Weekly Competition #350 - A Blot On The Landscape Competition

Title Weekly Competition #350 - A Blot On The Landscape
Judge davidstorm
Closing Date 30/03/2014
Opting Out If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest.
Description
Hello everyone! For this week's competition, the theme is 'A Blot On The Landscape', which means exactly what it says! I would like to see images of things which you perceive to be an eyesore and which are spoiling an otherwise beautiful view. This could mean an ugly building among lots of beautiful buildings, an ugly building in a beautiful landscape, an object spoiling a lovely view, rubbish in the countryside or anything else that would fit with the title. As always, images must be shot on Pentax cameras (or their Samsung equivalents), there is no restriction on when the images were shot.

I am looking here not for the most ugly things in the most beautiful locations, but for the way in which they have been photographed to convey why they are 'a blot on the landscape'.

Good luck everyone, I hope to have lots of good entries to judge!

Best wishes
David

Winning Photograph


Competition Entries

Photographs uploaded to the Weekly Competition #350 - A Blot On The Landscape competition.

davidstorm
Posted 31/03/2014 - 00:11 Link
Hi all, very many thanks for your entries in what was probably quite a tough subject this week. I found judging this quite fascinating due to the diversity of interpretations on the theme, from a relatively small number of images. Here are my thoughts on the entries:

Perspicador - Fog of light
I can understand why this one was entered, the right background is essential for a successful macro image and the light does indeed spoil it but I'm not sure that this qualifies as a blot on the landscape as such. A good effort however and deserves credit for 'thinking out of the box'.

John Riley - Echoes of time past
Wow, that certainly qualifies as a blot! It seems like a scene of total dereliction, which is a shame if it once was a nice place. The photo certainly tells its story, I do wonder whether an angle slightly more from the left would have given a better lead-in for the eye and would also have avoided the white bucket cutting the edge of the frame. A good documentary image, also it is sharp, well exposed and fits the competition brief perfectly.

Northgrain - Dounreay
A wide, sweeping panorama in this shot which succeeds in fitting the competition brief with two different subjects that many would consider as a 'blot' - firstly the Nuclear Power Station and secondly the Wind Farm! The image itself is very pleasing, I do feel that despite its panoramic format it has a little too much foreground and this detracts a bit from its impact. A very good shot nevertheless.

Tyronet2000 - The Pylon and Power Lines
Good structure and composition to this image, I like the reflection of the pylon in the water. The shot could have so much more to give though, if only it was a bit less dark. The details in the foreground and background are obscured to an extent by the dark exposure, this may be intentional but I would prefer it to be exposed a bit more.

Gravelrash - Under the Spotlight
I really do like this image. It is stretching it a bit to call the buildings on the horizon a 'blot on the landscape' as I think they actually add so much to this shot. In this image, I like the dark exposure, due to the subject and composition it needs this to have impact and to me it works so well. I also like the letterbox format, although if it were my shot I might be tempted to crop the right hand side a bit, but this is not a criticism. All in all a great image.

Davidtrout - Heavy Industry
Another great shot that I really like! There is so much going on here for the eye to visit, the industrial buildings are very prominent and the smoke / steam rising from the chinmeys adds so much atmosphere to the overall image. This would have been enough for me, but to cap it off there's a boat and a bird perfectly positioned in the frame too! Great colours, great composition and great atmosphere.

Billyspad - Coke on the rocks
I hate to see plastic bottles on a beach! They are so bad for the environment and are a scourge of our modern way of life. A clever idea to use the bottle as foreground interest in this image. I'm not sure that HDR adds anything to it as there are not massive extremes of dynamic range in this shot, but the HDR effect is subtle so it does not really detract either. A nice shot, well executed.

Nicesparky - Flotsam Cramond Beach
I wonder whether flotsam on a beach is actually something quite nice? To me, the rogue element in this image is the chocolate bar wrapper, not the flotsam! Regarding the image itself, I think it needs something more to make it 'pop', maybe a wider aperture could have been used to add some selective focus and a touch more contrast would not go amiss. I think this shot would also suit a BW conversion.

Paulb531 - After the Flood
Another great image that I really like. The subject here is quite special, it really does tell a story and also makes a great photo. I like the contrast of warm red against the cool background tones and also like the way Paul has used the stones as a lead-in. Well done Paul, a fantastic entry.

Aliengrove - Bhopal
An intriguing image - masses of detail and a trademark Aliengrove shot! The only problem I have with this one is that it is not obvious what the subject is as the shot is taken from such a height that it could be almost anywhere. This is no criticism of the image itself, it's just that it's hard to see why this place is a blot on the landscape and for this reason it doesn't have the instant impact that some of the others in this week's competition do.

Jim-w - Tunisian Graffiti
This is a shot that I really like! Normally I am a stickler for level horizons, so I would be inclined to shout 'NO' at an image like this, but the tilt actually plays so well here and enhances the feel of the shot. I don't know if it is intentional or not, but it works for me! I love the subject matter and the processing brings out the best in the shot. Well done!

Ken2390 - Building Site
I really feel for you Ken! This really is an eyesore, why has no-one cleaned it up? The image graphically demonstrates the way this spoils the environment, if I had a slight criticism it would be that it needs a small crop at the bottom to remove some of the 'dead space'. Thanks for sharing this with us.

Wendy - A very welcome blot on are landscape
I do hope the passenger is OK! I think the helicopter is an enhancement here rather than an eyesore! I think the image could have done with a bit of re-framing, there's a little too much space at the bottom and not enough at the top, which makes it look a bit unbalanced. Great subject though!

Noelcmn - Building blots
A fascinating story behind this shot, I am very fond of the natural environment and feel it is important that we preserve the last natural outposts, so any threat to them always gets my attention. The shot itself is well framed and competently taken but doesn't have the wow factor for me.

Hullman - Drax Power Station
Another great shot with an industrial backdrop - these installations certainly make for dramatic photography, especially at sunset or in inclement weather. I like this image, but there's something a bit odd going on with the colour balance; there's a lot of magenta in the steam which isn't reflected in the colour of the sky behind, I'm a bit puzzled as to why? Great drama though and a good shot.

The results are:

1st Place: Davidtrout - Heavy Industry

2nd equal Place: Gravelrash - Under the Spotlight, Paulb531 - After the flood

3rd Place: Jim-w - Tunisian Graffiti

HC's: Aliengrove - Bhopal, Ken2390 - Building Site

Thanks once more to everyone who entered!

Regards
David
Edited by davidstorm: 31/03/2014 - 00:15
Northgrain
Posted 31/03/2014 - 00:17 Link
Instant judging! Top stuff David.

Congrats DavidT and all the placings. Really interesting theme.
tyronet2000
Posted 31/03/2014 - 08:03 Link
Congratulations to the Winner and other places. Thanks to David for the interesting subject, the judging and constructive comments.
Regards
Stan

PPG
Noelcmn
Posted 31/03/2014 - 08:06 Link
Congratulations Davidtrout! Super Shot and worthy winner. Congrats too to the 2nd and 3rd spots and the HC'c. Thanks David for an interesting challenge which, besides being challenging, was also very interesting.
davidtrout
Posted 31/03/2014 - 09:03 Link
Many thanks for an interesting subject and your expert opinions David. There were some fine entries so it was a pleasant surprise for me to win. Congratulations to those with whom I shared the podium and the HCs.
You and some of your colleagues who live in and around the Peak District are masters of landscape photography whereas I'm more of an urban animal. But the impact of heavy industry on the landscape has always fascinated me so I loved this competition.
David

PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtrout
paulb531
Posted 31/03/2014 - 12:21 Link
Many thanks David for a thought provoking subject and good feedback. A lot of great photos and congratulations David Trout the worthy winner.

Regards

Paul
aliengrove
Posted 31/03/2014 - 13:05 Link
Congratulations David, Gravelrash and jim-w, and my fellow HC's! Great comp and judging!
Jim-w
Posted 31/03/2014 - 18:23 Link
Well done to David T for the win, beautiful image and well done to the mentions and everyone else.
Thanks to David S for the comp and judging and my 3rd place , I thought this was quite a tricky competition as I guess most of the time people try to avoid photographing the "blot" on the landscape.
David the angle of my shot was not deliberate but with a slight crop the wall and path went nicely corner to corner so I left it

Jim.
ken2390
Posted 31/03/2014 - 20:14 Link
Just got in and seen the results. Well done the Winner and runner ups. Must say I was pleasantly surprised at getting an H C. The owner of the Mobile site has been promising for over 5 yrs now that the spoils will be moved. As I said,(one day).Have taken note of your comment David and shall act on it. Thank you again. Ken
Gravelrash
Posted 01/04/2014 - 00:58 Link
I'm flattered with the joint 2nd place. Cheers.

David's picture is a well deserved win. Would have been my choice too.

Thank you for the critique and the time you have taken for all of us.
Steve

Sometimes I'm serious and sometimes not, but I consider sarcasm an artform. Which is it today?

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo