Weekly #517 Urban Scene / Landscape Competition
| Title | Weekly #517 Urban Scene / Landscape |
|---|---|
| Judge | mudge | Closing Date | 11/06/2017 | Opting Out | If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest. |
| Description | |
Comp. ends midnight 11th June Rules as usual: ie Only Pentax etc camera, and winner sets and runs next week's comp |
|
Winning Photograph
Competition Entries
Photographs uploaded to the Weekly #517 Urban Scene / Landscape competition.
Posted 12/06/2017 - 02:50
Link
Many thanks Mudge, and congrats to JR, JAK, Mike and David.
Posted 12/06/2017 - 10:01
Link
Well, there's a surprise, it's a while since I won one of these, but I'm pleased it was that shot, especially as it was from the tiny Pentax Q-S1. Set to Bold Monochrome, it gives me just the sort of black and white I spent years in the darkroom trying to perfect.
New competition up in a few moments!
New competition up in a few moments!
Best regards, John
Posted 12/06/2017 - 10:01
Link
Thank you for an enjoyable competition.
Well done to John and the places and HC.
And thank you for your kind comments.
More entries please!
All the best
Well done to John and the places and HC.
And thank you for your kind comments.
More entries please!
All the best
Posted 12/06/2017 - 10:03
Link
That's a great promo for the camera (and the photographer!). Lovely B&W John.
johnriley wrote:
Well, there's a surprise, it's a while since I won one of these, but I'm pleased it was that shot, especially as it was from the tiny Pentax Q-S1. Set to Bold Monochrome, it gives me just the sort of black and white I spent years in the darkroom trying to perfect.
New competition up in a few moments!
Well, there's a surprise, it's a while since I won one of these, but I'm pleased it was that shot, especially as it was from the tiny Pentax Q-S1. Set to Bold Monochrome, it gives me just the sort of black and white I spent years in the darkroom trying to perfect.
New competition up in a few moments!
Posted 12/06/2017 - 10:40
Link
Another interesting weekly competition - why oh why don't more people enter these? In my early days on this Forum it wasn't unusual to get around 40 entries some weeks. You can learn a lot about photography by entering and if you win and have to judge the next one you quickly learn about how to appreciate other people's photos. This makes you more observant and consequently it improves your own photography.
Thanks for the challenge Mudge and for my HC and congrats to the occupants of the podium - especially John.
David
Thanks for the challenge Mudge and for my HC and congrats to the occupants of the podium - especially John.
David
Posted 12/06/2017 - 10:49
Link
Thanks for the second placing and congrats to JR and the other podiums and HCs (that's everyone!)
I did try a cropped version as suggested but it seemed to leave the image unbalanced so went with the original which is the OOC jpeg with sig and border added in Irfanview. The raw file showed significant barrel distortion but given the jpeg was fine i just went with that.
FWIW it was shot from the top of a bus through the bus's window. I spotted the view on the outward journey so was ready to capture it on the return trip.
I did try a cropped version as suggested but it seemed to leave the image unbalanced so went with the original which is the OOC jpeg with sig and border added in Irfanview. The raw file showed significant barrel distortion but given the jpeg was fine i just went with that.
FWIW it was shot from the top of a bus through the bus's window. I spotted the view on the outward journey so was ready to capture it on the return trip.
John K
Posted 12/06/2017 - 13:04
Link
Hi Mudge, thanks for the 3rd place, I'm more than happy with that especially given all the great images entered!
John's BW image is brilliant with so much in it to explore.
Cheers
Mike
John's BW image is brilliant with so much in it to explore.
Cheers
Mike
Posted 12/06/2017 - 17:36
Link
Heavenly Shades---a subject of much debate a short while ago, will not be cropped anytime soon.
Posted 12/06/2017 - 18:17
Link
Forgot to add LOL to my post above.
Posted 12/06/2017 - 20:29
Link
go4IT wrote:
Heavenly Shades---a subject of much debate a short while ago, will not be cropped anytime soon.
A lovely sunset, be a shame to hide it.
Heavenly Shades---a subject of much debate a short while ago, will not be cropped anytime soon.
John K
Posted 12/06/2017 - 22:25
Link
You bet, JAK. The sky and buildings talk to each other and add to each other, methinks.
By the way, I have been very busy, but I meant to comment on your photo, which I very much admire. To me, it has the look and feel of a really good Norman Rockwell painting, especially in the way your people appear. How in heck did you achieve that?
By the way, I have been very busy, but I meant to comment on your photo, which I very much admire. To me, it has the look and feel of a really good Norman Rockwell painting, especially in the way your people appear. How in heck did you achieve that?
Posted 13/06/2017 - 00:09
Link
Quote:
Heavenly Shades---a subject of much debate a short while ago, will not be cropped anytime soon.
I agree! I was just commenting wrt the competiton criteria! LOL
Heavenly Shades---a subject of much debate a short while ago, will not be cropped anytime soon.
Posted 13/06/2017 - 11:56
Link
go4IT wrote:
By the way, I have been very busy, but I meant to comment on your photo, which I very much admire. To me, it has the look and feel of a really good Norman Rockwell painting, especially in the way your people appear. How in heck did you achieve that?
Thanks, didn't do anything special!
By the way, I have been very busy, but I meant to comment on your photo, which I very much admire. To me, it has the look and feel of a really good Norman Rockwell painting, especially in the way your people appear. How in heck did you achieve that?
John K
Add Comment
To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


76 posts
17 years
Morecambe
In the end, I decided on the following placings:-
1st: “The Lucky Building“ by johnriley
2nd: “City Colour“ by JAK
3rd: “Exeter Cathedral Green “ by MikeinDevon
HC: “Potential for development“ by davidtrout
All the rest are Commended!
Nottingham Tram: by Perspicador
An excellent starting image, with a well caught night shot of two passing trams. It shows good detail, considering the difficult light conditions.
The slightly blurred pedestrians add movement to the image.
I found the bright overhead street lights, and the large orange “To Let” sign, tended to draw my eye/attention, as did the top left black area. So, a crop off the top of the image, down to the bottom of the sign, would (in my opinion) improve the image, by focusing attention on the action/interest (ie the trams and pedestrians)
There is also a slight leaning to the right of the buildings and lamp posts
Heavenly Shades of Night are Falling: by go4IT
Another interesting low light scene, with plenty of urban high rise architecture depicted!
The sun lit clouds have been well caught, and nicely sets off the silhouetted buildings.
However, as the dramatic sky takes up more than half the image, and it tends to overpower the buildings/landscape, particularly the bright area at the top lh corner. For the purpose of this competition, cropping off about half of the sky would put more attention back on the buildings themselves
The small aeroplane in the centre is a nice bonus!
Driving Home: by Nigelk
Another nicely caught night scene!
The blurring of the cars etc gives a powerful sense of motion.
I assume it was taken from a car, hence the blurring of the buildings on the rh side
This image would have done particularly well in last week’s competition!
The Lucky Building: by johnriley
This image has immediate impact. Its monochrome quality is first class, with well rendered blacks and whites, and all shades in between.
The amount of detail is amazing, giving plenty to mull over.
Retaining the bit of modern building on the lh side, helps emphasis the age of “The Lucky Building”, which is a nice touch. Most authors would have cut it out!
Pity about the unavoidable post cutting through the centre, but hey, that’s life!
City Colour: by JAK
A really lovely colourful and sharp image, with a nice sprinkling of human interest! And, as you say, a very welcoming sight to the City, if arriving by train. Whilst the scene, in general, has been very well captured, I find the partial lamp post and white sign, on the lh side, a little distracting and would have been tempted to crop them off, had it been my image.
Good Morning Paris: by Mag07
A good shot, with a dramatic sky and sunrise, dominating the image!
The silhouetted Eiffel Tower, is very impressive, but the rest of the landscape is a little small/obscure.
Unlike the previous “Heavenly Shades of Night are Falling” image, a recommendation to crop off some of the sky is not an option, because of the “Tower”!
Cobbles: by davidwozher
Another one from Paris!
It’s a good/interesting pattern shot that has been well seen and captured.
The inclusion of the bottom of the railings and disembodied legs works well, adding life to the image! Perhaps a very slight trim off the top, to removed most of the dominant/distracting brilliant white area behind the post, would slightly improve it
Pictures at an Exhibition: by I-Berg
Another really high quality monochrome shot, with some great detail. However, in this case, in my opinion, there’s actually too much detail to take in, without a focal point to settle on
The disjointed window sections, and diagonal presentation, gives it a very strong initial impact, with an “abstract” feel to it.
Potential for development: by davidtrout
I quite like the initial colour impact of this scene.
In stark contrast to the previous image, this one relies on very simple lines/details, and bright bold colours! A good example of “less is more”
Street Trees Within Urban Jungle: by stephen-s
An interesting interpretation of the theme, with everything except the foreground tree thrown out-of-focus, the latter of which is sharp and colourful!
Its composition is good, with the relevant tree well placed in the top rh corner, allowing a uninterupted view of the of the ghostly background figures
I also like the play on words with the reference to “trees” and “urban jungle”
Town: by Simonmac
Another low light shot, taken at dusk, in Birmingham, when most of the daytime throngs of people have left for home, with just one or two remaining to add some human interest!
At this time of night, there’s still enough natural light to illuminate the buildings sufficiently to successfully record their main detail.
The market lighting has also been well captured, as has the dramatic sky
Diners Club: by Noelcmn
An interesting image with half of it showing a distant view of the Johannesburg Cityscape, and the other half a closeup of the Diners Club, with its window reflections of the City
Exeter Cathedral Green: by MikeinDevon
Last, but not least, this image differs in that it concentrates on the human aspect of an urban landscape. It’s colourful and sharp throughout, and gives the feeling of a lovely summer’s day, with everyone relaxed and enjoying the warm sunny conditions