Colour or B&W (again)....


LennyBloke

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 09:30
A couple of shots that I spent some time messing about with - deciding whether colour or black & white suited them better - from my final images it appears that my preference when outputting as colour is to go for slightly lower contrast, while the monochromes are more contrasty.

What do you think?














LennyBloke

Benz3ne

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 09:45
For these two subjects, I'm personally preferring the B&W versions. They've got a little more 'pop' to them, though subdued colours are 'up my street' too, so to speak.

I think the added contrast gives better separation between 'patterned' shots like these, and helps the wood stand out in the 2nd shot against the darker background in that example.

Regardless, I'm absolutely inexperienced so my word means absolutely nothing from a technical standpoint. Lovely in all instances, J.

Jumbo48

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 09:49
I like the black and white ones they seem to show more detail I think, but then I do like black and white pictures.
Regards John/Jumbo

swarf

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 11:58
B&W for me - personally I think that both subjects are better suited to monochrome than colour.

Phil
K-5iiS; K-r; ME Super; ME; DA* 16-50 f2.8; DA 18-135 WR; DA 55-300 WR; HD DA 15mm F4 ED AL Limited; FA 50mm f1.4; A50mm f1.7; DAL 18-55mm; M40mm f2.8; + assorted non-Pentax lenses

My Flikr Page link

bforbes

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 12:25
Black and white for me. I don't think there is enough strength of colour in the subjects
Barrie
Too Old To Die Young

http://www.pentaxphotogallery.com/artists/barrieforbes
https://www.flickr.com/photos/189482630@N03/

Nigelk

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 12:26
B&W for both is my vote

pschlute

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 14:33
Agreeing with the majority.....b+w
Peter



My Flickr page

PRYorkshire

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 15:00
Definitely better in black and white. Good contrast gives a more textured feel to both.
Paul

K1000, istD, K70

cardiffgareth

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 17:43
Agree the monochrome suits best. In the rocks it helps the eye to ponder around the frame. My eyes make more sense of the chaos and see the symmetry, lines, texture and shapes better.
Gareth
Welsh Photographer

My outfit: K1 gripped - Pentax D FA 24-70mm - Sigma 70-200mm OS HSM - Pentax modified DA* 60-250mm f4 - Irix 15mm Firefly - Pentax FA 35mm - FA 50mm - Tamron SP 90mm macro - Pentax AF 540 FGZ II

My Flickr
My PPG
My 500px

Marselus

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 20:18
Colour would be fine too but the post processing must be a little bit more overdone.
Than it could look not as it really is but there are no borders in photography.

alfpics

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 20:52
Also agree monochrome works best; however, if the stones had been wet, they might well have 'exuded' more vibrancy...
Andy

Sry

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 22:31
Also in favour of b+w, as they stand. The colours might bring something different in an interesting way, but would probably need another processing approach (or maybe, as Andy says above, if there were more wetness involved...).
Anyway, good shooting (and processing)

alfpics

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 23:11
alfpics wrote:
Also agree monochrome works best; however, if the stones had been wet, they might well have 'exuded' more vibrancy...

An eg here where I deliberately poured water on a group of the stones;


(not wanting to hi-jack lennyblokes thread)
Andy

HarisF1

Link Posted 20/11/2019 - 23:22
Good point above.

If John had wet the stones then I think his colour image would have looked nicer than the subsequent mono. Despite this, I still think the original mono has an appeal that would be difficult to reproduce in colour.
Last Edited by HarisF1 on 20/11/2019 - 23:22

Mike-P

Link Posted 21/11/2019 - 08:49
Just to be different I have to say I prefer the mono images, they definitely have more "pop" than the colour.
. My Flickr
Add a Comment
You must be registered or logged-in to comment.