Weekly #843 - A railway station Competition

Title Weekly #843 - A railway station
Judge davidwozhere
Closing Date 12/11/2023
Opting Out If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest.
Description
There must be a lot of archived images out there - or you can take one specially. Pentax cameras or accepted clones only.

Winning Photograph


Competition Entries

Photographs uploaded to the Weekly #843 - A railway station competition.

davidwozhere
Posted 14/11/2023 - 14:14 Link
Sorry for the delay here. I'm presently wearing too many hats and taasks have piled up.


Il était une fois une petite gare by Francisbd
An excellent idea that works admirably. Admittedly, the alignment cannot be made exact but the effect is remarkable.

York's Industrial age masterpiece by davidtrout
The normally apple green or bright blue locomotive in this classic view would stand out from the darkness of the station. The black painted 8F, from a 'foreign' region simply blends in and stands there as if it owns the place. The composition is near perfect and the title tells the story.

Highley Station by johnriley
Another classic shot of a classic traditional station building, albeit on a lesser scale. I think the brillance and time of the day may have conspired against perfection by creating the deep shadow at the bottom left. It does tend to grab one's eye.

Oporto Station by NigelK
More Victorian classical architecture and once more on a grand scale. I had to check to see what the focal length was as the size of the place was clearly challenging. For example, the bit to the left of the clock (central) is identically sized to the bit on the right! A nice balancing of the need for higher ISO to arrest passengers' movement and to stop down sufficiently to get it all focused. The distortions (e.g.ceiling) caused by the wide angle can be forgiven in this instance.

Waiting for the 4:15 by garethjmorgan
That was either set up or it was an excellent bit of opportunism. Either way, it certainly grabs the attention but not, I think, through any merits of the station - even though it is an excellent example of a Great Western 'tin pagoda'!

Going into town by drofmit
Never discount the *istD. A beautiful example of provincial pride in a well exposed and nicely balanced composition.

Grossmont Station Yorkshire by sueriley
I like the treatment of this with its appearance of being a vintage postcard. With appropriate action going on everywhere it was a well timed shot too. The strong perspective lines lead into the image and are stopped by the locomotive at just the right spot and the whole tied together by the signal gantry. A first class composition.

Alresford Station by EricD1306
A pleasing 'diagonal' composition with lots going on, again with an empty space opposite the buildings but, in comparison with "Highley Station" the emptiness is well lit and does not distract from the rest.

Old Station by retsoor
A well exposed (it's a bit dim in there) black and white that is very appropriate for the purported setting. The museum doesn't do it a lot of favours with all the yellow painted lines but the photographer has captured the idea and intention very well.

Waverley by dewsburya
An excellent composition with the major horizontal components set out in almost perfect thirds and balanced at the bottom by the pair of trees. The rail engineer then completed the job with that amazing symmetry of trackwork. Who wouldn't be tempted to point a camera at this? I think I would have played with it a bit to see if I could reduce the aperture while keeping the distance mostly in focus. This would allow a reduction in ISO and would gain a bit more definition towards the bottom. Presently, there is bags of definition in the very extreme distance but less in the foreground - just the opposite of what you see in reality.

Gautrain-Rosebank Station by noelcmn
Well done for achieving that at 1/15th. Pretty challenging lighting down there though.

Newbury at night by RayW
Far kinder lights than in South Africa, they have provided considerable interest of their own with those stars and gentle flares. This would also make a good perspective/ vanishing/ leading lines prospect with everything being terminated by the red lights. The tiny bit of relief from the last light in the sky is pleasant too. It's a very satisfying sort of image. Compare the camera settings and results between this one and "Waverley". ......... can we have a shot of the passing train in the gallery please?

This was headed a railway station and that is the reason that super 8F at York didn't claim top spot - the star is the locomotive rather than the station itself. (Absolutely smashing picture David). The winning image from Oporto is all about the station and its concourse.

1st Oporto Station by NigelK
2nd Newbury at night by RayW
3rd York's Industrial age masterpiece by davidtrout
and HC to Sue Riley.

Nigel, you have more work to do!
Both the *istDS and the K5 are incurably addicted to old glass

My page on Photocrowd
Edited by davidwozhere: 14/11/2023 - 14:24
RayW
Posted 14/11/2023 - 14:26 Link
Thank you for the 2nd place. Newbury looks very different now. The bridge has moved, got higher, and there is OLE knitting everywhere. As you asked, the train I waited for is in the gallery now.
drofmit
Posted 14/11/2023 - 14:33 Link
Thank you for the competition David and congratulations to Nigel... shows the ceramics off wonderfully....
And congrats to Ray, David and Sue!!
Never be afraid to talk about your techniques...
"Give a thousand photographers...
the same camera, lens and scene...
and you'll always get a thousand different takes!!"
Anon.
davidtrout
Posted 14/11/2023 - 15:13 Link
Thanks David for a good subject and well considered judgements. Well done to Nigel and Sue and thanks for my 3rd place. I entirely agree with your comment about my 8F photobombing York station.
David
Nigelk
Posted 14/11/2023 - 15:41 Link
Thank you David for the competition and my top spot. Congratulations to Ray, David and Sue.
The image is I think a 4 photo stitch to try and fit it all in and yes at such close quarters distortion and movement were a challenge.
Posted 14/11/2023 - 17:17 Link
Thanks David, a good competition and judging which looked to be a difficult job with so many good photos. Well done to Nigel for the win and to Ray for second, and to David and Sue.
dewsburya
Posted 14/11/2023 - 19:27 Link
Thank you for a very descriptive critique , I had just upgraded my body from a K20 D to KF , first trip out with the KF , walking to the Edinburgh Tattoo a mere snap shot spotted en route , there is a lot of good criticism here and I take it on board
Thanks for the competition
Congratulations to the placed contributions
Edited by dewsburya: 14/11/2023 - 19:28
Noelcmn
Posted 15/11/2023 - 20:22 Link
Excellent choice of a winner, such a vibrant image, I can just see an artist tackling this for a masterpiece! Congrats Nigel. And congrats extended to Rayw and davidtrout! Not forgetting the HC sueriley. Thanks Davidwozhere for the challenge, judging and C&C's. much appreciated!

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo