Weekly competition #279 Street photgraphy Competition
| Title | Weekly competition #279 Street photgraphy |
|---|---|
| Judge | davidtrout | Closing Date | 18/11/2012 | Opting Out | If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest. |
| Description | |
The list of previous weekly subjects that Glyn has kept updated shows that so many subjects have been used already that its difficult to come up with an original one that isn't too obscure. However I see no disgrace in re visiting a previous topic, providing it wasn't too recent. So I'm going for Street Photography which is currently very popular among photographers and a subject I love. For guidance: Street photography doesn't mean just taking photographs of streets. There must be human presence, unposed and caught candidly to display, juxtaposition, scale, poignancy or humour etc. The rest is up to you. David PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtrout |
|
Winning Photograph
Competition Entries
Photographs uploaded to the Weekly competition #279 Street photgraphy competition.
Posted 19/11/2012 - 07:25
Link
Great judging, David, and congrats to all the podium places, especially ReklawyksEkul for his excellent winning shot, what wonderful lighting, composition and technique.Thanks for the HC and congrats too to my fellow HC'er's! This is the first comp I've entered in a while due to work commitments, hopefully I'll be a more regular contributor again.
Posted 19/11/2012 - 09:13
Link
I have come to enjoy street photography relatively recently and your comments, David, have been very instructive and useful !
Congratulations to the winner for a superb shot - I loved it.
Congratulations to the winner for a superb shot - I loved it.
Posted 19/11/2012 - 09:45
Link
Congratulations ReklawyksEkul-that is a lovely image.
Thanks for judging David.
An honest question? The brief-where the human presence should be prominent- seems to be rather absent from the winning photo. Not that I have a problem with the winning shot, its excellent. It just does not seemt to fit the brief. The human element is factually very small ratio-wise to the rest of the street and the buildings.
Thanks for judging David.
An honest question? The brief-where the human presence should be prominent- seems to be rather absent from the winning photo. Not that I have a problem with the winning shot, its excellent. It just does not seemt to fit the brief. The human element is factually very small ratio-wise to the rest of the street and the buildings.
Posted 19/11/2012 - 10:15
Link
Excellent comp and judging David. Congrats to the winner, well deserved, and all places and HC's. It has been educational to read your comments on all the images, as a result I think I have a better understanding of "street" photography.
Great simplicity is only won by an intense moment or by years of intelligent effort. T.S Eliot
Gear Not enough!!
PPG
Flickr
My not so new website
Gear Not enough!!
PPG
Flickr
My not so new website
Posted 19/11/2012 - 12:52
Link
Well done David for very well considered judging
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Posted 19/11/2012 - 14:57
Link
Where was your picture taken? Kirkwall or Stromness?
Ken
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
“We must avoid however, snapping away, shooting quickly and without thought, overloading ourselves with unnecessary images that clutter our memory and diminish the clarity of the whole.” - Henri Cartier-Bresson -
Posted 19/11/2012 - 16:03
Link
Noelcmn wrote:
Congratulations ReklawyksEkul-that is a lovely image.
Thanks for judging David.
An honest question? The brief-where the human presence should be prominent- seems to be rather absent from the winning photo. Not that I have a problem with the winning shot, its excellent. It just does not seem to fit the brief. The human element is factually very small ratio-wise to the rest of the street and the buildings.
I half expected someone to ask this question in view of the fact that I criticised a couple of the entries, including your's Noel, for having the figures so small in the frame. The answer is simple. Yes the man in Iqbal's picture occupies a small amount of space but the figure is dominant because he stands out clearly and attracts the eye straight away. There is no complex detail round him to distract attention. The buildings occupy a large amount of space but they are simple and graphic shapes which compliment the subject without overpowering it.Congratulations ReklawyksEkul-that is a lovely image.
Thanks for judging David.
An honest question? The brief-where the human presence should be prominent- seems to be rather absent from the winning photo. Not that I have a problem with the winning shot, its excellent. It just does not seem to fit the brief. The human element is factually very small ratio-wise to the rest of the street and the buildings.
Most succesful photos have clear and simple composition with an instantly recognisable focal point. Iqbal's entry has this quality.
David
PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtrout
Posted 19/11/2012 - 19:58
Link
Well done to Iqbal, great image. well done to everyone else, and thanks to David for superb judging and comments.
Jim.
Jim.
Posted 20/11/2012 - 14:08
Link
Thanks David- Appreciate that.
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


3312 posts
18 years
Durham,
England
Thanks to all who entered this week's competition. I've enjoyed looking through a wide selection of images. Some of these images have given me much pleasure but some others, although valid photographs that might have done well in another type of competition, failed this week because they didn't measure up to my understanding of the rules of street photography. I don't think everyone who entered this week read my comments when I introduced the subject. Tthe most important point I made was that that human presence must be a strong element in the photograph.
PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtrout
What is this life by Tyronet2000
Funny this guy has turned up again Stan. I photographed him not long ago in Northumberland Street, Newcastle. The fact that people are walking out of the frame on the left shows just how crowded this street usually is. The hoarding man certainly seems to have time to stare but I'm wondering what the story line is. I can't see any interaction or tension between him and the pedestrians . It's a shame the guy has virtually got his back to you and what we can see of his face is almost burned out.
Thinking by AndrewA
The fact that its not a street doesn't matter Andrew. The important point is that you've caught someone in a candid situation. Its a story of peaceful contemplation nicely caught. I like the repeating shadows of the park benches.
Millennium Bridge by Sandinista
This is getting spooky. Its another precise spot where I've stood recently (July) doing street scenes. But like the first picture I'm not sure the figures in the scene are adding much of a story. Its a shame the four people bottom left dominate the image. My interest is drawn to the woman with the carrier bag who appears to be turning round to look back at St Paul's Cathedral. I know this a difficult location to get the right arrangement of figures in a picture like this, it's always so busy. I like the photographic treatment you given it with the mono lower half and a very interesting slightly desaturated blue sky.
To Market by Dr Mhuni
This is an excedllent candid shot Andrew. I suspect you've been shooting from the hip and by going in wide and close you've grabbed a really intimate moment. The urgent expression on the woman'sface is superb and I like the catch light in her right eye. It adds a twinkle. The back of the receding figure, bottom left acts as a compositional aid by filling what would otherwise have been dead space.
Passion for Paris by John Riley
This is an original approach and I'm relieved to see that its on the banks of the Seine. I did my Paris street photography mainly around La Defense so its not another case of déjà vu. Its all classic street photography with the subjects caught candidly and showing an interesting variety of poses. I did wonder how candid the first image was because the girl seemed to be waving to you. Close examination of her eyes suggests she's looking slightly to the side and so must be waving at a friend. Lovely quality in all the images.
A wet end to Saturday by Cycler
This is a good illustration of the end of a damp day in a town centre. I love the reflections on the wet pavement and you've caught a variety of figures in various interesting poses. My eye goes straight to who I think is the focal point, the silhouetted figure striding purposefully away, shopping in hand. A good entry for your first time in one of these competitions Keith.
Pop's Corner by Noel cmn
This isn't quite what I had in mind when I set street photography as the subject . Its a street alright but I'm really looking for human interest as the main focal point. While you've captured a very good record of this city corner the tiny figure walking away from the camera, bottom left, and the pedestrian near the white car, bottom right, are so far away they are too small in the frame and don't really bring anything to the theme.
Look by Aliengrove
Still looks pretty vibrant to me Jon. The colours are gorgeous and the image does exactly what I was looking for - human interaction. The eyes of the sitting couple are firmly fixed on the passing girl who seems unaware of their interest or that fact you were taking her picture. Ideal street photography, the observer unobserved.
Bimble by Bettyswolloks
A perfectly caught moment and a picture full of poingancy. This clearly illustrates that people with disabilities often have to face serious obstacles when they go out in buggies or with walking sticks. That pavement would be hazardous for a fully fit person let alone someone trying drive a buggy. The fact that the house wall is not vertical doesn't bother me, this isn't an architectural photograph and the house is merely a backdrop, its not the story.
Love you by Opportunity
A tender moment caught in a scene that fits the bill for the theme of the competition. There may be a sad story line here because he isn't exhibiting as much passsion as his girl. While she flings her arms around his neck he stands woodenly, arms at his side. A couple of minor distractions are in the picture but they could easily be cloned out. These are the distant silhouette vanishing through the arch and the annoying shadow on the edge of the frame centre right. A slight shift in view point to include the full shadows of the lovers would have improved the image.
Street Walkers by Blaze
The eye wanders around this busy sea front scene taking in lots of fine detail. I like the subdued lighting which has resulted in some rather delicate colours. But perhaps there is too much going on for the viewer to single out an obvious story line, one made either obvious or merely implied by the attitude of one or more of the people.
Sale by Gartmore
A street scene all too depressingly common in Uk city and town centres with boarded up shops and others displaying adverts for closing down sales. Ken has decided to include all the street furniture including the forground metal container which could well be an empty ballot box for a police commissioner election.
But what converts this from a documentary image into a genuine street photograph is the group of musicians. The interest, as in all street photography, is in the dominant human presence. The three performers are playing to an empty street, rather like the resident band on the Titantic playing Rock of Ages as the ship sank. I love the shadowy figure of the young person sitting in a deserted doorway.
Who needs mobile phones by Mudge
This is fun and it makes an ironic point. Isthe future of mobile phones in question or is the real question 'Who needs all those phone boxes?' There are many figures in the scene but far from undermining the composition they underline the general lack of interest in public phones. The phone boxes make a great colour pattern.
Street Village by Darlene
There's no dominant figure or group of figures in this colourful scene but the human presence is represented by people scattered along the entire street. Its a very attractive view of an Italian town but I would argue its more of a documentary shot than pure street photography.
Total gridlock by Jim-w
Great capture Jim and there's humour too in the title. The guy on the right whose looking back at the traffic jam is crucial to the composition of this scene - and also he is an essential part of the story line.
Milan by KPATEP
While there's no dominant human presence here the girl's face on the side of the tram makes up for it. She certainly commands attention. I like the way the shape of the tram front is echoed by the white van behind it. It would simple to clone out the distacting half woman in red on the edge of the frame, centre left.
Praying for Dalai Lama by paulb531
The face of the Dalai Lama surrounded by his disciples is the centre of attention in this busy scene in Rome. Unfortunately the banner is fairly small in the frame and the random scattering of the followers on the ground doesn't help pull it all together in a cohesive grouping. As is generally the case in famous locations like Rome the backdrop of tourists rather spoils the effect being sought here.
I'm at a payphone by crazydave 1996
You've spoiled the plot here Crazydave by telling is this is your mate fooling around. First rule of street photography is to catch 'em when they don't expect it and catch 'em acting natural. Otherwise this could have been a genuinely effective street photo with some guy phoning up to order those fries without going anywhere.
Lone Diner by Geordie01
This is a good catch Geordie. She's is lost in thought while waiting for the her chips or coffee to arrive. I wonder how long you lurked outside this cafe or did to snatch this in seconds. Its a good piece of observaton, nicely pulled off.
Walking away by ReklawyksEkul
This is not only a classy street photograph, its also a beautiful image with gorgeous lighting and superb composition. The figure is tiny but he's a very powerul presence because he's perfectly placed in the frame and there's no distracting detail to compete for attention. I love the shapes of the houses and the one brightly coloured house forms an exquisite back drop to the lonely figure. The winding street is delightul and the wet shiny surface made my day. I'm sure this must be be a super place to explore at any time of day.
Devon Cottage by co049
This is a record shot of a fine looking cottage, unfortunately with its chimney chopped off. The image lacks contrast and suffers from dull lighting. Its not what I understand what street photography is about.
Bridge couple by dannyh
The bridge provides a good frame for this couple walking through the scene and you've caught them nicely in mid step so there's no doubt they were moving and not just standing there posing. Its a pity they are so centrally placed.
Results
1 ReklawyksEkul
2 Dr Mhuni
3 Gartmore
HCs: John Riley, Aliengrove, Opportunity, Bettyswollocks