Monthly Competition #5 - Sell Me Something Competition

Title Monthly Competition #5 - Sell Me Something
Judge GlynM
Closing Date 30/11/2012
Opting Out If you'd like to enter but not keen on creating and judging the following competition you have the option to opt out. If you're selected as the winning photo simply create a report saying that you'd like Admin to take over and we'll do the rest.
Description
Inspired by some of the dreadful pictures some people use to try and sell things on eBay I want you show how it should be done.

To try and make this open though I am not restricting this to a product shot but anything related to selling, from objects, services, food to even concepts and places to stay or visit. I would also be happy to see good examples of others selling and certainly here, with the run-up to Christmas, shop fronts and markets must be brimming over with good examples.

The usual rules apply the picture must have been shot during the period of the competition, from now until midnight on 30th November, using a Pentax, or Samsung equivalent.

Good luck everyone and I look forward with anticipation to seeing your entries.

Glyn

Winning Photograph


Competition Entries

Photographs uploaded to the Monthly Competition #5 - Sell Me Something competition.

GlynM
Posted 01/12/2012 - 00:18 Link
I would like to express my thanks to all of you that entered. In retrospect I think my choice of subject was a bit vague and may have put a few people off. However those that did enter have all exceeded my expectations and it has been a privilege to review your work.

Just a reminder that I'm no expert at this. Everything here is just my personal opinion and the results reflect my personal tastes. I have tried to make useful comments for each entry and hope that I have not upset anyone as this was definitely not my intention. As always it is a terrific collection of images.



Power Advertising – tyronet2000
I think this is a great picture to start off this competition. It captures a type of marketing that now so common that most of us probably ignore it completely.

It is also great to see an entry shot with a compact camera. This has provided a very good depth of field so that we can explore lots of detail in the background including the shop names and expressions on the faces of the shoppers. Perhaps the foreground feels just a little soft but does not distract from the impact of this image.

I think this is a good piece of street photography and well captures these two guys sharing a conversational break from what must be a soul destroying activity.


Marlow Bros MB No 1 Mahogany Field Camera – johnriley
John has provided a great marketing shot that puts many eBay sellers to shame. Not only does it describe exactly what is on offer but is captured in a complementary environment. The table top, probably oak, certainly helps to reinforce the age and quality of this article. The lighting also works really well particularly in the way it is used to highlight the bellows. Perhaps the top left corner where see beyond the edge of the table is little distracting but is probably not worth worrying about for the purpose of the shot.

An excellent eBay product shot which fully meets the theme of the competition.


Crab for tea sir? – davidtrout
I love this picture. It radiates a sense of happiness and fun capturing someone who obviously enjoys their occupation which must help pulling in the customers.

I think it is also great that the subject is wearing a poppy as this provides some context with the month of this competition.

Very nicely composed. I like the way the bowl of the scales dissects the bottom right corner which helps to draw the viewer into the crab and fishmonger. I also like that we get lots of background detail to explore. The capture is also very well executed in what were probably quite challenging lighting conditions.


Show Me The Meats – peteste
A nice detail of a market stall. Great to see that this makes good use of a fast, and probably prime, 50mm lens. This has been used well to lift the subjects away from the background.

It is a nicely composed shot with the hanging rail providing a good straight reference. I like the way the subjects are a mix of heights and that the netting and labels provide some excellent detail. As with any of this sort of shot the lighting was probably a challenge which has been well met.

An interesting detailed and well composed image in challenging circumstances.


On the Rack – bforbes
This shot provides a great splash of colour in a detail of a hanging rail in a clothes shop. It is also for me the first time I have reviewed an image from a Pentax Q.

Certainly the Q has been well mastered allowing the photographer to concentrate on a good composition which includes the challenges of metallic reflections. I like that we have a combination of repeating elements, although all slightly different, and the organised chaos in the background. There are lots of little details to find and the image well captures the tight space requirements needed in selling these items. I love that the hanging rail has a bend in it!

A great colourful image with impact plus lots of detail to explore.


Rendezvous – geordie01
I think this is a lovely image of an aging cafι frontage which works exceptionally well in black and white. The composition is perfect. The paving slabs provide lines drawing the viewer into the image which is emphasised by the diagonal aspect of the cafι frontage. The “ICES” logo provides a wonderful foreground feature creating an immediate entry point for the viewer.

The B&W approach brings out all the details that tells us about the age and decay. Not just the chips in white brickwork but also the cracked paving slabs and wonky wiring.

As an aside I think perhaps you need to sort out the date on your K-30. It appears to be a month out in the exif data although I am happy that, as you have stated, the shot was taken in the month of the competition.

A beautiful example of how to use B&W to portray the history of this aging cafι frontage.


Christmas Time – darlene
Darlene has provided a reminder that Christmas is approaching fast with this image of a seasonal decoration.

Initially I thought the subject was a little lost in the chosen background but when viewed in its larger size comes across much better.

Some bright lighting has brought out the detail and lifted the white and shiny objects. I love the price tag which provides the required selling connection and also gives a hint that it is not in the UK.

A nice little hint of Christmas.


Chocolate Hot Tubs – paulb531
I think a hard crop is well used here to pull the viewer into this inviting food stall while still providing context. The window provides a nice framing effect and the head of the possibly forlorn purveyor comes through from between a couple of flags.

There is nice sharp focus on the frontage and we can read all the signs. Perhaps the depth of field is little shallow and I would have liked to have seen the guy and his bowtie just a little sharper. However I am sure that a good compromise has been made to ensure that in this small establishment a soft background is present to help lift the foreground details.

Hopefully we are just seeing a lull and that this guy was soon busy selling his inviting wares.


Get Some Cider – jim-w
Black and white and some post processing have been well used to add an aging effect to reinforce this image of a cider stall in a Victorian market.

I am not so sure about the composition. While the background cloths provide some great detail I think I would have liked to have seen a bit more of the stall. I can see that it was probably important to capture the jars on the back cloth so perhaps the shot should have been pulled out a bit although this might well have been a challenge in a busy market.

However there are still lots of details for the viewer to explore and the shot captures a wonderful lack of interaction between the seller and prospective customer. I also love the detail provided by the leather jacket of the guy in the foreground.

An interesting and intriguing image with some well-crafted post production.


African Art and Curios – Noelcmn
As I sit and review these pictures outside it is below freezing so it is nice to see a picture from a warm sunny looking place.

Context for the competition is reinforced by the price tag on the bottle in what, for me, is different take on a craft stall. I think this is a well composed and presented image. I like the way we have the tall bottle off centre, on the right, and that the height of the other objects fall away into the picture creating some depth. The depth of field is nicely controlled to soften the background while keeping the foreground subjects sharp. The mix of soft green foliage in the background looks lovely.

A very nice colourful, warming and well-presented image.


Thunderbirds are go...– simonarron
I like this shot depicting a very relaxed way of selling classic cars.

It is a well composed image looking along the line of cars. I like the right-hand placing of the white car in the immediate foreground which creates a good anchor for the line-up. I also like that you captured the big sign which tells the viewer all about the context of this shot. The depth created by the line of cars is nicely reinforced by fence-line in the background and overhead cables on the far left.

I think the light conditions were unfavourable making the colour a little washed-out although no fault of the photographer. In bright sunlight it would probably look stunning. I think I might have been tempted to push up the saturation a little in post-editing to give the image a bit more punch.

I was impressed to see that this was shot with an FA 28-105. I have one of these, bought from new many years ago, which I have not used for ages so I am now temped get it out and try it again. It certainly worked very well in this image.

A well-presented and composed opportunistic shot of an impressive line-up of classic American cars.




I felt it was a good collection of images all approaching the brief from differing directions. They are certainly all very good creating for me a difficult task in picking the winners.

After some careful consideration this is it:

1st – davidtrout for Crab for tea sir? – Because of the fun and happiness that this image inspires.

2nd – geordie01 for Rendezvous – A beautifully crafted B&W image of the frontage of an aging cafe.

3rd – bforbes for On the Rack – For such a great splash of colour and mastery of the Q.


Highly Commended to:
johnriley for such a beautiful example of an eBay product shot

I think this completes my responsibilities here and hand over to David for the next round.

Glyn
Edited by GlynM: 01/12/2012 - 00:19
simonarron
Posted 01/12/2012 - 07:49 Link
Thanks for the prompt, kind words - and compliments to David on a fine winning shot.

And yes, Glyn, you should give the 28-105 another try. It's a light, practical on-the-road companion and acceptably fast.
tyronet2000
Posted 01/12/2012 - 08:01 Link
Congratulations to a worthy winner and to the other placings. Thanks to GlynM for the interesting subject and good judging.
Regards
Stan

PPG
johnriley
Posted 01/12/2012 - 09:45 Link
Many thanks indeed for the prompt and quality judging!

Congrats to all the winners also - our winning photographer is consistently excellent and does it again!
Best regards, John
davidtrout
Posted 01/12/2012 - 10:45 Link
OMG. I didn't se this one coming but thanks Glyn and my congratulations to George and Barrie too. It looks like a Geordie wipe out this month with the entire population of the podium coming from Co.Durham and Northumberland. Congratualtions also to John for his HC
Its a pity there weren't more entries Glyn, I thought it an excellent idea for a comp.
David

PS: I'll be along later today with a theme for December.


PPG: http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/davidtrout
Edited by davidtrout: 01/12/2012 - 10:50
geordie01
Posted 01/12/2012 - 12:47 Link
Howay the lads.
Thanks for the 2nd place Glyn and congrats to David on the win Barrie for the 3rd. Some great entries this month.
Date now sorted on k-30Only had it a couple of weeks honest
bforbes
Posted 01/12/2012 - 13:24 Link
Congratulations David and George, I'm glad to be in such prestigious company.

Thanks Glyn for your very detailed judging.

I'd hoped, when we switched to a monthly competition, entries would increase. It does not seem to have worked and I don't think it's any reflection on your choice of subject.
Jim-w
Posted 01/12/2012 - 19:35 Link
Thanks to Glyn for the comp and judging.
Well done to David and other places.

Jim.
darlene
Posted 03/12/2012 - 17:43 Link
Congratulations David Thanks Glyn for your very detailed judging.

Add Comment

To leave a comment - Log in to Pentax User or create a new account.


Proudly supporting Pentax User

Samsung Logo Asahi Pentax Logo