included, which I think were originally produced by a Swiss magazine.

The X-Ray photographs of Pentax, Leica, Nikon and Canon 50mm lenses are interesting in that the canon stands out as being almost totally plastic. All the others are held together with a mass of metal under the plastic exteriors. The designs are very different for sure!

The tests measure many things, such as MTF values at 10, 20 and 40 lpm, MTF graphs, decentering, distortion and MTF graphs as well.

I'm going to follow up this post with a few figures for you. These are what I really call lens tests!
Best regards, John
johnriley
Posted 08/09/2009 - 19:57 Link
Average decentering figures for some 50mm lenses:

Canon f1.8 8%
Chinon f1.7 5%
Konica Hexanon f1.7 5%
Konica Hexanon 40mm f1.8 15%
Leitz Summicron-M f2 16%
Leitz Summicron-R f2 3%
Minolta Rokkor f1.7 15%
Nikkor f1.8 12%
Nikon Series E f1.8 7%
Olympus Zuiko f1.8 8%
Pentax-M f1.7 2%
Pentax-M f2 6%
Pentax-M 40mm f2.8 12%
Ricoh Rikenon f1.7 13%
Zeiss Planar f1.7 3%

Then the f1.4 lenses:
Nikkor: 5%
Zuiko 7% Pentax-M 11%
Rikenon 7%
Zeiss Planar 8%

And the f1.2 lenses:
Canon 9%
Canon L 7%
Hexanon 7%
Leitz Noctilux f1 5%
Rokkor 16%
Nikkor 2%
Noct-Nikkor 5%
Zuiko 5%
Pentax-M 1%
Best regards, John
johnriley
Posted 08/09/2009 - 20:00 Link
Those figures show the accuracy of centering of the elements. I'll leave it at that for now while we absorb that information.

Clearly the star is the SMC Pentax-M 50mm f1.2, with virtually perfect construction.
Best regards, John
thoramay
Posted 08/09/2009 - 20:03 Link
Interesting, john...but what is decentering. How is it relevant to our lens, please?
George Lazarette
Posted 08/09/2009 - 20:03 Link
Interesting. The Summicron is equal worst.

Was Pentax-M f1.2 a typo?

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
George Lazarette
Posted 08/09/2009 - 20:05 Link
johnriley wrote:
Clearly the star is the SMC Pentax-M 50mm f1.2, with virtually perfect construction.
You'd expect perfection from a mythical lens. As this was 1980/81, the lens should have been a K.

G
Keywords: Charming, polite, and generally agreeable.
stevejcoe
Posted 08/09/2009 - 20:23 Link
Thanks for that John, I admit to being a data junkie and these sort of things really interest me.
It is this sort of in depth information that I would dearly like to see in the lens database that I mentioned in the 'mentoring thread'

Regards Steve
johnriley
Posted 08/09/2009 - 20:30 Link
Yes, the f1.2 was the K lens. My typo, not the magazine's!

To explain decentering, when lenses are made up of many elements these elements need to be in the correct locations and their centres lined up perfectly. Decentering can be measured and shows how far out of line some of the elements are. The higher the figure, the worse the lens.

5% is very acceptable in any lens.
Best regards, John
johnriley
Posted 08/09/2009 - 20:40 Link
Out of this mass of information then, the percentage MTF value for a few lenses at 10 lpm and two stops down. This shows the high contrast performance of a lens rather than the detail resolution.

f1.7/f2 lenses:
Canon 93%
Chinon 91%
Hexanon f1.7 89%
Hexanon 40mm f1.8 85%
Summicron-M 94%
Summicron-R 95%
Rokkor f1.7 91%
Nikkor 93%
Nikon Series E 93%
Zuiko 94%
Pentax f1.7 91%
Pentax f2 91%
Pentax 40mm f2.8 93%
Ricoh f1.7 88%
Planar 92%

f1.4 lenses:
Canon 87%
Chinon 87%
Hexanon 86%
Summilux-M 88%
Summilux-R 90%
Rokkor 89%
Nikkor 89%
Zuiko 87%
Pentax 83%
Ricoh 99%
Planar 88%

f1.2 lenses:
Canon 81%
Canon L 80%
Noctilux 73%
Rokkor 83%
Nikkor 74%
Noct-Nikkor 80%
Zuiko 90%
Pentax 75%
Best regards, John
johnriley
Posted 09/09/2009 - 10:58 Link
I'm now going to take that list and add a second % figure - this is the 40 lpm MTF figure and indicates the detailed resolution performance two stops down.

f1.7/f2 lenses:
Canon 93% 60%
Chinon 91% 42%
Hexanon f1.7 89% 51%
Hexanon 40mm f1.8 85% 34%
Summicron-M 94% 59%
Summicron-R 95% 58%
Rokkor f1.7 91% 44%
Nikkor 93% 59%
Nikon Series E 93% 50%
Zuiko 94% 60%
Pentax f1.7 91% 42%
Pentax f2 91% 44%
Pentax 40mm f2.8 93% 59%
Ricoh f1.7 88% 46%
Planar 92% 59%

f1.4 lenses:
Canon 87% 44%
Chinon 87% 34%
Hexanon 86% 37%
Summilux-M 88% 38%
Summilux-R 90% 43%
Rokkor 89% 46%
Nikkor 89% 48%
Zuiko 87% 37%
Pentax 83% 40%
Ricoh 99% 52%
Planar 88% 51%

f1.2 lenses:
Canon 81% 31%
Canon L 80% 33%
Noctilux 73% 22%
Rokkor 83% 35%
Nikkor 74% 28%
Noct-Nikkor 80% 30%
Zuiko 90% 46%
Pentax 75% 25%
Best regards, John
johnriley
Posted 09/09/2009 - 11:13 Link
There's a lot if info there for those who can decipher it. It only so far tells part of the story, and to put that into perspective lets take the SMC Pentax 50mm f1.2 which apparently has very poor results...and yet I still want one.

This is where we need to look at the decisions a lens designer makes. Everything is a compromise. Without resorting to aspheric elements (as in the Nikkors) what are the parameters for this Pentax lens?

First it has exemplary control of coma, even at open aperture. Coma is where point light sources are reproduced as smears and oblongs. Will we have point light solurces in images shot with an f1.2 lens? Very probably, and this lens caters for that.

Second what aperture will the lens be used at and for what purpose. In fact, maybe low light hand held shooting for which f1.2 gives us a really bright viewfinder image. Or maybe on a tripod at f8 in reality most of the time. At f8 the lens is as good in terms of resolution as the other 50mm lenses, not shown in these figures, so Pentax were thinking we will expect a cracking good lens when it's stopped down. They may be right.

What will be certain is that flatness of field will be out the window, so not a lens for use on bellows. And yet a slightly soft at f1.2 lens might be very nice for portraiture or flower studies...every lens "fault" has a potential for something.

Apparently it's better than the Leitz Noctilux from the figures quoted (£7000 anyone?) so there is more to lens tests than meets the eye.

Approach them with caution, especially the magazine ones that are really reviews rather than tests.
Best regards, John
Edited by johnriley: 09/09/2009 - 11:15
Father Ted
Posted 09/09/2009 - 12:14 Link
OK...I read...gagagaga

Sorry
johnriley wrote:


To explain decentering, when lenses are made up of many elements these elements need to be in the correct locations and their centres lined up perfectly. Decentering can be measured and shows how far out of line some of the elements are. The higher the figure, the worse the lens.
Is that what leads to chromatic abberation?

johnriley wrote:
I'm now going to take that list and add a second % figure - this is the 40 lpm MTF figure and indicates the detailed resolution performance two stops down.
You've totally lost me. What is MTL?

Sorry if this should be common knowledge
Getting there! Thanks to you guys

Pentax K3ii, Pentax K10d, Kit lens ( 18-55mm ), 50mm f1.7 lens, Tamron 70-300mm lens, Prinzflex 70-162 manual lens, Various old flashes.
johnriley
Posted 09/09/2009 - 12:27 Link
MTF is modulation transfer function, an electronic way to express resolution. A target which cosists of black and white patterns starts off as having 100% contrast. A machine can read the image at the film/sensor plane to see how much of that contrast gets through the lens intact. If the figure was 50% then the contrast has halved.

The target that is 10 lines per mm (lpm) gives us a guide to how contrasty a lens is.

The target at some other value (40 lpm here, a very challenging test) tells us how much fine detail can be reproduced.

So a lens with 95% at 10 lpm and 22% at 40 lpm is very contrasty but of low detail resolution.
Best regards, John
johnriley
Posted 09/09/2009 - 12:30 Link
Decentering affects sharpness and resolution as the lens is not made as well as it should be. The elements are not fitted together perfectly.

This is why I don't like casual dismantling of lenses - without the proper kit it's not possible to guarantee that the recentering is accurate. Also overtightening an element will distort the shape of the soft glass.
Best regards, John
thoramay
Posted 09/09/2009 - 18:27 Link
Thanks for the explanation, John. My curiosity is crushed and my mental powers exceeded....and I am no wiser, but should I be. I am amazed at the extent you Pentofiles delve into your equipment. If I take a pic and it isn't just so, I blame myself. Maybe I should be looking at my equipment instead!!!

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.



Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo